I hold my hand out for the whip and Layton drops it lightly against my palm, then he moves across the room to stand with the other men.
 
 “Go,” I croak out.
 
 “Stay,” she says calmly. “I want you all to witness this.”
 
 “Fuck,” I moan. “Princess, please.”
 
 Silence.
 
 She has nothing left to say and if I don’t do this, she will leave me. I don’t know which is worse right now. My heart is hammering in my chest when I whisper, “Have you been a bad girl, Princess?”
 
 Her tense shoulders relax, and I see her take a deep breath.
 
 “Yes,” she says, exhaling slowly.
 
 I shuffle around so that I’m facing her back. I can see our initials etched into her skin by Layton the other night.
 
 “What have you done?” I ask, forcing my voice to steady out.
 
 “I have betrayed the men I care about,” she whispers. “The men that I lo—love.”
 
 I cast my glance to the other three men, who aren’t moving a muscle. No. This is all on me. I feel sick.
 
 “How so?” I ask.
 
 “I let another man touch me,” she says.
 
 “No,” I say, shaking my head vehemently. “Ruby. No!”
 
 “I allowed another man inside me. I betrayed the men I love.”
 
 “Dammit,” I shout at her. “What are you doing?”
 
 Nothing.
 
 I pull my arm back and whip her as lightly as I can, knowing she will only say it again and again and I can’t hear it. My stomach clenches into a tight ball.
 
 “Harder,” she murmurs.
 
 “No.”
 
 “Harder. I fucked another man,” she spits out harshly.
 
 “Ruby!”
 
 “Harder, Daddy. I need this.”
 
 “Fuck!” I roar at her and whip her again, this time a bit harder. I know exactly how to wield this fucking instrument. I know exactly how much force to use to not hurt her and how much force will break the skin.
 
 “Again,” she says steadily.
 
 Feeling the bile rise in my throat, I do as she asks.
 
 She doesn’t utter a single sound. She just stands there.
 
 “Anything else, Princess?” I croak out.
 
 “I killed a man,” she says.