Page 129 of Forgotten Promise

“Make me.”

Kailani was at Benjamin’s shoulder. He looked over to see what she held, and smiled. Then he looked down at John, who was smirking while looking up at him through his lashes.

Benjamin shoved John’s ankles apart, kneeling between them. When John went to shift away, Benjamin pinned his thighs to the bed. He started to sit up, so Benjamin stretched out on top of him. They both jolted when their cocks brushed against one another. Then Benjamin kissed him, bearing him down into the mattress. John’s hand roamed over Benjamin’s back and ass, his fingers restless, stroking and kneading.

Benjamin shifted to the side, stretched out next to his lover with one of John’s legs trapped between his own. He kept kissing him, but now Benjamin had access to stroke John’s naked front. He followed the lines of his pecs, rubbing his thumb across John’s nipples, and stroked his belly as his hand worked south.

Benjamin rested his hand on the velvety-soft skin below John’s belly button, his fingers splayed.

John made a noise of frustration, his hips arching up.

“You want me to touch your pretty cock?” Benjamin asked.

“Fuck. Yes.”

“Then spread your legs. Wider. Good. Bend your knee.”

Benjamin kept one of John’s legs trapped between his own. Now John’s other leg was spread to the side, his foot flat on the bed, knee raised.

In reward, Benjamin gripped the base of John’s cock, squeezing. He arched up, air hissing between his teeth. Benjamin worked the shaft, then shifted his grip up. His palm and fingers wrapped around John’s dick, his thumb on the head, teasing the slit. Pre-come already wet the tip of his dick, and Benjamin spread it over the head.

“Fuck. Fuck,” John panted.

Benjamin looked at Kailani as he released John’s cock. She was there, ready to help. Since Benjamin was propped up on one elbow, Kailani helped him put on the black glove, then dribbled lube onto his fingers.

John had his head up, watching what they were doing. His face was tight, his eyes bright with desire.

Benjamin lowered his hand to John’s ass. The position wasn’t ideal, but it would work, and this way he could watch John’s face.

He slid his lubed fingers between John’s butt cheeks. John dropped his head to the bed, exhaling heavily.

Benjamin found the tight ring of muscle by feel and started to stroke the rosette with the pad of one finger. John’s cock bobbed as his muscles clenched in response to the stimuli.

“Why does that feel so good?” John moaned.

“Lots of nerve endings here.” Benjamin kept up the caress, adding a little pressure but still stroking.

Kailani took a seat on the edge of the bed, a towel spread out on the mattress next to her with the other things she’d grabbed. She’d pulled on a robe at some point and her nipples were two hard peaks against the silky fabric.

“Lube,” Benjamin said, lifting his hand. Kailani dribbled more of the thick lube on his fingers.

This time, Benjamin didn’t stroke. He put the tip of his index finger against John’s anus and pushed.

“Fuck.” John’s hips came up off the bed.

“Relax,” Benjamin chided, adding pressure.

“Oh fuck,” John breathed as his body yielded.

Benjamin pressed his finger into John’s ass up to the first knuckle, watching a fresh bead of pre-come leak from the tip of John’s cock.

Benjamin thrust in and out, slow and gentle, almost stroking John’s ass. When his hips started thrusting up in sync with the movement of Benjamin’s finger, he carefully withdrew. Stacking his middle finger atop his index to form a wedge, he once more invaded John’s ass. John sighed with pleasure when the tip of Benjamin’s middle finger was in, stiffening as the tip of his index finger joined it.

This time, Benjamin worked in stages, working his fingers in a half inch at a time. When his second knuckles breached the ring of muscle, and John’s cock was so erect it was practically lying on his belly, Benjamin looked over to Kailani once more.

Without a word, she passed him the washed and already lubed plug.

Benjamin carefully withdrew his fingers, smiling in satisfaction at John’s disappointed moan. Then he wiggled the plug into place.

---