Page 45 of Sinister Games

Her eyes pleaded with me as she whimpered.

“Open it,” I growled.

Her lower lip trembled as she obeyed. I pushed my cream-coated fingers deep inside. Her shoulders hunched as she choked and gagged.

“Lick my fingers.” Taking pity on her, I pulled them back slightly, allowing her tongue to sweep around and between them. I needed her to not just acknowledge but literally taste the evidence of her own arousal. She may have damned and cursed me during the punishment but her body betrayed her.

Pushing a third finger into her mouth, I kept her restrained as my left hand once more palmed her pussy. Rubbing between her legs a few times, I finally dipped two fingers inside her tight body.

Clenching my teeth, I stifled my own groan of approval. Christ, she was tight. My cock jumped against her stomach. She was too tight. As much as I wanted to plow into her till I saw her eyes glaze over with painful desire, I didn’t want her to tear. It was essential I prepare her body before my full assault.

Pumping my two fingers in and out, I added a third.

Taking my fingers out of her mouth, I grabbed her hair and pulled her head back. “Raise your ass up.”

“Richard, please. This is… please… I can’t… don’t make me like this.”

“We are far too deep in the game now, baby. Raise your ass up.”

Pushing up on her knees, she shimmied her ass up higher. I missed the pressure on my cock, but it was worth it to get better access to her holes. Pushing her ass high, she arched her back beautifully as her hair slipped over her shoulders and cascaded down over her body. The only thing that would make it more perfect was if I had removed her sweater so I could see her creamy white skin but I didn’t trust myself not to violently thrust into her body if she was completely exposed and vulnerable to me.

I ached to fill her body with my darkness but I knew the challenge of anticipation would make it all the more consuming when I did.

Pushing my three fingers inside of her, I added a fourth. With her cry, I once more pushed my hand into her mouth. I wanted her to feel restrained, overwhelmed by the power of my hold. I wanted her to feel the humiliation of having my hand deep in her mouth, as I speared her body with my other hand.

Still there was more humiliation to come.

Twisting my hand, I pressed deeper into her body, gaping her pussy as my thumb circled and teased her asshole.

Elizabeth bucked and tried to speak around my hand as her eyes pleaded.

Pressing past her resistance, I pushed my hand deep into her pussy just past the knuckles. I knew it would be painful as her sensitive inner muscles would be stretched and strained to accept my fist. The deeper I pushed the more my thumb teased her dark hole, pressing past the tightened, ridged skin to feel her dark warmth.

Elizabeth gagged on my fingers as she tried to scream from the intrusion into her ass. She was a virgin here; I was certain from her alarmed response. Good. It made me all the more determined to fuck her ass, knowing it would be mine and mine alone from the start.

Pushing my thumb in deep, I flicked the tips of my fingers inside her body in a fast-paced steady rhythm.

She bit down on my fingers as an orgasm racked her body in wave after wave.

* * *

Afterward,I allowed her to dress. Sending me a pouting look, she solemnly shifted to squeeze her body into the farthest, tightest corner of the back seat. After instructing Harris, we rode in silence until my car pulled up in front of her building. Grabbing her messenger bag, Elizabeth opened the door before we even came to a full stop and jumped out before slamming it behind her.

I rolled down the window as I watched her stalk toward her door.

“Elizabeth.”

She stopped but didn’t turn around.

“I am your new reality. Things will go far better for you if you just accept your fate.”

There was a pause before she quickly nodded and without looking back ran into the building.

Sighing, I realized I may have to start limiting her freedom sooner than I planned. Well, it wouldn’t be a worthy game if there weren’t unexpected obstacles to winning.

And I would win.

---