“Turn around.” Samuel’s hands dropped to my hips, and he guided me so that my back was to him and my front to Alex. He pushed up onto his knees and bent me at the waist. His other hand slid between my ass cheeks. He spread my juices over my back hole and pressed his first finger in. “You’re right, sweetheart. This is going to be tight. But you can take it. I know you can.” He replaced his finger with the head of his cock. The tip pressed hard into my ass, and I bit my lip at the strange sensation. He worked his way into me slowly, stopping several times to let me adjust. The sensation of fullness made my tongue feel thick in my mouth, and I barely breathed until he reached around my hip and used his thumb to circle my clit.
“We’re almost there.” His voice sounded strained, and I looked over my shoulder to see veins standing out on his neck and arms. He showed an enormous amount of restraint. “You’re doing great. Just a little more.”
Alex moved beside me and rubbed his hands up my back and around my ribs. He teased my nipples as Samuel finger fucked my clit. “I’m so full.” I lowered my head to the bed, offering him all of my ass. “Damn, it feels so good. Don’t stop. Please don’t stop.”
“I’m not going to stop.” He eased forward again and let out a breath. “I’m in. Give yourself a second, then straighten while Alex gets into place.”
I wiggled my hips to get a better feel of him.
“Fuck me. Be careful doing that. I’m barely holding on, Emma. I want to make this good for you, but you’re so damned tight. It’s all I can do to wait.” Samuel palmed my hips and gave a tiny thrust.
“Holy shit.” I straightened too fast and had to stop to catch myself.
Alex walked toward me on his knees.
I arched back into Samuel and wrapped my arms around his neck. He kept circling my clit with his thumb until Alex threaded his cock into my pussy, then he moved to my breasts.
The fullness I’d felt before was nothing to this. Every time I breathed, I felt them shifting inside me. Alex withdrew, then pushed deeper.
“I felt that.” Samuel panted into my ear. “I feel Alex in your amazing cunt. I feel every move he makes, and I feel you tightening around him. It makes your ass tighter too. You feel so good.” He pumped in and out in short bursts, his dick hitting that muscle deep inside that made me gasp.
“I need you to come now.” I kept one arm hooked around Samuel’s neck and put the other around Alex’s. The three of us were so close together, I felt every breath they took. The slightest move drove me closer to the last and final climax for the day. I felt it start and the raw power of it swept through my entire body in a tidal wave. I moved my hips, pulling away from Samuel and taking Alex deeper, then repeated the motion. They braced and helped me keep up the rhythm.
“I’ve never felt anything like this.” Alex pressed his forehead to mine. “This has to be the best sex I’ve ever had.”
“Me too.” Samuel’s cock pushed in hard and fast. “I may never be the same after this.”
Their words and actions combined, hitting all my emotional needs as well as physical. This time, when the orgasm came, I screamed out for both of them. I’d never felt anything this powerful in my entire life. It was like every nerve came alive at the exact same time and sent waves of the orgasm into every muscle and bone. Samuel came a second after me, his own release filling me with an impossible tightness as he bellowed and shot his cum in my ass.
Alex lasted another five seconds before he lost control. His eyes closed and he gripped my shoulders while he bowed backward and thrust one last time into my seizing pussy. Every pulse of his cum sent a new rush of feeling through me.
We collapsed into a heap. I struggled to catch my breath and burst out laughing.
Samuel pulled my hair back from my face and kissed my temple. “What’s so funny?”
“This has to be the best Christmas ever. I got my present two weeks early.” I turned my head to capture his lips. And maybe I’d get plenty more before it was all over.
Alex cursed and withdrew from me. He shook his head and held up a hand when Samuel tried to speak.
“Alex, what’s wrong?” I asked.
He rolled off the bed and grabbed his clothes, not bothering to put them on before he stalked from my room.
My door slammed shut without an answer.
The sudden silence and the tension radiating off Samuel almost made me afraid to look at him.
“What was that all about?” My chin quivered at Alex’s reaction.
Samuel caressed my shoulders and pulled his cock out of my ass while kissing my shoulder. “It’s not you, Emma. Alex is suffering from a bad breakup. I guess he’s not as over it as I thought.”
“Oh.” Well, shit. That didn’t make me feel any better. If anything, I felt worse. We’d just had the most wonderful sex of our lives. I’d hoped he would stick around. Maybe become friends? Was that too much to ask of the guys I was sleeping with?
Another, more agonizing thought rushed in. Did Alex have sex with me out of desperation? Was I breakup sex? I didn’t like the idea of being Alex’s rebound girl.
19
HENRY