“Are you going to make me come this time?” She jumped up when something cold drizzled over her butthole. Her breath hitched when his finger slid over her crack a few times, teasing the rim. She never had anal sex before and though she was curious about it, now that the moment seemed to be there, she was a bit nervous. Okay, she was a lot nervous.
“No.”
What? Right, he was answering her question. “That’s not nice,” was all she managed to say when another finger slid inside her pussy. Finally. “Please, Gio, fill me up. Fill me everywhere.” She knew he liked it when she was vocal, voicing her desires.
“Tell me what else you like.”
“This. This right here.” She tried to push her ass back, to gain some leverage and fuck herself on his finger, but he drew his finger away. How was this fair?
“I can’t fill all your holes at the same time, baby. No one man can.”
Why did it have to be one man? When he stiffened underneath her, she realized she had spoken out loud. Oh no. “I didn’t mean…”
“I think you did.”
Tension grabbed her by the throat and slowly killed her desire. Never before had she voiced her fantasy of being dominated by more than one man. It seemed silly; something she only read about in books. Suddenly, she felt the atmosphere in the room change and she tried to get up, but he kept her down over his lap.
“I’m sorry.” She hated the thought of him thinking that he wasn’t enough. When she had that fantasy, she saw Gio in it. Any other man was just a faceless blur.
“Don’t be. It’s normal to have sexual fantasies.” Judging by his voice and his gentle strokes over her ass, he wasn’t just saying that to save the mood.
“So, do you have them too?” It made her a huge hypocrite, but she hated the thought of him with another woman. In fact, it made her want to murder someone. Starting with him.
His lips burned on her ear when he bent over closer to her. “I’ve already had a threesomeandfoursome,” he whispered.
“I hate you.” The words just popped out of her mouth.
“No, you don’t. But to answer your question, yes, I have fantasies too. They’re just different from yours, as I have more experience.”
Meaning that he’d had a lot of time to already explore his fantasies. She wasn’t sure if she wanted to know the scoop on them. What she did know was how to get a rise out of him.
“Since you have so much more experience, you mind answering a few questions to ease my curiosity?”
He kept stroking her hair as he said, “Ask whatever you want.”
“Did you ever have sex with a man?”
“No.”
“With a goat?”
This earned her a swat on her thighs.
“Hey, that hurt!”
“You don’t know what pain is yet, but continue like that, and you will.”
Um okay. No more bestiality jokes then. “Do you ever think about having sex with multiple women again?” Even though the idea killed her, she had to ask.
“No, I don’t. But I do have other fantasies I will introduce you to soon.”
She couldn’t stop a sigh of relief. She wiggled her butt to get his attention back at the task in hand. “I’m all ears.”
“Good. Take a deep breath.”
“Why do I—”
Oh…No sooner had she voiced that, when he started pushing something hard and unyielding inside her ass.