Page List

Font Size:

“Are you certain?” one of the girls asked with a snicker. “Maybe she stole you from some other family and she’s been fattening you up just to eat you.”

It was at this moment that Ivy decided to intervene, appearing at her sister’s side with her hands clenched into claws, her back hunched, and her eyes crossed. She did a wonderful impression of a witch from the Grimm stories. “Perhaps,” Ivy replied with a malevolent grin. “Would you care to come inside and ask her?”

When she went to unlatch the gate to let them in, the girls shrieked and bolted down the road. Ivy cackled at the sight.

“Dummies,” she said. “Mama would never stoop to eat one of them.”

Ivy went about her business as if nothing had happened, but Rose couldn’t let it go. She marched down the drive to the cottage and stomped up the stairs to Sadie’s bedroom, where her mother was sitting at her vanity, getting ready to greet the day.

“Hello, darling,” Sadie gave off a warm golden glow only her oldest daughter could see. Rose always imagined it was the color of love.

“There were two girls outside the gate. They said you’re a witch.”

Sadie laughed, and Rose knew it was genuine. If her mother wasn’t afraid of the word, she wouldn’t be, either. “Maybe they’re right.”

“Are you a good witch or a bad witch?” asked Rose, who had recently devouredThe Wonderful Wizard of Oz.

“I’m not sure,” Sadie replied. “Is a thunderstorm good or bad?”

Rose’s nose wrinkled. It was a ridiculous question. “Neither,” she said. “It’s nature.”

Sadie shrugged. “So am I,” she said.

“Am I a witch?” Rose asked.

Sadie made a show of examining her daughter from head to toe, then spinning her around in a circle. “Not yet,” she pronounced. “Would you like to be?”

“Will I be able to make magic?”

“Why bother making magic when you can use the magic that’s all around us?”

Rose looked around the room as if hoping to spot some. “Where?”

“How about here?” Sadie reached for the vase that stood on the corner of her vanity and plucked a bright yellow flower from the arrangement. “This is freesia. It produces a fragrance that’s irresistible to both bees and humans. For thousands of years, women have used the scent of flowers like these to lure lovers. Bees turn the plant’s pollen into golden syrup. We can mix that honey together with a few humble ingredients and transform it into cake. Flowers possess some of nature’s most powerful magic. And if you know what you’re doing, there are ways to multiply that power tenfold, which is very helpful if you’re concocting an aphrodisiac.”

“What’s an aphrodisiac?” Rose asked.

“A potion you give to someone you want to lust after you.” Sadie winked at her.

“That doesn’t sound fair—to make someone love you.”

Her mother reached out and brushed Rose’s creamy cheek. “Lust isn’t love, darling. And don’t worry,” she said. “I doubt you’ll ever have need of an aphrodisiac.”

AT TWELVE, ROSE DIDN’T KNOWwhat her mother meant. By her nineteenth birthday, she’d turned down six marriage proposals from men to whom she’d barely spoken a word. Gifts arrived by messenger every day and were always sent back unopened. Those slipped under the estate’s gates were tossed back over. Rose was presentedwith flowers whenever she walked down the street. She always refused them. People whispered that a young man from Mattauk had thrown himself in front of a train after Rose spurned his advances. The fact that no one could ever remember the young man’s name did little to stop the spread of the story.

Outside the Duncan family, Rose’s beauty was seen as a blessing. God must have chosen to favor her for a reason, the townsfolk imagined. No one ever doubted she was as lovely on the inside as she was on the outside. The truth was, Rose was no better or worse than anyone else, and she’d come to believe she was utterly cursed.

“It’s so annoying,” Rose complained miserably one evening when the girls were dining alone with their mother. “Ivy and I can’t do half the things we’d like because the men in town are always following me around. They say they’re in love, but they don’t even know me.”

“I do miss the days when people were scared of us,” Ivy mused.

“So do I,” Rose said. “I honestly don’t understand why anyone would want to be beautiful.”

Sadie filled her wineglass. “You don’t?” she asked. “Have I kept you that sheltered? Beauty is the only power women out there are allowed to have.”

The girls knew very little of the outside world, and what little they knew made them less inclined to spend time there. “What do you mean?” Rose asked.

“The men who run the world forbid women to make money or hold public office. Most universities won’t accept women as students. Many of us barely know how to read. They keep our kind poor, uneducated, and dependent. Beauty is the only way for most women to better their lots in life. If you’re pretty enough to have options, you might get lucky and pick a good husband. That is, if you’re allowed to choose for yourself.”