Page 117 of Pretend Girlfriend

“How about we play around with your ass, then?”

There it was. Saying it out loud. I’d been subconsciously thinking about the butt plug since finding it in Theo’s suitcase, letting the idea roll around in my mind. Tasting it like wine. I was in the right mood for it, and my body felt totally relaxed from the weed and alcohol and orgasms. I was already trying something new having Austin in the room with us, and I was loving every second of it. So why not try something else new?

Slowly, I nodded. “I’ll try it.”

“You sure?” Theo asked.

“I think so,” I admitted. “But I have one condition.”

Theo’s eyes sparkled. “Yeah?”

I looked back at Austin. “Austin has to be the one to do it.”

I felt Theo’s cock stiffen even harder inside me, as if that were even possible. Austin only stared at me with the same lusty half-grin he’d been wearing.

“Why, Joanna,” he said with that smooth Texas drawl. “I thought you’d never ask.”

A shiver of excitement ran through me as he got up from the chair and let his pants drop all the way to the floor.

“Shirt, too,” I demanded while slowly riding Theo. “Take it off.”

Austin tilted his head. “I thought I was the one giving the commands.”

“You can command all you want, as long as it’s done shirtless,” I replied.

Austin chuckled and stripped his shirt off, joining us in complete nudity. His tan body was a sight to behold, muscular and with a smattering of light chest hair. He walked past us, arm almost brushing against my foot on the way to Theo’s suitcase—even that near-contact was enough to make me shudder with anticipation. He flipped open the suitcase and peered inside.

“The felt bag,” Theo said.

Austin pulled out the butt plug and lube. “You came prepared.”

I slowed my hips as Austin came up behind me. There was a long moment of anticipation while he stood there. Austin had never so much as touched me, aside from carrying me to safety on the beach. We’d never even kissed. Yet here I was, bent over Theo and totally exposed to this man who was almost a stranger.

That turned me on a whole lot more than I ever expected it to.

There was a click as he opened the bottle of lube. I felt a trickle run down the middle of my cheeks. Theo grabbed my ass with both hands again, pulling it apart more than before.

I tensed, waiting for the toy.

But it wasn’t the toy that I felt. It was a pair of fingers—fingers which weren’t Theo’s, since he was still gripping my ass. Austin’s fingertips ran up and down my crack, coating himself with lube. He circled my tight little rosebud, gentle as can be. Making sure I was properly lubed.

Then one finger slid inside.

“There you are,” he breathed an inch from my ear, leaning over me. “So tight.”

“Ohh,” I moaned while sensing this new feeling. It was just his fingertip, barely inside me at all, but it thrilled me. Both the physical act, and that it was Austin, the man I’d been furious with just a few days ago and yet who had slowly impressed me.

“She’s clamping down on me,” Theo murmured underneath me. “She likes it.”

“That true?” Austin purred into my ear.

“Mmm hmm,” I replied, biting my lip. It was all new and different and good, so good, better than I expected.

I began moving on Theo again, slowly up and down while Austin fingered my ass. One finger, then a second one curling up inside me. The dual stimulation, a cock in my pussy and fingers in my ass, was exhilarating.

I reached back and found Austin’s cock, long and stiff and hot. He made a deep noise in his throat at my touch, which went on and on as I began to stroke him.

“Isn’t this better than just observing?” I asked over my shoulder.

---