Page 23 of Tainted Hearts

My eyes flick up and a primal urge fills me. Abby stands there, a plate of cookies in her hands, eyes wide as she takes in the scene before her.

“I’m gonna– Oh, fuck!” Luke roars, back arching off the couch. I don’t watch the two men in front of me, eyes still locked on my girl. Because sheismine. Or at least, she will be.

She can’t see Noah with Luke’s cock in his mouth or Luke’s face contorted in pleasure, but she sure can hear every single noise they’re making.

Me, however, she can see. And as if she can hear that thought, her eyes lock with mine.

That sets me off. I start to pound into Noah like a fucking animal, hips slapping against his ass, the sounds filling the air with Noah’s moans and pleas for more.

Wrapping my hand around Noah’s throat, I pull him up so that his back is flushed to my chest.

Abby shifts in her spot, gripping the plate tighter as she bites her lower lip, driving me wild.

My hand wraps around Noah’s cock, and I start to jerk him off in tandem with my thrusts. “Our mate needs to cum,” I snarl. I’m not just talking to Luke, but to Abby too.

Her eyes flick down to where my hand is gripping Noah’s cock. Her breathing picks up, and I can smell just how turned on she is. It’s faint, but it’s there.

“Yes!” Noah sobs. “Please, let me cum.”

I’m close, only a few seconds away from unloading inside Noah.

When Abby’s eyes meet mine again, it’s like the first time we saw each other. Me fucking into someone, her watching like she wishes it was her.

Only this time, it’s with the right people. How it should have been.

“Cum!” I growl to Noah.

He does, letting out a strangled cry. Both Abby and I switch our attention to Noah’s cock as he pulses in my hand, thick streams of cum shooting out and landing on Luke’s legs.

Quickly, I look back up at Abby, her eyes finding mine again, and I let go. “Fuck!” I roar as my orgasm hits me like a freight train.

My cock violently jerks inside Noah, hot cum filling his tight ass in waves.

The room is thick with the smell of sex and sweat, only the sounds of our breathing left to be heard.

Licking my lips, I smirk at Abby. “Dinner and a show?” I joke, hoping not to fuck this up.

“What?” Luke asks, then looks over the couch. “Well, hello, Spawny,” he purrs. “Didn’t know you were there.”

“Shit,” Noah curses, leaning over and grabbing a pillow from the couch to cover his cock.

Poor boy is so damn innocent sometimes. Even after taking two cocks like a champ. Next time, I’d like him to be inside Abby when we do this.

“Little late for that, babe.” I chuckle, kissing his cheek. I pull out of him, making Noah hiss.

“And she brought cookies!” Luke cheers excitedly, jumping off the couch butt-naked and hopping over it. He grabs one from the plate and moans as he takes a bite. “Thanks.”

Abby just gapes at us. “I–Ah—I made some cookies.” She blinks.

“We can see.” Luke chuckles, kissing Abby on the cheek before grabbing another one. “They’re fucking amazing. I’m going to shower. Wanna watch a movie with us?”

“Ah... sure?” I’m trying not to laugh. But I know for a fact that she’s a naughty little thing. Maybe this is a little eye-for-an-eye for the time she was with Leo and Zed in the hot tub.

“I’ll be right back,” Noah says, standing up and running to the bathroom like his ass is on fire.

“Wait up!” Luke says, running after him. “I’ll help.”

Abby just stares at the door like she’s wondering if she’s dreaming or not.

---