A mutinous look shimmered a split second before she grew limp in Alexander’s arms. “I trust you.”
Ethan sat behind Alexander. He watched with a rabid intensity that I knew meant he was cataloging her every sigh and whimper. By the time we left this room, he would know everything that made Clara excited, which parts of her were the most sensitive. We all were beginning to understand the things she liked and what pushed her over the edge.
“You said you wanted all three of us.” Alexander brushed a kiss over the tip of her nose. “We’re going to try something different first.”
“Different?” She rubbed her legs together in a move I realized meant she missed the feel of me inside her. I almost said screw the plan and impaled her with my cock, but a look from Alexander stopped me in my tracks.
He turned her around to face me. “Stand up.”
We all moved together. Clara ended up in the middle of us all. I stood in front, Alexander behind, and Ethan closing the gap on her right.
“We’re going to fuck you one at a time. Slowly. While you stand there with your eyes closed. I want you to feel everything.” I traced the curve of her cheek with one finger, moving from her cheek to her eyes. “Let us take you somewhere new.”
“I’m not a bystander.” That look returned in full force.
I grinned when she nipped at my finger. “We don’t expect you to be. It’s just something different.”
She huffed but closed her eyes.
Ethan and I traded places. Alexander braced her from behind. “Open for us, Clara.” He rubbed both hands down her stomach and over her thighs. The instant she spread her legs wide enough, Ethan guided his cock into her.
Her eyes shot open even as her head fell back.
Alexander kissed the side of her neck. “Feel that? Do you feel how hard you make us?” His cock was nestled between her ass cheeks, and Ethan stroked deep in a single, slow pulse.
We’d wondered how this worked with all three of us. Maybe we didn’t have it all figured out, but as long as we made Clara happy, I’d be fucked if I cared about anything else.
Clara dug her nails into Ethan’s shoulders. Her legs went weak, which was why Alexander and I stayed close. We braced her up. Ethan quickened his pace, each thrust pushing her closer.
“How long do you plan to do this?” she asked.
I couldn’t tear my eyes away from the blissful look on her face. “As long as you can stand it.”
“I’m pretty resilient.” A smile shot out. “Oh fuck. Not if you keep doing that.”
Ethan pulled out, and he and Alexander swapped places. Alexander teased her clit with his cock, adding pressure when her knees trembled. “That’s why we’re doing this.” He lifted her right leg over his arm and thrust deep. “You’re ready to come, aren’t you.” It wasn’t a question, but she nodded. “You will, but not yet. When you come, it’s going to be the best you’ve ever had.”
“You can’t keep making it better every time. There has to be a breaking point.” Even as she argued, her body tensed on the precipice.
Alexander stopped moving, then withdrew to the tip. She tried to take him back, but he held her leg steady and Ethan and I helped him keep her still. “We can try,” was all he said as he slid slowly back into her.
He pumped into her in a series of quick thrusts, then backed away and lowered her leg to the floor.
“This is torture.” Eyes squeezed tight, she reached a hand between her legs. “I can’t hold on. I need to come. I’m on fire, and if you don’t put me out of my misery, I’m going to go insane. Let me come or I’ll do it myself.”
She damn well would. The woman was stubborn as hell.
The three of us grinned at each other. “Okay.” I took her hands and locked them behind my neck. “Hold on to me. You’re going to need the support.” I slid my cock into her. She immediately clenched her walls and locked down on my cock. “That’s it.” I made a few languid thrusts, stoking her heat. “Now let Alexander in your ass. We’re going to make you come.”
She brought our lips together in a fierce kiss, then whispered in my ear. “I want you to come too.” Once she had my agreement, she stretched one hand back and hooked it around the back of Alexander’s neck. “You can’t come yet, Alexander. Liam is going to, but you and Ethan have to wait a little longer.”
I used her distraction and changed my pace, working my cock faster and deeper. “You’re asking a lot of Alexander. Poor man.” My lips stretched in a smile I’d copied from him during some of our worst meetings. It said I didn’t feel the least bit sorry for him.
“That’s okay, Clara. Whatever you want.” He caught the rhythm I’d set up and eased into her ass.
“I’ll never get used to that.” She sucked a heaving gasp through tightly pressed lips. “The two of you inside me is fucking amazing. I feel you both so deep.”
I felt it too. Every stroke of my cock in her pussy brought me up against Alexander’s dick through the thin wall separating us. I’d never felt anything like it. If anyone had ever asked, I would have thought it strange, but not anymore. Clara sank her teeth into the curve of my shoulder.