Page 105 of F*ck Steal Kill

“Yes, James. Let Ty fuck you,” she cooed, encouraging them.

James nodded, swallowing slowly as he got up and grabbed a bottle of lube. While I continued to torture Mallory with pleasure, we watched as Tyler prepped James.

James wasn’t a virgin to ass play, and I’d pegged him a time or two, but I knew he hadn’t ever had sex with a man before. It was something he’d wanted, but they hadn’t been able to find a suitable guy candidate that they’d meshed with.

Honestly, it was probably because he was in love with Tyler and hadn’t been able to say it. So, now, they could have their moment.

When Ty had James ready, they moved closer to us, and James decided to play a little with me. He breached my rosette, and when he thrust one finger in, I trembled so hard I almost fell on top of Mallory.

“Shit,” I cooed, pressing my butt back at him.

“Turnabout is fair play, baby doll,” he teased, kissing down my spine as he continued to prep me. When he was ready, he squirted a lot of lube on himself and me before lining up and pressing in. I focused on Mallory, who was petting my hair and telling me how good I was doing. I loved how much of a cheerleader they were for each other and now me.

His thighs met my ass, and I sighed in relief once he was entirely in. He stilled in me as Tyler lined up, pressing his monster cock into James’ ass.

James pulled me up, kissing me deeply as his ass was breached. Mallory also kneeled, lining her front with mine and running her hands over the two of us. Pulling apart from James, I kissed Mallory and then had them kiss. I reached back and grabbed Tyler’s hand, feeling us all connected.

“Ready?” Tyler asked, his voice strained. “Fuck, your hole is so tight, James. I’m not going to last long.”

“Me either,” James gasped, his hips thrusting forward into me.

Somehow the four of us moved together as I fucked Mallory with the dildo, James fucked me in the ass, and Tyler him.

Our moans filled the room, and our skin clapped together as we all rocked toward our orgasms. Mallory was the first to go, her body convulsing as she came around my fingers and Mr. Silver. I knew I’d made her squirt again when she gushed over my fingers.

“Yes, Mal. You’re a fucking queen. Covering my fingers with your cum,” I cooed, making both guys moan.

“Shit, that’s hot,” Ty whispered. “I’m so close.” He dropped a kiss on James’ shoulder, and that was all it took for him. James stilled as he gripped my hips, his cock shooting off his load in my ass and filling me with his warm cum. My orgasm rippled to life as I tensed around him, Mallory’s fingers helping as she rubbed my clit and flicked my nipple.

“I’m coming,” I screamed, tensing my walls as everything went black this time.

Coming to in a naked pile of arms and legs, I sighed contentedly as the person nearest to me rubbed my back in soft caresses. James and Mallory were the bomb at aftercare. I always felt cherished and loved. Speaking of…

“I love you, guys,” I whispered, realizing it was true.

“We love you,” Mallory and James said together like they often did.

“And me?” Tyler asked, rubbing my face. I blinked, staring into his eyes.

“Halfway there, maybe more,” I admitted, kissing his lips. He smiled, and it lit my heart on fire.

Our relationship wasn’t conventional, but I’d never wanted one that was. This was what my heart needed, and I was here for the long haul.

“What would you guys think about trying for a baby?” I asked, leaning up to look at Mallory and James.

Mal’s eyes watered as she nodded. “Really?”

“Yeah. I want everything with you guys. I don’t know if I can, but I’d like to try. I want to give you that.”

“But you want it to, right?” James asked, scanning my face as he stared at me.

“Yes. I didn’t think I did before I met you both, but now, I couldn’t think of anything that could make me happier.”

“Is that something I can be part of?” Tyler asked, his voice small.

“For fuck’s sake, Ty. You’re in this now. Your sperm or my sperm, I’ll love that baby. It will be our baby. Can you say you won’t?” James challenged.

“No. I would. You’re my family. Always have been.”

---