Page 43 of Theirs

“When you can take three fingers, I’ll put my cock in your ass,” Colin promises, pulling his finger out to press two against my tight hole.

Okay, two is a lot more than one. I whimper as he thrusts those two digits inside of me. Maybe I won’t be ready to have them both at the same time. Colin’s girth is way bigger than two fingers.

Colin doesn’t move once both fingers are inside me, he just lets me get over the discomfort. Ben has completely stopped his thrusts, both men patiently waiting for me to get accustomed to the feeling. I have no clue how Ben is holding it together right now; I feel like I’m going to combust.

“We’re not going to move,” Colin says, his voice gravelly. “Baby, take what you can. Do what you need to do and when you’re ready, I’ll add the third finger.”

I nod my head in understanding, they want me to take control, even though it feels like Colin is the one pulling the strings. After a moment, I lift up just enough to start riding Ben, pressing my ass onto Colin’s fingers.

“That’s it,” Colin praises. “Look at you, you’re doing so good, baby.”

“Lav, you’re so damn beautiful,” Ben adds. “So damn tight, you’re going to be almost unbearably tight when Colin puts his cock in your tight little ass.”

Their words give me enough encouragement to keep going, to keep preparing myself for Colin. I finally feel like I’m ready, and ask Colin to add the final finger he promised me. He removes the two from me, and I hear him add some lube before he presses them back to my asshole. I don’t wait for him to move them in slowly, I thrust back onto them as soon as I feel them at the rim.

“Oh, fuck!” I scream.

“You okay, Lav?” Ben asks as Colin almost removes the three from me.

I look over my shoulder, gritting my teeth at Colin. “Don’t you dare take those out of me. I’m so fucking close again.”

He pushes them back in and I arch my back.

“Yes!” I pant, and begin frantically riding Ben. There’s zero tempo in my thrusts, I’m just trying to get the orgasm out as quickly as possible. I have zero shame in that moment as I stare down at Ben. I have no idea how he hasn’t cum yet, I’m losing my damn mind right now.

“That’s it, Lavender,” Ben urges, placing both his hands on my breasts, tugging on my pierced nipples. “Let me feel that pussy constrict my cock, baby.”

That’s all it takes. I moan and whimper as I feel warmth pool in my belly, my thighs tighten as the pleasure leaves my body. I’m not sure if I’ve ever cum so hard before, but then again, I also didn’t know that I could get off by praises and dirty talk or having my ass filled.

“Colin,” I gasp, riding out the last of my orgasm. “I need you in me now. Please, fuck my ass.”

Colin pulls out his fingers, and I hear the cap of the lube open again, followed by Colin stroking his cock three times, covering himself in the lube. His tip meets the entrance of my ass, and he bends to place a kiss at the tip of my spine.

“Tell me if you need me to slow down, go easy, or stop,” Colin demands. “I don’t want to hurt you, I just want to make you feel good.”

I nod frantically, and bite my bottom lip as I feel him slide slowly inside me. He’s way bigger than three fingers, but I’m grateful that he took his time stretching me just enough. I don’t even want to know how painful this would be if I were with someone careless who just wanted to fuck and leave. Someone who didn’t care if it hurt or felt good to me.

Ben and I don’t move as Colin stretches my ass with his cock. Ben just smoothes his hand over my cheek and keeps whispering words of encouragement, but I can’t make out everything he’s saying because I’m distracted by the pleasure pain that Colin is causing. I want him to stop, but I also want him to keep going, keep spreading me. I want him to fill me up, and that’s exactly what he does.

“You okay, Teagan?” Colin asks, once the both of them are finally deep inside me. “Are you ready?”

“Yes,” I say. “Please, Colin. Ben. I want you both to fill me with your cum.”

I don’t have to say another word. Both men instantly begin moving in and out of me. Somehow, they both keep up the same speed, when one of them pulls out, the other slides in, they keep up that pattern, their hips never stuttering. Moans escape my lips, and I stay hovering over Ben, afraid to move an inch and ruin the steady pace.

“Holy shit, Lav,” Ben says. “I can feel him inside you.”

“Do you like it?” I whisper, trying my best to sound seductive.

“Hell yeah, I like it,” Ben says, his hands squeezing my hips. “It feels so fucking good. Does it feel good to you?”

“Mmhmm,” I whimper in agreement. “I’ve never felt so full, so connected.”

“I’m not going to be able to last much longer,” Colin warns from behind me. “This feels too damn good, Tea. You were made for us.”

“I second that,” Ben says.

I shake my head. “I don’t give a damn how long you guys last right now. I want your cum, fuck me until you cum!”

---