Page 38 of Paradise

Pushing a digit against my puckered hole, he easily slips past the ring of muscle from how wet I am.

“Fuck,” I moan long and deep, the stretch and intrusion feeling painful in the most pleasurable way.

He slowly moves his finger—in and out, around, in and out, around—and then he adds a second, all while licking my clit.

As he moans underneath me, I yell from the pinch between my cheeks. But he does the same thing again, this time with both fingers, using them to stretch me, and then he adds a third.

I tense up, and he sucks my clit harder, using the pleasure to distract me from the pain. After he’s repeated his motions again to stretch me, he slowly pulls the digits from inside me and pats my ass with his hand. “Lift up, baby.”

I do as he says, letting him slide from underneath me to stand up, then I drop my pelvis back to the bed.

After a minute, he comes back and stands next to the bed. Smacking my ass hard, he growls in the back of his throat. “Come here.”

When I lift my head to look at him, I find him standing completely naked next to me, a bottle of lube in one hand and his rock-solid cock in the other.

My stomach flips, and I lick my lips as I slide my feet to the floor. He leans forward, kissing me hard enough that my jaw aches, then lifts me from the bed so I’m standing before him. When he pulls away, his pupils are blown, and he looks at me like he’s ravenous.

“Turn around and bend over,” he grunts, flipping the cap for the lube.

I do as he says, pressing my chest against the bed and bending over the edge. I grind my hips in anticipation, and Carson chuckles behind me as he drips some of the lube onto my asshole.

“You ready for this?”

I moan, “Yes.”

I look back at him, his face flushed and his lips curved into a smirk. His chest is tensed, the muscles that create pivots and crevices along his stomach glistening with sweat. His raw need for me makes my pussy clench.

Dripping some of the lube onto his dick, he then slowly slides his hand down the hard shaft. When his eyes find mine, he licks his lips and takes a step forward to position his cock in between my cheeks.

He slides it around, up and down my ass crack a few times so the head of his cock is completely saturated in lube, and then he pushes himself against my asshole.

I tense up in reflex, my body going rigid, and he uses his free hand to smooth down my ass cheeks.

“Take a breath and relax, baby.”

I breathe in through my mouth, and as I blow it out slowly through my nose, I relax my muscles again. Carson puts his hand around my waist and pushes against my ass again with the tip of his cock until it slips inside me.

Pain radiates from the inside of me and throughout my body, making me cry out. “Carson!”

He freezes his hips, only leaving the head of his cock inside me. “Take a breath, I’ll go slow.”

I do, repeating the same motions as before. In through my mouth, out through my nose, only this time, as I exhale, Carson pushes farther into me slowly.

Even as pain splinters through me, even as I feel like I’m being torn apart by his dick, I feel my pussy leaking and clenching as waves of pleasure ripple through me like a current. I breathe heavy and fast, willing my muscles to stay relaxed as he continues to push into me.

“You okay, baby?” Carson grunts, his teeth pressed so hard against his bottom lip that I can tell he’s holding himself on a tight leash so he doesn’t hurt me.

I blow out another breath, sliding my hand between my legs to stroke my clit to mix pain with pleasure. “Keep going.”

He grunts as he pushes forward again, and then pleasure explodes inside me. I moan loud, spreading my legs wider to give him more room, then I grind my hips against him as I push backwards, taking him farther into my ass.

“Fuck!” He grabs my hips, meeting my thrust with his own until I feel his balls against my pussy.

I scream, burying my face against the bed. “Oh myGod.”

He doesn’t move, just keeps his cock sheathed inside me and bends forward to kiss along my spine. “Does it feel good, little sister?”

I feel myself tighten around him as I moan again, my entire body burning and throbbing with tiny sparks that vibrate on my skin. “Carson, holy fucking shit.”

---