Page 12 of Their Favorite Game

"That was awesome!" Rex swayed back and forth as best he could in the water.

Matty nodded in agreement. "You're a pretty good swimmer, Mal. You seem to have improved since we watched your last swim meet."

I winced. "Thanks," I said, trying to brush off the compliment.

Jake wrapped his arm around me, pulling me closer. "Yeah, great job." He smiled down at me.

"Of course, you won, Jake. While some of us were studying, you were in your pool." Matty rolled his eyes. "Didn't your dad even pay for fancy swim lessons?"

"Fine, give me a different challenge," Jake replied.

"Truth or dare?" Rex smirked.

My heart quickened. Truth or dare? I knew how dangerous this game could be, especially with the three of them. They couldn't expect me to play as well. The last time they played, Frankie made snow angels in boxers, and Sammy had to ask a neighbor for shampoo while only wearing a towel.

"Sure, let's do it." Jake flicked his tongue against the roof of his mouth.

Matty rubbed his hands together eagerly. "Okay, I'll start. Rex, truth or dare?"

"Dare," Rex grinned.

Matty's eyes glistened. "I dare you to skinny dip around the buoy."

Rex laughed, "You got it." Rex pulled off his boxers and tossed them onto the buoy.

Heat rose to my cheeks as he climbed onto the buoy. Damn. His body was carved from pure stone. No wonder he was so good at football. I tried not to look at his cock, but I couldn't help it. Even flaccid, it was like him, massive. He dove into the water before they caught me gawking at him and swam around the buoy. When he finished, he winked at me. Maybe he had seen me staring.

Rex pointed to me. "Mal, truth or dare?"

I bit my lip. "Um, no."

"You have to play." Jake batted his eyes at me and stuck out his bottom lip.

"Fine, truth." This was dangerous.

Rex leaned in, his eyes locked onto mine. "Have you ever fantasized about any of us?"

My stomach turned, and my face was on fire. I couldn't believe he had just asked me that. I looked around, trying to gauge their reactions. Jake looked unfazed, Matty looked curious, and Rex looked almost predatory.

I took a deep breath and nodded. "Yes, I have."

"Who, when, what, all of us?" Matty’s eyes grew wide.

I grinned. "Nope, I already answered. Jake, truth or dare?"

His eyes locked onto mine as he said, "Dare."

I bit my lip. He was challenging me, daring me to say something dirty. I steadied my breathing. My skin vibrated. "Kiss me."

He leaned in, his lips grazing my skin. I closed my eyes. His lips traveled across my jaw to my neck. His hands gripped my waist, pulling me close. His lips found my pulse, leaving a trail of kisses up my neck. He groaned into my ear, sending a shiver down my spine.

"Wait, shit," Rex's voice came out husky. "Let's take it to my house."

Matty nodded in agreement. "Good call. This is too hard to do in the water."

I clenched my fists, trying to reign in my hormones. I had fantasized about all three of them multiple times.Could I really do this?Yeah, it was just truth or dare, but I knew where it was heading. My hands trembled.

"No way. The last time we played, I ended up running around the neighborhood naked." Jake shook his head.

---