Page 31 of Their Virgins Secret

“Oh, oh. ” She couldn’t stop it. It felt too good. Cole still plucked at her right nipple, squeezing harshly, then rolling it. His other hand played in her pussy, sliding all around while Burke seated the plug deep in her ass.

“Give it to her, Cole. I want to watch her come. ”

Jessa nearly screamed when Cole took his hand away. “Don’t stop!”

There was a smack to her ass that made her moan. The plug shifted, causing waves of jagged sensation to streak through her.

“Hush, Jessa,” Cole said, his voice a sharp bark. “You’ll get what you need when I decide you need it, not before. ”

As though she weighed nothing at all, he lifted her up and she found herself falling on top of him, sprawled across the big bed that dominated the suite. The shades were open, and the twinkling lights of Manhattan lit up the room.

“I told you I would force you to ride my cock. I mean what I say, baby. Burke, I need a condom. ”

Jessa shook her head. “No. You don’t. I’m on the pill. I want to feel you. I’m clean. ”

“Obviously,” Burke said, standing next to the bed, a concerned look on his face. “Cole and I never have sex without a condom. And you might not believe it, but we’re not out there every night with a different woman. We’re clean, but maybe we should still…”

“No,” she said, practically pleading. “It’s safe. I don’t want to stop. I want to feel you, skin to skin. ”

Cole gave her his answer by thrusting up and joining them in a single smooth move. “Oh, god, that feels so fucking good. ”

It did. Nothing between them but shared breaths and bare flesh. She was so glad she’d decided to go to the clinic and get on the pill. No stopping for protection. No latex. Just her and them, the way it should always be.

“That sounds heavenly, sweetheart. ” Burke shoved his pants down and off. “I want a turn, too. ”

“You’ll get it,” Cole replied. “Soon. I had her pussy first. You take her ass. ”

Cole surged up, pumping inside her. With his hands, he forced her to grind down on him. He was so damn deep, she gasped, mouth open, sensations washing over her as her pussy clasped and grabbed at him, pulling him even farther inside.

“Fuck. I want that. I want that so goddamn bad. ” Burke reached for the lube.

“Come for us, baby. Let go for us before we take you together. I want you soft and happy when we share you the first time. ”

She gave over to him and rode that big cock. The plug took up a lot of space, making her feel fuller than ever before. She slid up and down, Cole’s hands on her ass, a finger on the plug, holding it deep. She slid down on him, her clit hitting his pelvis as he surged up, hitting just the right spot inside her once, twice, again. Then she came with a mewling cry, the pleasure crashing through her system. She fell on Cole’s chest, and his arms closed around her, making her feel safe and warm.

“Get that plug out and get inside her, Burke. I don’t know how much longer I can last. Fuck, she feels so good. ” Cole groaned against her ear, spreading kisses across her cheek, brushing his lips over her mouth.

Jessa felt the bed dip as Burke climbed on. His hands moved tenderly over her ass, and the plug slid out. She sighed, tightened. Cole was still thick inside her body, holding her impaled against him, but now she felt the loss of the plug. Her ass felt empty.

But not for long. Cole soothed his hand down her back as Burke spread her cheeks. She whimpered as she felt him spread more lube on her anus, preparing her to take something far larger than the plug.

“It’s going to be so good, baby. We’re going to fill you completely,” Cole murmured, his hips moving in lazy, teasing thrusts.

Every time he rubbed her clit, a little aftershock sent more pleasure through her that just added to the sweet aftermath of her stunning climax. As they touched, soothed, and worked, she felt boneless and momentarily sated. She let them have their way—just like they’d planned.

Cole’s hands tightened around her, hugging her as she felt Burke’s cock at the rim of her untried hole.

“Sweetheart, you’re so beautiful,” Burke said as he gently stroked himself in, taking her in increments, forcing his cock inside in neat little thrusts. “You feel so good. ”

“It burns. ” Far more than the plug, in fact. She gritted her teeth. It wasn’t pain exactly but it wasn’t comfortable.

“It’s all right,” Cole whispered. “It’s going to be okay. Let him in, baby. Arch your back. ”

She lifted her ass a bit higher, pressing her breasts against Cole’s chest. His heart beat loudly with hers as the burn of Burke’s dick sinking a bit deeper seared her. He worked his way inside her, bumping against the tight muscles of her ass.

“Push out against me,” Burke gritted out, taking her hips in hand and lifting her ass higher.

Jessa pushed out, wondering if he would really fit inside her. A moment later, he popped past the barrier and slowly filled her with his cock.

---