Turning my head, I stared into her sparkling hazel eyes. Her face was set like flint. “Sins, no. I’m telling you no.”
“And I’m telling you yes.” I had no retort. “I’m going to do it. I could eat pussy, I think. Is that what she wants?”
“I can’t discuss this with you.” The nausea was hitting me again. What was worse was that someone like Mason would call me a fool for trying to talk my girlfriend out of a threesome. But this wouldn’t be like well-produced studio porn. It would be nasty, homemade creepy porn with terrible lighting. It would be my dream girl with my worst nightmare.
“Well, we should. I got tested last week for STDs. I am clean. How long have you been having sex with her?”
“I never fucked her without a condom. She’s been threatening me for months, but I’d never stick my raw dick inside her. I would never do that to you, Kinsley.”
“Well, there’s that. Good.” Kinsley turned in her seat, angling her body towards me.
Grabbing her hand on the console, I pleaded, “Sins, I never wanted to have sex with her. I’m sorry. I should have told you sooner, but… I thought I could let you go and then it wouldn’t matter. If I—”
“I get it, George. She’s forcing you into this. But now we have to fix the issue.”
“You’re the bravest fucking person I know.” She was. Kinsley was brave and forthright, and sharp as a whip. So was her tongue. But she also had no sense of self-preservation. “Even if you agree, Gianna could just force me to do it again some other time.”
“I’m not stupid, George. I’ve already thought of that.”
It dawned on me that Kinsley was strategizing a secret plan. “No. Sins. Whatever youthinkyou can pull on her, don’t. It will end worse for you.”
A little vindictive smile crept across her face. I’d seen that look after she would prank me. “Or it could end worse forher. She can’t get away with being a sexual predator and trying to ruin my boyfriend’s life.” Even from my peripheral vision, I caught her swallow thickly.
“How would you feel seeing her and I together?” I asked.
She hesitated before she spoke. “Seeing you and her? Having sex?” I waited as she considered her answer. “Sick. Angry. Jealous… And also aroused.”
“Yeah. I’d feel the same way.” Thinking about it just made my stomach feel like I’d swallowed batteries. I didn’t want to share my girlfriend. Especially not with Gianna. Being with my ex-stepmother always made me feel confused, sick, like I was broken and dirty. It was my personal hell and I didn’t want to drag the love of my life into that pit with me. “Sins, I don’t want you to do this.”
“Too bad. I’m doing it. We are getting you out of this mess so we can be together, and so we can give that bitch what she deserves. Let’s talk rules.” We had reached her apartment and were sitting in the lot. “But first, I’m starving and need hot cocoa. Come up?”
“It’s late, not sure how you can sneak a body like mine inside the girl’s dorm.”
“I know Mary at the front desk. You’ll be fine.”
“Stay right there,” I said with authority as she put her hand on the door. Jumping out, I walked around to her side, and grabbed her so her legs surrounded my waist as she clutched my neck with her arms. It was our position.
Mary didn’t say a thing to us when I carried Kinsley past the front desk. When she lifted her eyes in a question, Kinsley quickly explained I was helping her after an accident.
Dropping my girlfriend onto her bed, I pointed to her dresser. “PJs?” She told me which drawer to find them in. I got a glance at her colorful underthings, which made me oddly excited, like I was a twelve-year-old boy again. I handed her the T-shirt she asked for.
“I can walk, you know.” Standing, she pulled off her leggings. Watching her undress made my dick twitch, but I willed it to calm down. She may not be ready to get reacquainted after what happened. I was still in shock that she was even talking to me. When she walked into her bathroom, I perched lightly on her bed, but she beckoned me through the open door with a finger. “I have an extra toothbrush. Come on.”
“Y-you want me to stay?”
“Yes, of course.”
We brushed our teeth like an old married couple, and my skin burned hotter than ever. It was such a simple thing that I never knew I was missing until it happened. Now I wanted it every night. She eyed me in the mirror and spat out her toothpaste, rinsing her mouth. I followed behind her. “Kinsley,” I said as we returned to her room.
“Take off your shirt and pants. Come to bed with me. We need to talk about a plan.”
“Kinsley. What are you doing? You were ready to cut me yesterday. Now, suddenly, you’re okay with me being your boyfriend. A boyfriend that’s fucking his stepmother?”
She sighed. “No. I’m not okay with it.”
My heart stopped.
She quickly said, “I don’t want her in your life. George, she’s an abuser.She’sthe problem here. You were trying to save your family, and I think that’s noble, albeit I think you’re taking on way too much responsibility.” Propping herself against some pillows, she sat up in her bed. “Yourproblem was pushing me away. I want to show you how great of a team we can make when we join our brilliant minds.” She held her hand out to me. “We can figure this out…together.” When I still didn’t move, she patted the bed. “Now, strip Big G, and get the fuck in the bed with me.”