Page 19 of Room Twenty-Seven: Theirs to Punish

My cock is just as hard as it was before I came, but it doesn't feel the same when I enter her this time. My dick is overly sensitive, my balls emptier. The sensations have changed but are just as good.

“Suck Bane’s cock like you mean it. Make him come down your throat because if you don’t, he will use another hole of yours.”

Lilly’s pussy tightens around my cock, making me wonder if she would like getting fucked in the ass. Grabbing her ass cheeks, I spread them apart to get a good look at her puckered hole.

While I keep a steady pace pumping into her cunt, I spit on her asshole before rubbing my thumb over it. Lilly moans around Luke’s cock, making him throw his head back with a groan. He grabs a fistful of her hair, keeping her in place while filling her mouth with his cock until she gags.

I keep massaging her asshole. Her thighs quiver, and her pussy squeezes down on my dick like she’s about to come. We’re all three about to come, and then… this is over.

This can’t be the last time I have her. Once is not enough. Fuck me, it might not ever be enough.

“Do you want to come, Lilly?”

Luke pulls back, letting her catch her breath before she moans, “Yes! Please…”

“I’ll let you come if you agree to another night. Meet us again.”

“What?” She twists around to look at me over her shoulder. Her mascara is smeared around her eyes, her lips are swollen and wet, and spit runs down her chin. Somehow, she is still beautiful, just in a deprived, sexy way.

“I won’t let you come. Not until you agree.”

Her gaze turns from confused and lust-hazed to outraged in a split second. “What?!”

I can’t help but smirk as I dip the tip of my thumb into her ass. Her whole body is stiff. Both of her holes tighten. She is so close to coming. “Say it, say you’ll do it.”

“Okay! I’ll do it.”

As soon as she agrees, I shove my thumb all the way into her ass. Luke reaches under her, rubbing her clit as I fuck her cunt mercilessly.

When she finally does come apart, her pussy tightens so much I worry it’ll take my dick right off. Her orgasm, combined with her scream, forces my own painful release.

Then we all collapse in a heap of sweaty, spent bodies. There is nowhere on earth I would rather be.

9

Lilly

The thoughtof making my limbs move to simply get dressed seems impossible. How the fuck am I going to pull myself together enough to get home? Even in my state of absolute mental and physical exhaustion, a deep kind of sadness overcomes me. It sneaks up, only a feeling at first, but soon, I realize why this tugs at the edge of my consciousness.

I’m sad because this is it. They have gotten what they wanted. Niklas is done with me, and no matter how much I want to lay here with them all night, it’s time to go. We are not at my place, and this is not a date. We won’t cuddle or fall asleep together. We won’t get up to drink coffee and eat muffins. We’re at a sex club, fulfilling an arrangement that is now over.

I feel the cold tracks left behind by a tear on my cheek before I realize I’m crying.

“Hey, what’s wrong? Why are you crying? Are you hurt? What’s going on?”

Their concern only makes me cry harder.

“Lilly, please look at me. Tell me what’s wrong,” Bane demands.

I blink my eyes open, trying to make out his face through the onslaught of tears. “I don’t know.” It’s only a partial lie. I know why I started crying; I just don’t know why I can’t stop.

“Are you overwhelmed?” Luke questions. “You’ve experienced a lot today, and this was intense. I think it was just too much all at once.”

I shrug. I guess that’s part of it as well. The guys keep holding me, stroking my bare skin, running their fingers through my hair. It all feels amazing, and I’m slowly able to calm down. Hiccups replace my sobs, and my tears have left my eyes swollen and raw.

Lifting my head slightly, I lock eyes with Niklas once more. “This is what I was scared about,” I manage to say between hiccups.

“But why? I don’t understand,” he responds, concern wrapped around his voice.

---