Page 19 of Out Matched

He grins. “All yours.”

And so I take over, wrapping my lips around the head of Theo’s dick. It’s challenging at first, and my jaw protests the strain a bit as I sink down lower, but I push past the discomfort to take more of him, and eventually it eases.

“Do you have condoms? Lube?” I hear Alex ask.

“Yeah, in the-oh, fuck,” he groans as I apparently hit a particularly good spot, “Nightstand drawer. I think they’re still good.”

I hear footsteps, a little shuffling, then, “Yeah, these are good for another six months.”

Theo lets out a little hiss and I feel his fingers in my hair. Gently, he draws me away, panting hard. I look up at him in confusion, but he just shifts to the side and beckons Alex over.

I take the hint, and once Alex is in place, I start to work sucking him off. He’s a little less girthy than Theo, so it’s a little bit easier on my jaw, but he makes up for it in some extra length that I have to be careful not to choke on.

While I do, Theo takes a condom from Alex and rolls it on, and I reach out to stroke his sheathed cock while I’m blowing Alex.

It feels like both the dirtiest, sluttiest thing I’ve ever done and the most natural, comfortable thing in the world. The awkwardness I’d expected had never come, and all of my fears were blasted away by their touch.

After a while, they pull me to my feet and Theo hoists me off my feet like I’m weightless, tossing me right back into the center of his bed. I squeal and giggle, but my laughter is pretty quickly silenced when he leaps atop me and kisses me, stealing my breath.

I hear the ripping of another foil packet and assume that Alex is rolling on his own condom. But I’m a little preoccupied, as Theo is carefully guiding his cock into place between my thighs.

I tense a little bit, my nerves flaring again, and he freezes. “You ok?” he asks, “Did I hurt you?”

I shake my head, and he searches my face with that deep blue gaze. “I can stop if you don’t want to do this,” he says.

I can tell he means it. Even if he’d rather die than stop right now, if I said the word, he’d back off. And a single glance at Alex reveals the same. If I called this off, right now, even after all we’ve already done, they’d shut it down without hesitation.

It only makes the moment that much more special. And I have no intention of stopping them. So I shake my head again. “Just nervous,” I admit, “It’s uh…it’s been a long time since I’ve done any of this.”

“Well, your skills are definitely not rusty, if it’s any consolation,” Alex quips.

I laugh. “Thanks.”

“He’s right, though,” Theo murmurs, running his thumb along my lower lip, “You’ve got a talented mouth, little lady.”

My face flames. “You going to keep kissing my ass, or are you going to screw me?” I ask, raising an eyebrow.

I sound far more cocky than I’m really feeling, but the challenge seems to have the desired effect. Theo smirks and after taking a moment to position himself again, I close my eyes and he begins the long, slow slide into me.

I’m so wet and ready that I’m kind of surprised by how easily he manages to shove that monster in me, but the foreplay has done its job. I’m expecting him to move, but to my surprise, he just kind of shoves it in and then freezes. But when I open my eyes, I see that Alex is behind him with the lube bottle. From where I’m lying, I can’t see all that well, but when Theo grunts in pleasure, it’s pretty easy to figure out that Alex is teasing his ass with fingers slicked in lube.

It's a new and different sight and I like it. It’s a turn-on to watch this strong, dominant guy getting dominated a little himself.

His hips pump a little as Alex teases, involuntary bucking, and each time, I whimper. But before long, apparently Alex has decided that Theo’s warmed up enough for him, and I listen to the sounds of pleasure as he finally buries his cock in Theo’s ass.

Theo’s expression contorts in pure pleasure. “Holy fuck,” he gasps, “Holy fuck, this is so good.”

Thinking about it, he’s probably in the best position of all of us. I’ve never tried anal, and even if I did, I know it’s not the same as it is for guys. But even so, the look on Theo’s face definitely sparks my curiosity a little, and I wonder if maybe someday I could ask them to try it with me.

And somehow I don’t doubt that there will be a next time.

But when they really start to move, my curiosity is quickly forgotten, because all I can think about is how fucking good they’re making me feel.

Theo’s dick fills me, and every pump hits spots inside me that leave me seeing stars, and the angle he’s positioning himself at has him striking my clit with every thrust. I feel the pleasure building quickly, and soon I’m digging my nails into his flesh. “I’m gonna cum,” I whimper, “Please don’t stop, I’m so fucking close.”

“Me too,” he rasps.

“That’s right,” Alex grunts, “I want to watch you two cum for me, together.”

---