Page 69 of My Ex-Best Friends

She grinned, the smile stretching wide and making her eyes crinkle in the corners. “Fell asleep on the beach. Woke up to a seagull on my forehead and Lucy snapping at it. This was its last act before Lucy inhaled it.”

Noah inched closer to her. “Are you okay?”

“I was coming over. Before Logan showed up. It’s a whole thing. I’m sunburnt on half of my body and-”

“You’re dressed just like that night.” I ran my hand down my face and fought to stay calm. “The only thing missing is you needing a place to stay for the night.”

She crawled closer to me. “Mom kicked me out. She said I had a perfectly good home waiting on me and she was tired of listening to me mope around.”

I pushed her wet hair behind her ears and held her gaze. “You’re ours. Your crazy aunt has been right all along. You’re going to marry us and we’re going to have a fuck ton of kids,enough to fill our teams. We’re never letting you go again, Brooke.”

She licked a raindrop from her lip and gripped my forearms. “I had to do the asking for you three to touch me the first time around. I’m not accepting less than a proper proposal if you want to marry me.”

“You can have whatever you want.” I cupped the sides of her face and then slid my hands down to hold the sides of her neck. Running my thumb over her pulse at the hollow of her throat, I searched her gaze. “Just say that you’re ours.”

“I’m yours.” She glanced back at Logan and then at Noah. “I’m each of yours. I never want to be without you again.”

“Then you won’t.” I wanted to pin her down and take her so hard she’d never forget where she belonged but I forced myself to move slowly closer to her. Just like the first time. “If we do this, I’m always going to know what your tits look like. I’ll always want to see them again.”

Her lips parted as I said the same words to her that I’d said a decade earlier. Just as I started to wonder if she remembered how she’d responded to me that night, she smiled and grabbed the bottom of her tank top. “Maybe I’ll always want to show you.”

The rest of the world ceased to exist as she pulled her top over her head and tossed it aside. Her bare breasts stood proudly, her hard nipples jutting out at me. The normally pale pink tone of them was darker, flushed with blood rushing to them. They begged for attention, but just like that first time, I waited.

“Well?” She wasn’t nervous like the first time she’d asked that. “Do you like them?”

Thunder clapped outside as I moved closer. I leaned down and let my breath dust over her nipples. “I’ve never seen hotter tits, Brooke. Jesus. I’ve always imagined but…”

“You’ve imagined them?” Her chest rose and fell faster. “You can… You can touch them.”

I wasn’t shaky like I was that night. I cupped her breasts and stroked my thumbs over her nipples, loving the breathy little moan she let out. I deviated from the script for the truth. “All the time. And every day since then. Lay down, Brooke.”

“Do you want me to take off my bottoms?” She stretched out between us, her sweet expression almost angelic as she watched me nod. Then she reached down and gripped the top of her shorts. “Help me?”

I moved so I was kneeling at her side. Taking her shorts, I slowly pulled them down her thighs, over her knees, and past her calves. Once she was bare, she pressed her knees together and stared up at me with her lip caught between her teeth.

I took over, not needing her help remembering every single word we spoke. “I laid beside you and rested my hand on your stomach. I could feel how nervous you were. I suddenly felt like a bumbling idiot. I knew what I wanted but I was terrified I’d do something wrong and you’d sprint out of here. I asked if I could kiss you and you giggled. You thought it was silly because you were already naked. What I didn’t tell you was that I’d been dreaming of kissing you for as long as I could remember and it felt as significant as taking your virginity. I knew that tasting your lips was a line and once I crossed it, I’d never want to go back.”

She let her hand trail into my hair when I laid next to her and leaned over. She tipped her head back, offered me her lips, and smiled. “Once you kissed me, I understood.”

I pressed my lips to hers and let out a guttural sound of pleasure. She was as soft and minty as the first time and every time since. My fingers tightened over her stomach as I deepened the kiss, stroking my tongue against hers and tasting her. Her legs eased apart the longer I kissed her and I could feel her startto move her hips, the need getting to her. She wasn’t shy like she’d been the first time. She embraced her desire and moaned my name against my lips.

I stroked my hand down to her sex and listened to the sweet sounds of her moans as I trailed my fingertips over her wetness and then parted her lips to find her clit. Her hips bucked when I did and I rushed the memory to get my fingers inside her. I stroked one and then two fingers into her wet heat and buried my face into her chest.

“This is when Noah and Logan came in. You got wetter when they watched. Just like me saying their names just made your pussy grip my fingers tighter.” I sucked her nipple and then let it pop out of my mouth before raising my eyes to hers. “You were made for us. Spread your legs wider, Brooke. I’m going to fuck you just like you so sweetly asked.”

56

***Brooke***

Ispread my legs and moaned at the feeling of Colt’s big body settling between them. I reached over and grabbed Noah’s hand as Colt gripped my hips and slid himself deep into me. Gasping, I lifted my legs and wrapped them around his body. “Colt.”

He slowly pulled out and eased back in. His eyes were narrowed as he watched me and thrust like he had all the time in the world. “You came like this the first time.”

He dipped his head and sucked at my nipples while continuing his slow thrusts. He was right and just like the first time, my first orgasm came fast. He kissed me hard and then pulled out. I didn’t even catch my breath before he had me flipped over on all fours. I was scandalized the first night but I was older and wiser and knew that sex like that hit something special inside me and lit me up like the fourth of July.

Noah and Logan had stripped and Noah didn’t hesitate to move in front of me in the new position. Just like the first time, Ididn’t hesitate to open my mouth and take his cock in. It’d never crossed my mind that most people didn’t lose their virginity that way. It just felt…right.

Noah pushed my hair out of my face and stroked my cheeks while I sucked him. His eyes rolled when one of Colt’s strokes pushed me deeper on his length. He reached forward and cupped my breasts, stroking my nipples while I stroked his cock. It quickly became too much for me to handle and when Colt’s fingers found my clit, I came hard.

---