Page 36 of The Pact

I tighten my grip on the arms of my chair. Even if he fucked her, that won’t give him any extra points if she decides to play.

She squirms again in her seat, looking uncomfortable. “I—I like you too. I’m sorry if—”

“Why are you sorry, cutie?” Ashton interrupts her. “Do you have a favorite between us? You can be honest if that’s the case.”

The light pink of her cheeks darkens a few shades as she shakes her head. “No, that’s the problem. I like each of you. Equally. But I don’t want that to become a problem if we hang out again. I wouldn’t know how to choose—”

Relief floods me. So she does like me. “That’s exactly what we were hoping to hear, Ausra.” I interject.

She looks confused. “So you didn’t bring me here because you’re mad at me for kissing you all?”

Bode takes her hand, brushing his lips against her knuckles, the smooth asshole. “We aren’t mad at you in the slightest, pretty girl. We’re actually happy to hear that you like us all because we have something we want to ask you.”

***

Ausra

––––––––

WHEN BODE SAYS THAT they all like me, my heart does a happy leap in my chest. I’m still a little worried about what they want to ask me, thinking that I don’t want to have to choose one of them over the others.

“We want to have sex with you,” Bode says, kissing my knuckles with warm, gentle lips.

“Sex?” My voice comes out in a breathless squeak. “All of you? Together?”

They liked to share girls.

Mc was right. The rumors she heard about them are true.

Kelley takes my other hand, rubbing soothing circles on my palm. “Yeah, together. It’s a game. We spend a night together and we play. You’re in charge of the game, baby. Nothing happens unless you agree to it and you want it. But we’ll make you come. A lot. And by the end of the night, you give each of us a score. We add that to our own scores calculated on what each of us got to do with you and to you. The one with the highest score is the winner.”

Don’t ask me why out of the bajillion questions I could ask them, the first thing that comes out of my mouth is, “What do you win?”

Ashton winks at me. “Bragging rights. Because the winner will end up being the one who gave you more orgasms.”

There’s heat in his silver eyes when he explains that and I can’t help but feel that heat reverberate all over my body.

I feel my nipples immediately tighten in my bra and a wave of throbbing heat between my thighs.

I’m disappointed and intrigued at the same time. “So you aren’t asking me to date each of you and then choose?”

A look passes between the four of them. Kelley is the one who explains. “We don’t really date. It would be a one and done. Just a fun game.”

Again, my own reaction surprises me. “Just one night? With all of you? What happens after?”

Shep rubs the back of his neck and there’s hesitation in his voice. “I ... I don’t know. We stay friends? We see each other around? It would be a no strings attached kinda deal.”

Ashton nods. “Yeah. Truth be told, we’ve only ever done this while away for competitions. We’ve never played with anyone local before. But we all like you, so ...”

I’m fucking crazy. Because I’m not getting up and walking out of here. Because these guys have somehow gotten under my skin in the space of two days. I mean, of course I knew them from school but—ok, no. I didn’t really know them at school. I thought they were hot.

Another question comes out of my mouth with me barely realizing that I spoke out loud. “So I have to have sex with each of you?”

Bode shrugs. “Ideally, yes. I can guarantee you that each of us will try everything in their power to get you to have sex with him. And while you don’t necessarily need to let each of us ‘fuck’ you, we all want to make you come. It’s part of the game.”

Shep nods in agreement. “Exactly. And, of course, we wouldn’t mind getting to come too. So we’ll definitely try. But if you say no to anything, it’s set in stone. We can try to persuade you but if you don’t want to do something, it’s off the table. You’re in charge.”

The idea of being in charge of these four drop dead gorgeous, cool guys is way more exciting than it should be.

---