Page 35 of Pleading Innocence

“Come here,” I said, pulling her toward me. “Get on top.” I grinned.

“How’s this going to work?” she asked, straddling my hips.

“Oh, I’ve stared at that asshole while you’ve ridden Mario. I know exactly what to do next.” Anthony smiled at her. “See, you’re going to swallow him with your pussy,” he started, before grabbing her by the back of her neck. I watched as she bit her lip and as her already hardened nipples became redder before me.

“Yeah?” she asked, so sexy I had to touch her clit. “Mm, yes.” She nodded.

He thrust her forward so that her breasts slammed into my chest—not too hard but hard, the way she definitely liked it. I could feel her slickness against my lower abdomen, right on top of my pelvis.

“Then your pretty ass is going to be spread right in front of me,” he said, and by the way she gasped against my neck, I knew he was doing something.

I wasn’t sure what he was doing until I saw that he was holding the butt plug in his hand. He’d just pulled it out and she started kissing my neck in response. Raising her head, I cupped her face in my hands so that I could kiss her long and hard.

Anthony whistled. “You should see how stretched your asshole is right now. Ready for me, whenever you are,” he said, and then he dipped his head. She shuddered against me, riding my pelvis, moaning into my mouth as he ate her ass.

“Ready for the both of us inside you?” I asked.

She nodded, moaning as he continued to work her ass with his tongue. “Please, I’m ready,” she said out loud, looking behind her for Anthony, reaching up to cup her breasts.

“Yes, ma’am,” Anthony said, swiping at his mouth as he backed up so that she could bring her pussy to my cock. She shuddered and so did I as she lowered herself over me. The tip of my cock pushed against her entrance, stretching her before her body slammed down on top of mine, accepting me with ease.

“Mm, fuck,” Tiffany and I said together before we smiled at each other in humor. Both our faces soon twisted in pleasure as she started to work her lower hips against me.

“Hold on now, don’t get too carried away. You still want me in you, don’t you?” Anthony teased her.

“Yes, yes, oh fuck yes,” she said, lowering her breasts over me, stretching her arms out past my head so she could press her mouth against mine. She sucked on my tongue while rocking against me gently and my cock warmed.

I ran my hands up and down her back, rubbing her, gripping her, relaxing her as I fought against the urge to start thrusting. Then I felt it, just as her fingers gripped my hair so tight it felt like she was about to pull my hair out of my scalp. She became so tight, it felt like my cock expanded within her, and the pleasure was so intense I became fine with the idea of losing a few hairs.

“You okay?” I whispered against her lips. “Does it hurt?”

She shook her head. “It doesn’t hurt. It feels different,” she said.

“Good different?” I asked.

I saw the green of her eyeballs disappear before she nodded. “It’s getting there. Oh!” she said as if surprised. “Mm, yeah, it’s getting there.”

“You okay?” Anthony asked a little louder, since he couldn’t hear our conversation.

“Mmhm,” she said.

“Do you want more of me?” he asked, leaning over her to kiss the back of her neck before he scraped his teeth against her skin.

“Oh!” she said, with another tone of surprise. “Mm, yes, please. Slow,” she said.

Her breath shook as she licked her lips. Meanwhile, I had never experienced this much tightness around my cock before. She was right, it was different—good different. I didn’t even have to move to feel every single nerve in my penis start setting off tiny explosions. I couldn’t imagine what it would feel like if I moved.

“Damn, you’re so tight, so fucking hot. You are fucking out of this world,” I said, kissing her forehead, damp with sweat.

Anthony’s eyes were squeezed shut and he was biting down so hard on his lips he looked like he was going to draw blood. Then she asked for the unexpected. “Will you two please ride me?”

Chapter 21

Anthony

Whoa!Whoa,whatisthat? Is that Mario’s…dick?!I thought upon first penetrating her with all of my length. THAT was definitely something new during anal sex. It had me speechless for a moment as I watched them whisper something to each other. It was not something I was expecting. It was strange as fuck to have my dick pressing up against another man’s dick, especially my best fucking friend!

It was one thing to be in the room with your best friend while he had his dick out and you had your dick out. It was a whole other thing to feel it against yours. Through the condom, I could feel the thickness and hardness of him. I was fucking frozen until her sphincter muscles clenched around me.

---