Page 76 of Theirs

I don’t get to respond before Mac’s next command. “Ride Dr. Donaghue’s cock, Kitten. Make him feel good.”

I reach down between us, lining Ben’s hard cock up with my entrance, slowly baring down on his thick shaft. I lay my body over his, moving my hips up and down, while my hair brushes against his chest. I glance over, just in time to see Mac pull a bottle of lube from the nightstand. My movements stutter, realizing that they’re really going to give me what I want.

“It’s okay, Kitten,” Mac says. “I’m going to get you ready, don’t worry. You get to choose though, who do you want in your ass?”

“You and Alex,” I beg. I remember Alex telling me he was willing to try this as a group, as long as he was on top, I don’t want him to feel trapped. “You and Ben first, please.”

“Yes, ma’am,” Mac says. “Why don’t you take your mind off of what I’m getting ready to do, and suck Colin’s cock? Alex, maybe you and Colin can share while I get our little one ready?”

Colin and Alex stand up on the mattress after they both remove their clothes, holding onto the posts of the bed to keep balance. I sit up on Ben’s cock, and he thrusts his hips up so I can take care of his friends.

I place my lips around Colin’s awaiting dick, licking the tip of it before I bob my head up and down on it. I look up just in time to watch his head fall back, a moan coming from his mouth. I let my tongue slide over the vein in his cock, the ball on my tongue piercing sending him a sensation that has him bucking his hips forward. I gasp when I feel a finger press against my asshole.

“You okay, babe?” Alex asks from my other side.

I nod, my head beginning to bob up and down on Colin’s cock again. I notice Ben has stopped his thrusting, that way Mac can play with my other hole. Mac’s single finger pushes into me, and it’s beyond tight, I don’t even think he’s passed the second knuckle on his finger. I can’t stand that he’s just pulsing it inside me, I want to feel it moving in and out. I pop my mouth off of Colin, and grind against Ben’s cock, and push back on Mac’s finger. I try to think about when Colin was the one fucking my ass, how gentle and slow we took it, I’m too impatient this time around. I want them all.

“Kitten, we’ve got to move slow,” Mac says. “I don’t want me or Alex to hurt you. It’s going to be a lot to have both of your holes filled at the same time.”

“I know,” I whimper, remembering the time Colin and Ben took me together. “I just want you inside me already.”

“It’s going to take time, you know our cocks are a lot bigger than one single finger,” Mac says, pushing his finger deeper for emphasis. “Just keep playing with Colin and Alex, I’ve got this under control. I’ll fuck you when I say you’re ready. When you feel ready.”

He smacks my ass with his other hand, punishing me for trying to move things along too quickly. I mumble my annoyance, but then look over to Alex, asking him for his cock.

He takes a step closer to me, and I open my mouth for him. I don’t take my eyes off of Alex’s as I move my head up and down on his length. He pushes my hair back from my face, and holds it for me.

“You’re so gorgeous, Teagan,” he says, almost like he can’t believe it. “How did I get so lucky to have a girlfriend like you? Someone I can share with my best friends, someone who loves us so unconditionally. You’re perfect for us.”

“She’s such a good girl,” Colin praises, and I move back over to take him in my mouth, but I use my hand on Alex’s shaft. “She’s our good girl.”

I nod my head in agreement, just as Mac pushes another finger in me, and I gasp against Colin’s cock, drool falling from my mouth onto Ben’s bare chest.

“Are you going to clean that up?” Mac whispers in my ear. “You just made a mess on Ben’s chest. Better get it before it slides off and onto the sheets.”

I take my mouth off of Colin, and remove my hand from Alex’s shaft. Ben watches me as I lean down, pushing my ass into the air to lick my saliva off of his chest. Then I realize the position has made it easier for Mac to slide a third finger into me. I sit up, and impale myself back onto Ben, wanting to ride out the sting in my ass.

“Such a good, dirty girl,” Mac says, fucking my ass with his fingers. “We’re almost there, Kitten.”

“I’m ready,” I gasp. “Please, Mac. Put your cock in me.”

Colin curses beside me and I watch as he stops stroking his cock, muttering something about me making him blow his shot too early, but he keeps watching. Mac removes his fingers, making me cry at the empty feeling, but he doesn’t make me wait too long. Ben holds my hips, preventing me from moving, as Mac strokes some lube onto his cock, and lines himself up with my tight hole.

“Breathe, Lav,” Ben says. “Keep breathing, baby. Just like the last time with me and Colin.”

The head of Mac’s cock penetrates my ass, but he stops there. “Don’t tense up, Kitten. Relax. You’re going to take me one inch at a time. Slowly.”

Mac places a hand on my back, urging me to lie down against Ben’s chest. He places a kiss on my forehead, and I turn my head just enough to look back toward Mac. He looks like he’s concentrating, savoring each tiny push into me. He pulls out the inch that he managed to get in, before pushing back in even further. It feels like it takes forever before he’s finally buried deep inside me.

“Now, take it easy, Kitten,” Mac says. “I’m going to let you control it. Place your hands on either side of Benjamin’s head. Fuck our cocks, baby.”

I lift up, my tits hanging in Ben’s face, he grabs onto them, massaging and playing with my nipples as I begin to shift forward and back on their cocks, fucking both of them at the same time.

“That’s it,” Mac says. “Tell her what a good girl she is, guys. You know our little one has a praise kink.”

“You’re doing so well, Lav,” Ben says. “Are you going to make me cum in that tight pussy? Are you going to let Mac and I fill you up at the same time?”

I nod my head quickly, and then Colin is grasping my hair, holding my head so I look at him as I continue riding Mac and Ben.

---