Page 58 of Caged By the Ruthless Thief

I reach up and hook into her, rubbing her rough spot. Nico’s got his hand on her belly, pushing down. And she shatters. Her thighs clamp on my head like she’s never come so hard before. With her, each time is new. Each moan is distinctive from the last. The surrounding mattresses are designed to contour to the mermaid’s body, bringing her the highest amount of satisfaction.

“Whoa.” Belle pushes up on her elbows, grabbing Nico around the neck. She’s gentle, and the only thing that’s going to do is piss him the hell off.

“You’re not going to break me, Little Krill.” He flips them so he’s on his back and her back is resting against his chest.

“There’s a chest of supplies in the alcove next to Nico’s trident,” I tell Eros, mostly because he’s the closest.

He breaks open the seal and tosses me the lube. To hell with him if he thinks he’s getting in on the action right now. What he’s done has joined us together. But not now.

“Slide onto me, Annabelle.” Nico’s cock is hard and between her legs. She takes it and pumps him once. He groans. “Fuck.”

Annabelle’s blue eyes catch mine, and our gazes lock. She’s torturing him, but herself too. Her cunt is gleaming for us. She slides up onto him while I undo the buckle of my pants and push them off.

I’ve never been more ready for this. I take the lube and work around where she’s taking Nico. We haven’t done this with her before. But I want her pussy as much as he does. He’s just going to have to share. I work her tight lip, sliding the lube around until I’m positive I’m going to get my cock in beside Nico’s. I hold her legs. “Are you ready, Belle?”

Her reply of, “uh, huh” is muffled by Eros’s kiss. I know he’s going to stick his cock in her mouth when things get going. But at this point, I don’t care. I just need to be inside her. Then I can be whole again. She’s everything to me. Absolutely everything. I remove my fingers and position my cock at her entrance.

“Go slow,” Nico grunts into Belle’s back. He’s holding her around her hips, sliding her back and forth. When I move into position, he holds her still. It’s tight, so tight. Slowly, I make my way in until I’m seated to my hilt. She’s a dream, an amazing dream I never want to leave. We have her home. I take a second, and when I’m sure she’s ready, I fuck them both, driving them into the bed.

But Belle isn’t going to leave Eros out of this. She’s pumping his cock with her hand one minute, and the next her mouth is on him. She swallows him down whole. He holds her head. The blue feathers in her braids flutter away as he picks them out. His eyes are closed.

But I can’t close my eyes to this. “You’re so beautiful, Belle. You’re the most beautiful mermaid on the planet.”

Her pussy flutters, and I lose all control, slamming into her over and over. I want to possess her. Own her. Make her understand she’s mine and I’m never letting her leave us again. Nico moves his hand from her hip to mine. He squeezes, and I slow the pace. I get it. He wants Eros to blow first. His eyes are squeezed tight, and he doesn’t have long. With my pace slower, Belle works him harder.

“Sunshine,” Eros grunts, but she doesn’t let him go. She swallows everything he gives her. Eros pulls out, and he kisses the trail of his cum away from her chin and cheeks.

Her eyes are back on me, and nothing is going to slow me down now. I’m here for her. Each thrust, each movement. I wiggle my hand between our bodies and find her clit. It’s only a few strokes before she’s losing it. We’re all writhing and shaking on the mattress. Eros holds her leg out. With another roll of my hips, we come crashing down.

Belle screams our names. It’s loud in here, but not that loud. Nico was right. There isn’t a person here who doesn’t know who she belongs to. She’s our mermaid, and I wouldn’t have it any other way. I’m wearing the scent block. But she’s still mine.

I pull out of her. I look up, and Eros is feeding Belle some restorative gel. I smirk like he does. She’s going to need to supplement. Because I want her again, and soon.

She rolls sideways off Nico, who looks better than he did when we came into this place. His coloring isn’t as off, and while his chest is shaking, so is mine. She nestles into his side, her fingers skating up and down his abdomen.

I press a kiss to her cheek. She hums when my lips slide over her.

“Think you can hang on to our Sunshine a while?”

Nico’s lips are on her shoulder. He glances at Eros. It’s a small attempt to tell him he’s not going to kill him today. When Eros was in our pod bed—no, I guess it was just Nico’s pod bed at the time—Nico shot down every nickname Eros came up with for her.

Belle smiles. “I’m not letting any of you go.”

“You want to get cleaned up?” Nico’s fingers sink lower to Belle’s core.

“Not yet.”

“That’s our mermaid.” Nico’s knees bend, and he’s straddling her before she can say another word.

Belle looks up at me over Nico’s shoulder. “And what more do you have planned?”

“So much more.” I smile. “But for now, I want to watch.” I move to the side of her Nico abandoned. He’s entered her again. Their rhythm shakes the mattress.

I’m kissing her, and then she turns her head to Eros. I shouldn’t like it, but I do. Watching her enjoy another male is good. It’s different from when she’s doing it with me. I can enjoy every micro-expression. Every sigh, every twitch of her hands.

But then he breaks his kiss with her and languishes attention on her newest mating mark on her neck. Her hips buck, but Nico’s not having it. He’s not done with her. He stills her hips, controlling how she moves.

I go in for her lips, tasting Eros on them. My hands are everywhere, and soon she’s coming again hard. A sheen of sweat over her breasts glistens in the light.

---