Page 34 of Thanksgiving With Dad's Best Friend

We lie entangled for a few minutes, my cock still inside her. The excitement never seems to wear off with her. I want to do this again, but I know we need to talk. She gasps as I remove myself from inside her, looking disappointed at my absence. I stroke a strand of blonde hair off her face.

“You’ll always be mine…we’re going to make this happen, I swear to you. I’m not going to let you slip away.”

Lexi tugs her panties back up to cover her decency, smiling sleepily at me. “I know…it’s going to be perfect. We’re going to be so happy.”

I lean in to kiss her feverish lips. She’s still hot from the moment we just shared together. My hands tangle in her hair. Though I’ve pulled up my pants to hide it, my erection is quickly returning. Having her once is never enough to fully sate my appetite for her. But I guess when it comes to Lexi, I’ll never be fully satisfied.

I’m about to kiss her again when I hear a noise. I sit up straight, but not quick enough to hide as the door flings open. Eddie stands before us, his face red with anger. He knows exactly what we were doing.

And now, things are about to get bad.

Lexi

I squeal in shock, trying to cover myself up. I can’t believe my father has just walked in and caught me with his best friend. Worse still, I can see that it’s not just anger on his face.

It’s hurt.

“I knew something wasn’t right,” my father says, shaking his head. His voice breaks as he speaks. “I wanted to believe I was making it up in my head…but now I can see that you’ve both betrayed me.”

“By wanting to be together?” Flynn asks sharply. “You think you know what’s happening here, but you have no clue, Eddie. Why can’t you give us a chance to explain.”

My father is shaking with rage. “Why should I give you an opportunity to talk when all you’ve done is lie to me? I trusted you with my daughter. I wanted you to get close because you’re my best friend. But not like this. Never like this…”

I feel a stab of guilt in my heart as I retreat closer to Flynn. I’ve never seen my father look this angry before. I can tell that I’ve truly hurt him, but it’s not fair. This isn’t just some reckless fling. This means something to both me and Flynn. Hell, moments before he came into the room we were planning a future together. I can see myself marrying Flynn and having his babies. What’s so wrong about that?

“Dad…I know you’re angry. But there are two sides to every story. We couldn’t tell you about this because we knew you’d react badly.”

Dad turns to look at me, breathing hard. “Then what does that tell you, Lexi? If you knew it would hurt me this much, then maybe you shouldn’t have done it.”

“But what about what I want, Dad? Don’t you want me to have someone to care about me? Don’t you want someone you can trust looking after your daughter?”

Dad laughs bitterly. “Trust? You think I can trust either of you ever again? You’ve been treating me like a fool! You’ve barely even tried to cover your damn tracks!”

Flynn’s face is flushed with anger. “You’re the one who came bursting into the room without being invited. It’s an invasion of privacy, Eddie. And quite frankly, what we do together is none of your business.”

“She’s my daughter! The one person that should be off-limits to you…it’s an unspoken agreement, Flynn?” Eddie shakes his head. “You crossed a line, and for that I can’t ever forgive you. You’ve corrupted my little girl. Lexi, put some damn clothes on. We’re leaving.”

“She’s not going anywhere,” Flynn growls, finally standing up to square up to my father. “I’ve tried to be patient with you because you’re my friend, but you’re taking this too far. I care for your daughter. She cares for me too…you don’t get a say in this.”

Dad is shaking as he looks at me. “I won’t ask again. Get dressed.”

I pull the sheets up around me defensively. “No, Dad. I’m not leaving. Perhaps you need to go…calm down a little…we can talk about it in a few days.”

He shakes his head in disgust. “Absolutely not. I’m not leaving you here alone with him. I’m not allowing this to continue any further.”

Flynn grabs my father by his shirt, fury blazing in his eyes. “I told you…this isn’t your decision. Lexi is an adult. She can do what she wants. Now back the fuck off before I do something I’ll regret.”

“Flynn, no!” I cry out. I don’t want him to hurt my father. He releases him from his grip, though I can tell he’s only doing it for my benefit. As my father backs up a little, he looks both shocked and a little scared. He looks my way, his anger replaced with hurt.

---