Page 124 of You Were Always Mine
I don’t move my fingers. I curl them harder inside her. My jaw locks so tight it hurts as I lift my head slowly, meeting him over her shoulder.
Scar’s whisper cracks against my ear, broken, pleading: “Kai…”
And Tyler smirks like he knows exactly what I’m doing under the table.
Her nails dig crescents into my shoulders, but I don’t move. My fingers stay buried in her, pressing, curling, making her twitch even as she’s frozen stiff. The music pounds, the lights flash, but all I see is him.
Tyler leans an elbow against the booth, casual, smug, like he isn’t standing three seconds from his own funeral. “Didn’t know you two liked to… share.” His eyes flick to Scar’s face—her wide, guilty stare—then drop to her body on my lap. “Guess big brother’s not so protective after all.”
Scar shakes her head, whispering, “Please, Kai,” like she thinks I’ll pull away. Like I could.
I push deeper instead, slow and deliberate, and watch her gasp. “Smile for him, Scar,” I murmur against her ear, cruel and soft. “Don’t let him see how fucking wrecked you are on my hand.”
Her lip trembles. She can’t look at me.
Tyler chuckles, low and mean. “She doesn’t look like she’s enjoying herself, man. Maybe let her up before she embarrasses you.”
I stroke harder, just once, making her whimper into my neck. My other arm locks tighter around her waist, pinning her there, keeping her trembling on my lap where she belongs.
I meet his gaze, calm, deadly calm. “You should walk away, Tyler.”
Scar stifles a sob against my skin, but I don’t loosen my grip. Not yet.
Scar’s thighs clamp around my hand like she can trap the shame inside her, but my fingers don’t stop. They work her slow and cruel, sliding against the heat she’s trying so hard to hide. I keep her pinned, keep her trembling, her pulse hammering against my chest.
Tyler smirks as if he owns the room. Like he isn’t already dead.
“Funny,” he says, sipping his drink like he’s got all the time in the world, “she told me once she wanted something real. Not some dirty secret. Guess she lied to me too, huh?”
Scar stiffens, her breath hitching, and I feel her nails bite through my shirt. She’s trying not to break in front of him, trying not to whimper, but my fingers curl deeperand she can’t hold it—her body jerks, a muffled sob swallowed against my neck.
He leans in a little closer, voice dripping poison.
“What’s it like, Kai? Having her look at you like that? Like she’s disgusted but still lets you touch her. Pathetic.”
Scar shakes her head, whispering, “Please stop,” but it’s not to him. It’s to me.
I drag my fingers out slowly, slick, and shove them back inside her, hard enough she gasps against my ear. My lips brush her hairline.
“Don’t give him the fucking satisfaction,” I whisper. “Stay quiet for me, Scar.”
Her whole body trembles, but she obeys.
Tyler chuckles, eyes narrowing. “Yeah, keep hiding behind him. That’s what sluts do. Bet you begged for it, didn’t you?”
My jaw cracks. I keep my hand working inside her, steady, merciless, like every thrust is a vow. My voice is a razor when I finally answer him.
“One more word out of your mouth, Tyler, and I swear you’ll choke on it.”
She’s trembling like she might shatter, thighs clamping tight around my hand, but I don’t stop. I curl my fingers deeper, knuckles brushing against the heat of her, slow and deliberate, grinding the heel of my palm into her clit until she’s choking on a moan.
Tyler’s grin spreads wider as he leans down, voice low enough to slice. “Look at you, Scar. Thought you were a good girl. But here you are, dripping in his lap. Bet he makes you say please, doesn’t he?”
Scar shakes her head, frantic, burying her face in my neck. She’s seconds from coming undone and terrified he’ll see. Perfect.
I drive my fingers harder, cruel, holding her pinned so she can’t escape the proof. Her body jerks, nails scraping down my chest. She’s whispering, broken: “Kai… please…”
Tyler laughs, shaking his head like it’s a joke. “Guess I hit a nerve. Careful, Scar, one of these days the entire world’s gonna know exactly what you two are doing.”
