“I see all the little hickeys I gave you are gone.” She sighs as I trace my fingertips over the top of her chest. I push her breast up and kiss and suck the soft skin underneath. “I think I’ll give you a new one right here.”
Epi slides her hand into my hair, drawing me closer to her breasts, while Case moves down her body, settling himself between her splayed legs.
“Fuck,” he hisses as he gets another taste of her. “Like cotton candy.”
“I know,” I murmur, alternating between places kisses against her breasts, sucking and leaving little love bites behind and claiming her mouth, plunging my tongue deep between her lips, mimicking what Case is doing to her below. She loves all of it, moaning and writhing underneath our ministrations.
“You want my cock, baby?” I ask as I pull back to sit up on my knees.
Her eyes grow wide, and she licks her lips. “Please.”
“Open up.”
When she does, I slide my cock past her lips, closing my eyes as her wet, hot heat envelopes my sensitive flesh. “Oh, baby, you feel good.”
She grips me tightly, moaning her pleasure as Case brings her to the edge. I can tell she’s close to climaxing by the way she jerks and sucks greedily at my cock.
“Fuck.” I grip her hair and thrust my hips faster as I come, opening my eyes to find Lee kneeling on the bed on the other side of her, his hands roaming over her breasts, pinching and plucking at her nipples as she slides her hand up and down his length. Next to him on the mattress is lube and a dildo about half the size of us and perfect for stretching her.
Epi swallows my cum seconds before she cries out, her lips parting as she fists my cock and rides out her own orgasm, overflowing and soaking Case’s mouth. He comes up from between her legs, wiping his mouth and grinning like a goon. “Damn, I love how you come, sweetheart. Like a gusher candy.”
Lee climbs off the bed at the same time Case changes places with him, lying parallel with Epi. He cups her face and kisses her, mixing her arousal with any trace of my cum left on her tongue. Kissing her breathlessly, he rolls onto his back, bringing her with him, Lee helping by bringing her leg over to straddle him.
Once she’s laying on top of Case, Lee smacks her ass. “On your knees, pet.”
Case releases her as she comes up, glancing over her shoulder. “Are you going to spank me?”
“No.” He shows her the dildo. “Porter’s going to prep you with this while Case fucks you.”
Her eyes grow wide. “With that thing?”
I chuckle. “Baby, that’s half the size of us.”
“Ride Case’s cock, pet, and relax.” Lee places his hand on her back and pushes her forward at the same time I climb off the bed to stand behind her. I grab the lube, dripping it over the crack of her ass, letting it slide down as Case grabs her ass cheeks and spreads her wide for his cock.
I rub my thumb over her puckered hole in tight little circles until she visibly relaxes, arching her back as Case slides in and out of her at a torturously slow pace. Pouring another two drops of lube onto her ass crack, I change from my thumb to my middle finger, pressing and prodding until I push my first knuckle in—sliding in and out until my entire finger is sucked in tight. I thought Lee was going to take her virgin ass, but considering he gave me the dildo, it looks like I will get those honors. He wouldn’t have me prepping her if he didn’t want me to go first.
Case, being the first inside of her tonight, will obviously be the first one to mark her with his seed, another first Lee won’t get. Part of me wonders why he’s willing to give either of those up to us, when I know being first speaks to his primal nature. But then, I remember who I’m dealing with, and he’s probably more concerned about being gentle her first time, which I am the most prone to be out of the three of us.
Pulling my finger out of her ass, I’m pleased when she wordlessly arches her back as if to ask me for more. Lubing the dildo, I press the tip against her hole and push forward slowly, the gasp leaving her mouth my first indication she’s tensing up, the groan coming from Case’s lips, my second.
“Relax, pet,” Lee says, stroking her hair back from her face and tilting her chin up to claim her lips. She whimpers as he steals her breath away, Case’s fingers digging into her hips as I slowly push and pull the silicone coated dildo in and out of her ass inch by inch. This dildo is only five inches long, a good two and a half to three inches shorter than any of us, and only half as wide. But as expected, she loves it—the tension in her shoulder blades loosening as she grows used to the foreign sensation.
“Do you like it, baby?” I lean forward and kiss her ass cheek, biting her gently.
“Mmhmmm,” she moans.