Page 5 of Noelle

She nodded her head unable to speak as I grinned.

“Never forget who you belong to. Who This ass belongs to.” with a smirk he spun her so he could palm her round ass in both his big hands. He wasn’t gentle about It, spreading her cheeks as wide as they would go, James threw me a glance over His shoulder.

“Should we fuck her ass, Benji?”

I loved the way he Included me even when today was all about him. It shouldn’t have worked this little trio of ours, but it did. And it worked well. But then I had always known it would. From the moment she had stepped into my office building to see her old dom, the first time I had seen her I had known she was the one. Finding out her tastes were the same as ours was just the icing on the cake.

“Yes.” I didn’t hesitate. We had played but neither of us had breached that forbidden hole before. It wasn’t a hard limit for her, but it wasn’t something she said she enjoyed. Today that would change.

There was something about even the thought of it that made me groan low in my throat. “Stretch her out. So, we can fuck her at the same time.” Even to my own ears, my voice was gravelly with need. James’s eyes sparkled.

“That Is a good idea.” He went back to kneading her backside. His fingers dipped between her cheeks to test that tight little hole. She arched her back, thrusting her ass out more. Wanting to please him. “I’m going to stretch you wide, Aubrey. Before I punish you.”

He stepped away, glancing over at the small table where our toys were stored. I got there before he did. My finger’s closing over what he needed. I passed them over to him with a knowing grin. Plug and lube.

He would stretch her and then he would punish her with that silver plug splitting her cheeks apart. I knew because he had spoken about wanting to do It so often. And now he finally had the chance.

“Back arched and ass out Aubrey.” He barked out the order. His hands pressed into the small of her back. She did as she was told just like she always did. Aubrey wasn’t a brat. Not usually anyway.

Moving away from my spot I went to stand in front of her. My hands wrapping around her chin, I forced her face up. “Eyes on my face Aubrey.”

Holding my breath, I knew the moment the coldness of the lube fell between her cheeks. She shivered slightly but didn’t move from her position.

“You have such a tight little asshole Aubrey,” James growled out behind her.

I didn’t need to see to know he was forcing that plug into her body. Her eyes gave her away. Pain and lust in almost equal measures.

God, I loved that look on her face.

“Spanking or paddle?” James queried.

I thought about It for a second. “Paddle on her ass and a vibrator on her cunt”

“I like the way you think Benji. I like It a lot.”

Aubrey

The chill of the sweet smelling lube as it tickled down between my ass cheeks had me clenching in a way that was totally foreign to me. Not that I had a chance to move away. Something equally cold pushed against my asshole. Metallic and thick. Back and forth James rubbed it over my opening. Testing the resistance with every move.

The plug was narrow at the tip but still wide enough to make my eyes water as he pushed it against me. It breached my body. In and out, a little more each time. James took his time about it. That was one of the good things about James he always took his time. Whether he wanted to please me or punish me It didn’t matter. He made sure it was done properly. with love and tenderness even when he was hurting me.

It was one of the reasons I enjoyed being with him so much.

“Beautiful.” He forced it that last inch. Stepping back to admire his handy work. Giving me time to grow accustomed to the sudden feeling of fullness that was engulfing me. I squirmed; it wasn’t painful just uncomfortable, but I knew the pain would come. I was ready for. It, I craved It. But I knew tonight would be different.

What had Benji said about a vibrator against my clit? The moment I thought the words my body rocked forward. The sharp thwack of James wooden paddle making contact with my flesh. He wasn’t cruel about It, but the wood made tears spring up into my eyes anyway. A paddle always hurt more than a hand or even a flogger.

I was in good hands though. James would push me until breaking point but no further. He knew when to stop. When to control himself. They both did.

He struck me again. The sound of it was loud in the quiet room. There was nothing but the sound of the paddle hitting my already smarting flesh and our ragged breathing. James was already breathing heavily. Panting from exertion and pleasure.

“Eyes on me.” Benji’s fingers tightened cruelly around my chin, jerking my head up so I had no choice but to meet his eyes. His were shining with mischief. It took me a few seconds to realise why.

The little bullet he had hidden in his palm, pressed against me. Sending a shockwave of pleasure shooting through my body. My knees buckled. It was too much. My body didn’t know what to feel. The Sting of my punishment was painful, almost too much and then there was that little silver bullet against my clit, bringing me unbelievable pleasure. And the entire time I was being split in two by the plug in my ass.

“You can take It, Aubrey.” Wrapping his fingers into my hair, Benji tugged my hair back. His fingers scrambled to undo the straps of the gag. It fell away forgotten and I sucked in a breath, my lips and chin wet. Benji captured my lips with his. His tongue demanding entrance I gave it to him willingly.

“Let me hear you, Aubrey.”

---