Page 42 of Theirs

“Fuuuuck,” I scream, letting my head fall back on the pillow and squeezing my eyes shut.

“So fucking pretty,” Colin says, awe in his voice. I open my eyes to find him staring down at me. Hunger in his eyes. Ben comes up and looks at me as well, his smiling mouth covered in my orgasm.

“Fucking beautiful, Lav,” he says. I crunch up to crush my lips against him, tasting myself on his tongue.

“Tear me apart,” I whisper against his mouth. “I need you both. Please.”

“Baby,” Colin says beside us. “Are you sure you’re ready for that?”

“I trust you to get me ready for that,” I smile, lying back on the bed and pulling Colin down to kiss my lips.

Colin groans when he tastes my pleasure on my lips.

“Get on top of Ben,” he tells me.

Ben trades me spaces on the bed, lying down. I straddle his hips and he reaches into his nightstand, handing Colin a bottle of lube. I hear the cap crack open, and I’m shivering in anticipation. Colin bends over me and places a kiss on my shoulder blade.

“Oh, wait...” Ben says, reaching for some folded paper on his nightstand. “I forgot, the guys and I have something for you.”

I take the papers from him, and unfold them, looking over the medical document. At the top of each page is the name and birthdate and other information on each of my boyfriends, followed by some test results.

“Is this what I think it is?” I ask, arching a brow.

Ben nods. “We all got tested for you, Lav. We’re clean, and we’re yours.”

I smile and lean down to place a kiss on his lips before putting the papers back on the nightstand. We don’t bother grabbing the box of condoms inside. I get to feel all of Ben and Colin tonight.

“I want you to ride Ben,” Colin whispers in my ear. “Just relax, and have fun. I’ll get you ready. Don’t worry.”

Colin runs his hand down my spine, and I reach down between Ben and I position his cock at my entrance. He smiles up at me, and places his hands on my hips. I shiver as their hands touch my soft skin, four hands, two sets of eyes watching me as I sink down on Ben’s shaft.

“Good girl,” Colin praises from behind me, as Ben moves his hands to my ass to help me lift up and down on his hard cock. “You look so fucking good from every angle, but next time, I want you on top of me.”

I look at him over my shoulder, and smile as I fuck Ben. “I like when you talk to me.”

He moves close enough to kiss me. “Yeah? You like the dirty talk?”

I moan and nod. “Yes. God, yes.”

He chuckles, and pulls away. “If only you could see yourself from here, milking Ben’s cock, your first orgasm coating him. Maybe we should install some mirrors in here, I want you to see this, I want you both to see this.”

“Colin,” I moan, pressing my hands to Ben’s chest to support my body. “I’m so close. I need you inside me.”

Colin presses a hand to my back, and urges me to lie down on Ben. Ben takes my bottom lip between his, and his tongue licks along it. I tense when I feel some of the lubricant drizzled on my ass, but Ben holds my face to his, and starts thrusting his hips up when my movement stills.

I can’t concentrate on Ben while I’m waiting for Colin to join his body with ours. I’m scared, but I’m also excited beyond belief. I’ve never done anything like this, I’ve never had a guy claim my ass, I’ve never had two guys filling me up.

I feel something cold press against my tight hole. Colin uses his finger to lube the entrance.

“We’re going to go slow, okay?” Colin asks, and Ben slows his thrusts.

“Colin,” I pant. “Please.”

He pushes his finger in, it feels strange, but I think I like it. He only thrusts it into what’s probably his second knuckle before pulling it back out. I know we should go slow, but I need him so badly. As he’s about to push it back in, I don’t let him stop at the knuckle, I push back on him, taking his finger all the way in. I know it’s not much; we’ve got a long way to go before he has me completely prepared to take in his cock, but I’m not patient.

“Baby, I don’t want to hurt you,” Colin says, placing his other hand gently on my back. “We have to take it easy.”

“Please, Colin,” I plead, riding Ben and fucking my ass on Colin’s finger. “I need you inside of me.”

---