"I'm going to give it to you, just you wait," I said, pulling back. I brought my hand up to her mouth and pressed two fingers against her lips. "Get them nice and wet for me. Show me how you'd suck my cock."
"You're such a jerk," she said.
I chuckled. "I know," I replied before pressing the fingers into her mouth. She moaned and swirled her tongue around each digit, letting her saliva coat them. The sight was so erotic, but I had better things to do with Lily than let her sit here all day sucking off my fingers. I pulled them out of her mouth with a pop and she whimpered. The wetness was dripping from them and I touched one to each nipple. "That should feel nice and cold in a second," I said before lifting her skirt and pushing her panties aside. "But this," I grunted, "this is always hot for me."
I moved my fingers against her folds, which were already soaking wet. With the added saliva, my fingers glided against her clit easily and I started to work her into a frenzy.
"Please," she begged.
I let my lips hover against her ear as I let my fingers circle her entrance. "Please, what?" My cock was straining against my own pants by this time almost painfully. I wanted to bury myself in a pussy I'd missed since the first time I'd entered it.
"Please fill me up," she moaned.
I pressed a kiss against her neck. I wanted to kiss her more than anything, but she'd told me no, and I would respect that. That didn't mean I was going to make this easy for her, though.
"Like this?" I asked, dipping one finger in slightly.
"More," she groaned.
"This, then," I said, continuing to rim her with just the tips of my two fingers.
"Tyson," she gasped. I smirked as I licked the shell of her ear, and I could feel her knees go weak.
"You tell me first," I whispered to her.
"Tell you what?" Her voice was so beautifully breathy now.
"How you feel."
"I've always loved you," she said, not even hesitating to say it. I swear I almost shot my load right there at hearing her say those words. There was a part of me that didn't think she did. Maybe that's why I couldn't say it. More than that, there was a part of me that didn't think I deserved it. It didn't mean I didn't want it, though.
I pushed my pants down and freed my cock. I was done playing with her. "I need to be inside of you right now," I said to her.
"Condom," she moaned, wrapping her hand around my cock.
"Fuck," I said, realizing I didn't have one on me. "I'll pull out."
"You better," she said, and that was all I needed to hear before I was inside of her.
"Fuck you feel so much better like this," I moaned into her ear. I pressed her hard against the door and let her adjust to my size. I grabbed her by the hips and lifted her up. She wrapped her legs around me, and I squeezed her ass as I began to move inside of her.
"Fuck," I gasped. Fucking Lily the first time had been something I'd never forget. Fucking Lily raw was an entirely new experience. "Your pussy is gripping my cock so tight," I groaned into her ear.
"Faster," she breathed out.
I didn't respond. I didn't need to. I just pressed into her at a punishing pace, but she took it beautifully. I loved that she let me do this to her. I loved that I was the only one she let do this to her.
Fuck.
I knew I loved her.
The glass beakers on the shelves behind us were rattling as I continued to thrust in and out of her. She never held back her moans. Lily was always true to herself in whatever moment she was in, and right now, she was loud and begging me for more.
I didn't care if the whole school found out I was fucking her in this little room. It wasn't even on my radar of something to be concerned about. Right now, the only thing I cared about was bringing her to completion so that I could cum down that pretty little throat of hers.
"I'm close," she said to me, and I knew she was telling the truth. Her walls were fluttering, and I kept my pace steady. I moved one hand so it was thumbing the nipple of one breast, then the other.
"God, you're so beautiful when you cum," I whispered into her neck. "I want to see that face of yours. I want to see those eyes of yours roll back from the feeling of it all. Just let go. Let me see how good you feel."