Page 69 of Theirs

“But you deserve to hear me say it, Teagan,” he says, pulling me against him and wrapping his arms around me. “I didn’t think I would ever be able to love again after her. But I fell in love with you.”

“I fell in love with you too,” I tell him, resting my head against his chest before pulling away. “You grumpy, workaholic.”

“I can punish her for that if you would like, Alexander,” Mac says from behind me.

I spin around, making Alex place his hands on my shoulders. “That’s not fair.”

Mac strides over to us, and takes my chin in his hand. “Well, I guess you better play nice tonight.”

“And if I don’t?” I ask, using my bratty tone.

Mac leans in. “Then I’ll eat your dessert.”

My bratty smile disappears. “Don’t. You. Dare.”

“Then be good,” Mac says simply, turning away.

***

Since all of our stomach’s were full, we all decided to hang out in the living room and watch the Blackhawks game while our food settled. I cheer loud with Colin when they score their third goal of the night.

Colin picks me up and spins me around in victory as the game ends with us winning. We beat the Lexington Mustangs, but it was a close one.

“You owe me a game in person,” I tell him when he sets me back on my feet. I tug my pajama shorts down that I switched into when we got back to Mac’s where they had ridden up.

“Of course,” Colin says. “What my lady wants, my lady gets.”

Alex tugs me down in his lap as the announcers talk with one of the players post game.

“Hey, you,” I say sweetly, and let out a little yawn.

“Bedtime?” he asks.

I shrug my shoulders. “Maybe. You might have to lock me in a room away from these guys. They’re notorious for keeping me up at night.”

“What if I want to keep you up tonight?” Alex asks, I feel his erection grow in his pants.

“Do you?” I ask, my heart speeding up.

Alex smiles up at me. Whispering in my ear. “I think I’m ready to be re-deflowered.”

I gag. “Don’t say it like that!”

I stand up, and Alex follows. “Are you guys coming to bed?” I ask the other three.

Mac shakes his head. “I wanna catch the news, we’ll probably come to bed in an hour or so. Make yourself at home in my room.”

I bend down and give Mac a gentle kiss. “Thank you again for my gift and dinner.”

“Anything for you, Kitten,” Mac whispers back.

I move over to Ben and Colin and also place a kiss on their lips. “Night.”

Mr. Snuffy looks up at me from Ben’s lap and I give him a little chin scratch before turning around to Alex.

Alex holds my hand all the way to Mac’s bedroom, closing the door behind us. He presses me into it, and I gasp at this change in Alex. I’ve been wondering how he is during sex for a while now. Mac is dominating, he takes control in the bedroom. Ben wants to please me more than any man I’ve encountered in life, he tries to devour me with pleasure, and when we have sex, it’s fun, never too serious. Colin enjoys watching every movement I make in bed; his eyes are always watching. It would normally make me self-conscious, but when Colin watches... it’s empowering. All the guys empower me.

“Are you ready?” Alex asks me.

---