Page 4 of Room Twenty-Seven: Theirs to Punish

“My turn,” I announce, dragging Lilly out of her haze of lust. Oh yes, she’s definitely enjoying this a little too much. I don’t want her to like this.

She crawls over to me, her body moving slowly and sensually, almost like she’s in a trance of lust and passion. Her swollen lips glisten from saliva and cum. Her eyes are glossed over, and her cheeks are still wet from a few escaping tears.

Fuck me. I want to be inside her. No, not want. Need. I have to be inside her pussy, or I seriously might die. That’s how strong the urge to claim her is. It’s overwhelming. All consuming.

Kneeling in front of me, she reaches for my cock, but before she can touch it, I snatch her wrist. “Change of plans. I want to fuck you now. Lie down.” I pull her up to her feet just to guide her back down to lie across Luke’s and Bane’s legs on the couch.

Now she is sprawled out in front of me, completely naked and exposed, held down by my brother and best friend. I almost come just by looking at her. Bane cups her breasts, kneading them until a soft moan falls from Lilly’s lips.

My cock is so hard it throbs painfully, and I know it will only take a few pumps inside her juicy cunt before I blow the biggest load of my life. I want to draw this out. I want to see her squirm.

“Spread your legs farther,” I order. She does so without hesitation, spreading her legs until her wet fold is open, and I get the first glimpse at her cunt and asshole. Thinking about how tight her back hole will be, I sink my middle finger into her wet cunt.

She’s even tighter than I expected. Her channel squeezes my digit so tightly, I have to work to force the tip inside. I only get knuckle deep before I feel a small barrier preventing me from going any deeper. I’m so shocked, it takes me a few moments before realizing that this must be her hymen.

Then she does something that’s even more shocking. She pushes herself onto my finger, ripping through her innocence with a gasp.

My mouth pops open. “How the fuck are you a virgin at twenty-two years old?”

Her brows draw together in suspicion. “My club's profile says I’m in my early twenties. How the hell do you know exactly how old I am?”

I force a smile, giving her a moment to really look at me. “I know it’s been five years, but did you really forget I exist?”

Her eyes go wide, and I see the exact moment recognition sets in. “Niklas?” Her breathy voice is barely audible.

My chest tightens at the look of betrayal and hurt in her gaze. I pull my finger out of her tight channel and look down at the smeared blood on the tip with my mouth hanging open. She really was a virgin. How? Why?

I have to remind myself that this is what I want. I want her to feel betrayed. I want her to feel the same pain she inflicted on me.

I’m getting exactly what I want. So why does my chest ache and my stomach churn when I look at her tear-filled eyes?

3

Lilly

Usingevery ounce of strength I can muster up, I shove at him. He stumbles back, and I waste no time getting up to frantically gather my clothes from the floor.

“Hold on a second. I need someone to explain,” Bane demands.

“Tell them, Lillian. Tell them who you are.”

All I can do is shake my head while trying my best not to let the tears fall down my cheeks. I get dressed as quickly as I can. The room around me is nothing more than a blur.

“Wait, Lillian, as in your stepsister?” Bane blurts out.

“Technically, our stepsister, but yes, that Lillian.”

As soon as my shoes are on my feet, I head for the door.

Luke steps into my path, holding out his arms to block me. “Listen, why don’t we sit down and talk? You shouldn’t run out like this.” He reaches for my shoulders just as the first tear rolls down my cheek.

Before his fingers can make contact with my skin, I yell, “RED!”

The lights suddenly come on, forcing me to squint. A moment later, the door flies open, and a bouncer enters the room. “Everything okay in here?”

I wrap my arms around my torso, trying to hold all the broken pieces in my chest together until I’m out of here. “Yes, everything is okay. I just want to leave.”

“The contract hasn’t been fulfilled,” Nik announces. “No money will be paid.”

---