Page 18 of I Had a Threesome With Santa Claus

“Put your fingers in me,” Ellie demanded. Holly slipped a finger into Ellie as she continued to work her clit with her tongue. “Did I say finger Holly?” Ellie asked. “I can take more than that, now put your damn fingers in me.”

Holly pumped three of her fingers into Ellie and began to suck ferociously on her clit until she heard Ellie cry out and felt her pussy tighten around her fingers. Holly lifted her head to look into Ellie’s heavy lidded gaze as her hand loosened from her hair.

“That was exactly what I wanted, Holly,” she told her, “I think I’ll let you come now, and since you made me come so hard I have a treat for you.”

Ellie got up and went to her nightstand drawer where she pulled out a harness and a sizable dildo roughly the same size as Santa’s own dick. She strapped it on and turned to Holly, her fingers coating it with lube.

“Now, Holly, what I could do is fuck that pretty pussy until you come, but you’ve gotten to do that already on my husband. What I really want to do is fuck that tight little ass. What do you think Holly? Will you flip over and let me fuck your ass?”

Holly bit her lip in consternation as she studied the size of the dildo. “I don’t know. I’ve never had anything in my ass before.”

Ellie smiled at her sweetly, “I think you’ll enjoy it, I promise to take it nice and slow. We can stop immediately if you don’t like it.”

Holly thought for another minute before making a decision. Ellie and Santa had respected her boundaries all night and she found she trusted Ellie to do this. She looked at Ellie and nodded. “I want you to fuck my ass Ellie.”

Ellie’s smile turned devious before rolling Holly over. Holly felt a dribble of lube trickle down her butt and Ellie’s fingers soon followed as she began to massage the lube into her hole. She slowly inserted a finger as she worked the hole. Holly gasped at the intrusion and was surprised she didn’t mind how it felt. Ellie inserted a second finger and the pressure increased a little, though instead of hurting, she found herself growing slick.

“Are you doing okay, Holly?” Ellie checked in.

Holly nodded as Ellie continued to pump her asshole, occasionally scissoring her fingers to prepare it. Ellie smiled and added a third finger, stretching it more. Holly gasped as she felt her pussy get wetter and wetter. Santa had leaned back into the pillows as he watched, his cock somehow hardening yet again.

When Ellie deemed her properly prepared, she lined the toy up and Holly felt it began to push at her entrance. As Ellie eased in, she told Holly to take a deep breath and release it. Holly did so, feeling a slight burn at the stretch but as she released the breath her muscles relaxed and she was able to take the toy more easily. Ellie pushed in about halfway and then began to slowly pull out.

“Are you still okay Holly?” she asked.

“Yes,” Holly breathed, “I want more.”

Ellie smiled. “Greedy girl, I better give you want you want.”

Ellie began to thrust in and out as Holly writhed beneath her. She gripped Holly’s hips to keep her in place. Holly looked up at Santa to find him stroking his cock as he watched his wife fuck her, his hands in time with Ellie’s thrusts.

The feeling of the fat dildo in her ass was like nothing she had felt before, but she wasn’t sure if she could come like this, she needed something else. Ellie had increased her speed, now fucking her in earnest.

“Do you still need more, Holly?” she asked.

“Yes!” Holly cried out as she gripped the sheets. Suddenly, Ellie pulled out of her, eliciting a noise of discontent.

“Nick are you ready to take her again?” Ellie asked.

Holly gazed up at Santa as he looked them both over, “I think I am.”

Santa came down to the end of the bed and pulled Holly atop him. Holly lowered herself onto his dick, grateful to be full again.

“Do you like feeling full?” Ellie brushed her hair back from her shoulder and nipped her neck.

“Yes!” Holly cried out.

“Do you want to take both of these dicks right now?” Ellie asked.

“Yes!” Holly cried out again as Ellie inserted the strap on back into her ass. Holly had never felt so full in her life with one dick in her pussy and the other in her ass. Santa and Ellie began to fuck her between them and tears rolled down her eyes at the sweet pressure. They found a rhythm between them, both of their hands roaming her body as they worked her pussy and ass. The sensations overwhelmed her. She thought she was going to black out from the intensity as stars formed in her vision. She cried out with her release and collapsed onto Santa who furiously thrust into her until she felt his release come with a roar.

Chapter 18

When Holly came back to her senses, Ellie lead her to the shower where she gently helped her clean herself off. They toweled off and climbed into bed while Santa took his turn in the shower before joining them. They both cradled Holly between them, rubbing her back and peppering her with gentle kisses.

Holly sighed, her head on Ellie’s chest while Santa rubbed slow circles on her back. “This is the first time in so long I haven’t felt lonely this time of year. I almost don’t want to leave.”

Ellie smiled down at her. “You don’t have to leave. We love having you here with us. You could stay if you wanted to.”

---