Page 70 of Rewrite Our Story

I stop at the same moment she pulls her mouth off me. My cock throbs, already missing her mouth wrapped around it. It jolts at the thought of going from her warm mouth to her sweet pussy.

“Oh my god,” Mare pants. She slides to my side, her head falling next to mine on the pillow.

Our sides press against one another as I inch my mouth closer to hers. “Did you like fucking my face, baby?”

She bites her lip and nods. “I didn’t know I’d like it so much.”

My thumb brushes over her cheekbone. Her lips are red and puffy from stretching around me. It’s the hottest fucking sight mixed with the flush to her cheeks from her orgasm.

“Which part? My face buried in your pussy or you gagging on my cock? Taking me as deep as you can?”

“Taking you,” she answers, pressing a kiss to my lips. “Or maybe both.”

I laugh. “Good answer.”

“Cade?”

“Yeah, baby?”

“I’m ready.”

“Ready for what?”

“Ready for you to fuck me.”

She sounds so innocent, saying such filthy words.

I slide off the bed for a moment, fishing a condom out of my wallet. I hadn’t expected for things to happen tonight, but with how much Mare has been saying she wants me to be the one to take her virginity, I wanted to be ready just in case.

Using my teeth, I rip open the wrapper and pull out the condom. We make eye contact as I slide it on. She watches me hungrily. Her breaths are heavy as her thighs rub together for some relief.

She’s the most beautiful thing I’ve ever seen. I don’t take it lightly that somehow she’s chosen me for her first time. I don’t think I’ll ever deserve it, but fuck, I rage with jealousy at the thought of anyone else ever seeing her like this.

Climbing onto the bed, I settle between her legs. She’s so wet that there’s paths of wetness down her inner thighs where she’s dripped with pleasure.

Mare watches closely as I pump up and down on my shaft, making sure the condom is well-fitted.

“You sure about this?” I’m desperate for her, to know that I’m the only man to ever do this, but I’d wait forever if she needed me to. I want her to be confident in giving me this.

“I’ve always wanted it to be you. I’ve never been more sure.”

I hold eye contact with her, wanting to gauge her reaction to make sure she’s telling the truth.

She looks back at me with so much want and desperation—something I’m sure she sees mirrored in my own features—that I know she wants this.

I glide the tip of my cock through her wetness. She moans even though I haven’t pushed inside her in the slightest.

I pause, catching Mare’s attention. “Why are you stopping?”

“I’m scared of hurting you.”

“No physical pain could compare to the hurt of not having this moment with you. Fuck me, Cade. Make love to me and let me give you this. Let me have this. Hurt me because I promise it’ll be the best pain of my life.”

Her words unravel me. I haven’t even inched inside her yet, and I know no one else could ever compare to her. She’s my everything. My ruining, and I want everything she’ll give me.

Before I push inside, I lean down and trap her lips between mine. Our hips rock against one another as we lose ourselves in a kiss. The kiss seems to say so much. Neither one of us has ever uttered the three words that will change everything, but the kiss seems to say it for the two of us.

I am hers. I’d do anything to keep her as mine.

---