Page 116 of Pretend Girlfriend

“I’ll do better, then. Joanna: reach between your legs, take Theo’s cock in your hand, and guide it into your soaked pussy.”

“That’s better.” I did as instructed, gripping his rock-hard length between my fingers and aiming it vertically. But I took my time lowering myself on him, taking just the tip and wiggling my hips in a circle.

“She’s teasing me,” Theo said with a big grin.

“I’m doing as I was told,” I said with an innocent pout. “Austin didn’t specify how quickly I had to do it.”

“I’ll allow it,” Austin ruled like a judge. “Torture him, Joanna.”

“Mmm, with pleasure.”

I rolled my hips back and forth, feeling only Theo’s crown pressing against my inner walls. I was eager to take all of him, but teasing it out was more fun just then. If we were going to put on a show, why not make it an interesting one?

“Do it,” Austin finally said. “Take all of his cock, now.”

I slammed my hips down hard, accepting every millimeter of his shaft inside of me. I moaned and sat upright, arching my back. I squeezed my breasts together, which made Austin breathe harder.

“Goddamn, you feel good,” Theo groaned.

“Not as good as you.”

“I highly doubt that.”

Still sitting upright, I used my thighs to move up and down on his stiff length. After the intensity of the last position, it was a nice, steady pleasure as I rode him. I made my body ripple like waves as I moved, tossing my hair from one side, then to the next. It was all a show, so I wanted to make it look as good as possible for Austin.

But it was torturous in another way. Austin was right there, sitting in the chair with his cock in his hand, watching without participating. That seemed so inadequate, now. Especially after all the talk about threesomes in the past two days.

Yet I was terrified to make the move. To invite Austin to join in. I was feeling submissive tonight, doing whatever I was told. Asking him to come over here didn’t feel right, even though it’s what I wanted more than anything.

Theo squeezed my ass with both hands, spreading my cheeks open and digging his fingers into my flesh. I gazed over my shoulder again at Austin, and our gazes locked together. His crystal blue eyes sparkled with desire.

And then he suggested something that I wasn’t expecting at all.

48

Joanna

“I saw the toy you were playing with,” Austin said. “In Theo’s suitcase. Do you two like to play like that?”

My riding movements faltered for a moment. I turned back to Theo and said, “I was actually surprised to find that.”

Underneath me, Theo looked embarrassed for a moment. “I brought it on the trip. Just in case.”

“Oh,” Austin said. “Well, then.”

“It was just a thought,” Theo said. “We don’t—”

“I’m interested,” I interrupted. “I was shocked when I found it, but excited.”

“Have you ever done anything like that?” he asked.

I shook my head. “But I want to do whatever you want to do.”

His brows rose. “Yeah?”

I nodded. “I like the way you use me.” I looked over my shoulder at the second man. “And I like the way you tell me what to do.”

Austin smiled like he knew exactly what I meant.

---