Page 59 of Theirs

Mac closes the curtain, I can still see outlines of the people making out and touching each other, but I know they can no longer catch a glimpse of me. It’s too dim up here.

“They don’t get to watch you, baby,” Mac says. “Only we get to watch you. You are ours, and we’re yours. Understand?”

Mac loosens his hold on my hair long enough for me to nod my head.

He rubs his thumb over my clit and I push back against him, begging.

“You ready for me, Kitten?” he asks, pulling his fingers and thumb from me.

I nod quickly, and open my eyes to find Alex staring at me. When I look down, I see him rubbing his crotch. God, I want him in my mouth right now, but I know better than to ask for anything tonight. I don’t get to make demands right now, only Mac does.

Mac releases my ponytail, and moves his hands to my hips, gripping me there as he nudges the tip of his cock against my waiting entrance. No one speaks as Mac impales himself inside me, I gasp, and move forward, finding Alex’s waiting lips. He kisses me as Mac pounds into me from behind.

“You’re so damn beautiful, Teagan,” Alex says against my lips. “How’d we get so lucky?”

Mac stops thrusting his hips, and instead pulls my hips against him, and then off. I place my hands on Alex’s shoulder, and kiss him again before taking over for Mac. I push my hips onto him, and pull off over and over again until I’m letting out a scream that Alex devours with his mouth. Mac grunts, and stops my hips, I feel him release himself inside me. Praising me for being so good. He pulls out, and comes over to sit beside Alex, catching his breath, his cock still hard, but covered in my pleasure. I hope that’s not all he’s giving me tonight. I want more.

Someone else comes behind me, and I don’t have time to turn around and see whether it’s Colin or Ben before they fill me up. Whomever it is, they’re more gentle with me. I find the rhythm with them, bouncing back and forth to the beat of the music in the club. Alex reaches forward, tugging my breasts out of the deep neckline of my dress.

“Isn’t she so pretty?” Colin asks, and I smile when he leans down and presses a gentle kiss to my neck. “So beautiful. We should keep her forever.”

Forever? My heart swells at the thought, my eyes opening to look at Alex. I wonder if he remembers what I painted on that wall. I meant it, even if I didn’t say it out loud.

“I know, baby,” Alex says, placing his hand on my cheek and stroking it softly while Colin kisses all over my neck. It’s like he’s reading my mind. He knows I want to be theirs forever.

I lean down, losing Colin’s lips on my neck, but gaining Alex’s lips on my mouth. Colin pounds into me excruciatingly slow, he reaches around me, tweaking one of my pierced nipples and I squeal.

“Cum on my cock, baby,” Colin whispers. “Let me feel that cunt tighten around me.”

“I’ve got you,” Alex says, and when I look down, I watch as he moves his hand between us and starts circling my clit with his thumb. “Are you going to let me help you cum?”

Nodding, I let Colin and Alex get me to the edge again. Colin’s still playing with my nipple and moving in and out of me when I feel the pleasure fill me up, starting in my thighs, and traveling up my belly. Alex slows down on his circles as Colin shouts out his orgasm. As he pulls out I feel Mac and Colin’s cum sliding down my thighs. I start to get up, not wanting to ruin Alex’s suit any more than I probably have, but he keeps me down.

“My turn, Lav,” Ben says, kneeling down and licking up some of the cum spilling from me.

“Ben!” I gasp, which causes Mac to stand up and spank me.

“Bad girl, I told you what kind of words you’re allowed to use,” Mac scolds. “Now what do you say?”

“I’m sorry, Daddy!” I gasp.

“Good girl,” Mac says, smoothing some hair out of my face. “Now if Ben wants to taste it, let him. You know Ben’s always hungry for that pussy. Are you going to behave now?”

I nod my head, and Ben dips inside of me. My thighs start shaking from overdrive. It’s impossible to hold myself up any longer. Alex pulls me to his chest, letting me rest there, as Ben fucks me with his tongue before standing up to push his cock deep inside me.

I want so badly to beg him to go harder, deeper, to tell him how good it feels, but I’m not allowed. Now I understand how this is punishment, Mac knows I like responding to their dirty talk when we play. Since I can’t say any of that, I just start chanting the only words that I’m allowed to say, turning them into their own form of dirty.

“I’m sorry,” I gasp. “I’m sorry. Sorry! I’m—I’m... please, Daddy.”

“Yes, Lav,” Ben says, pounding into me harder, resting one of his knees on the couch next to mine and Alex’s. “You were so bad, trying to ruin the surprise. Keep telling us how sorry you are.”

“I’m sorry,” I moan, pushing my ass out more, urging Ben to get deeper. “Sorry! I’m—”

I don’t even get the last apology out. Alex covers my mouth with his, softening my moans as Ben cums deep inside me. As he pulls out, and collapses in a chair beside us, laughter boils up in my stomach, and I find myself in full-on hysterics.

I collapse to the side, my head falling into Mac’s lap, my legs over Alex’s.

I look up and find Mac staring down at me. “What a good little girl. Taking her punishment like a champ. Daddy loves you.”

My heart soars at his confession of love, but I pass out from exertion before I can respond.

---