Before she can utter another word, King secures the blindfold, taking away her sight and allowing us to remove our masks. “Without your sight you are forced to rely on your other senses, which will heighten everything we are about to do to you and make you feel everything,” I say as I glide my hands up her legs, loving how gooseflesh dots her skin. As I crest the apex of her thighs, her breathing turns choppy and her chest rises and falls rapidly. Both Bray and King are smiling down at her, but Bray’s the first to lean down and capture her nipple in his mouth, causing her to scream out in ecstasy.
I slide a finger through her folds and groan when I feel how wet she is already and we haven’t even touched her yet. This girl is blowing my fucking mind and the fact she is willing to try anything and trusts us to guide her is fucking exhilarating. To find a woman like this is so fucking rare, she is fucking rare indeed. I slowly push my finger inside her. She tries to clamp her legs closed but the spreader bar does its job and keeps her legs open. When I curl my finger inside her, she arches her back off the bed and cries out in pleasure.
“You look like a good slut laying there and taking everything my brothers are doing to you,” Kingston purrs in approval. I bend down and swipe my tongue through her drenched cunt and suck her clit into my mouth.
“Holy shit!” she screams out. I flick my gaze up to see my twin undoing his slacks and pushing them down his legs, his cock rock hard and his piercings on full display. Her moans fill the room but the second Kingston turns her head to the side and shoves his dick down her throat, they are muted. Bray releases her nipple with a wet pop and grins at the sight of her choking on our brother's dick. I can tell he is thinking the same thing as I am.
She fits us perfectly.
“Tonight you will get to feel all three of us moving inside you and you’re going to take our cocks like a good little slut.” She’s a quivering mess and it’s clear she can’t even string two fucking words together to reply, but I know my brother and Brayden will bring this all to a stop unless she vocalizes her wants. “Answer me, you whore, or I’ll make him stop eating your dirty cunt!” he bellows, causing her to suck in a sharp breath and choke on Kingston’s cock.
“Hmm hmm,” is the only answer she can give, thanks to King not pulling his dick out of her mouth, the greedy fucker.
“Flip her over, I want her on her hands and knees.” At Bray’s command, Kingston pulls out of her mouth this time and I lean back. King pushes into a sitting position while Bray strips off and climbs on the bed behind her, she shivers when she feels his naked flesh against her own. I lean forward and brush my lips against the shell of her ear as I say,
“His cock is so hard for you, birdy. He’s going to tear that fucking pussy open and force his way inside you until you feel nothing but himandus.” Her soft gasp has me smiling. Once Brayden is in position, we remove the spreader bar then flip her so she is straddling him. Once she is settled, I step back and strip my clothes off, eager to feel her body pressed against mine and finally be able to slide inside her and feel her milking the fuck out of my cock as she comes. I was a good brother and allowed Brayden to have her pussy and tonight, I’m getting that ass. My twin may have taken her virginity but I’ll be the first man to ever take her ass, and knowing that shit has me puffing my chest out and wanting to beat my fist against it like I’m King-fucking-Kong.
“Lean forward and brace yourself against him, birdy.” She does as I say eagerly. I reach for the tube of lube, grab the butt plug and lather it up. I part her cheeks and my mouth salivatesat the sight of her tight muscle wall, it’s practically begging me to breach it and mark her as ours.
NINE
MOLLY
My breath hitches when I feel the cool metal prod against my hole. Hands run up and down my back soothingly, I’m tense and trying to relax but it’s fucking hard. This is all new to me and I should be terrified but… I’m not. I feel safe and secure with these three, which is fucking absurd since I don’t even know their damn names!
Yet, here I am, handing my body over to them and trusting them to know what they are doing.
“Lift your hips,” one of them barks at me. I do as he says and moan when I feel the guy beneath me rub his cock through my dripping folds.
“I want you inside me,” I pant. That earns me a smack on the ass. I gasp in surprise but when he massages the sting away I find that I enjoyed that shit and want him to do it again.
“You don’t call the fucking shots in here, you filthy bitch, we do.” Jesus, his crass words have me clenching on air and the need to feel all three of their cocks inside me intensifies. The whole thing about having my sight taken from me and not knowing who they are only heightens my need for them. All week I have been dreaming about having them again and now, I finally get that.
“Sink down on my fucking cock.” I start to tremble in anticipation but the second I feel his head breaching my entrance an inferno erupts inside me and liquid fire flows through my veins. The feeling of him stretching me out and slowly filling me as I sink down on him, the burn is compelling and addictive. “Fuck, she’s so tight.” The gritty tone in his voice empowers me and emboldens my movements.
I feel like a fucking goddess and need these men to worship me and show me what they hide from the rest of the world. I want their darkest desires and wants, I need them to teach me!
“Fuck, it feels so good,” I cry out when I sink down on him completely. The sting of pain mixed with the pleasure of feeling him inside me is a heady mix. I scream so fucking loud when the guy behind shoves the butt plug in my ass without warning—tears prick my eyes and pain explodes throughout my body. “That fucking hurts!” I cry.
The person beneath me grunts and thrusts his hips, drawing my attention away from the pain and forcing me to focus on the feelings he is directing me to feel. “Open your mouth and suck my brother's cock while you ride me like a good little slut,” he snarls. I open my mouth and instantly gag around the guy’s girth, he’s large and thick. The salty taste of his pre-cum hits my senses and I moan. I tug against the cuffs, wanting to reach out to him but the guy beneath me holds my hands against his chest.
“Ahhh!” I groan around the cock in my mouth when the butt plug is pulled almost all the way out, then pushed back inside me.
“Be grateful I’m being nice and stretching this ass out instead of making you take my cock right now,” the guy behind me says it like he is doing me a favor. “You better get used to this because in a minute, you’re about to have the full force of all three us filling every one of your holes.” His threat has my pussy quivering and hunger coursing through me like a damnavalanche ready to wipe out an entire town. Hands grip my waist and help lift me up and down, as spit drips down my chin and I try my best to find my rhythm with both guys. Just as I do, I fuck it up when hands grip my ass and part my cheeks.
“Relax, birdy, we’re going to make you feel so good,” the guy behind me says. “Deep breaths or it’ll hurt.” I try to do as he says, but it’s fucking easier said than done. When I feel him remove the butt plug and press the head of his cock against my hole, my mind blanks of everything. I have wanted to experience something like this for a long time and now that it’s happening, I have no idea what the fuck I’m supposed to do but Jesus Christ am I willing to learn.
The burn roars to life as he presses forward slowly, stretching my hole out to accommodate his size. When I begin to whimper, the guy in front of me pulls his cock out of my mouth, then cups my face between his hands as I pant.
“Relax, you’ll be fucking grateful for the pain when they mix it with pleasure. Focus on the way my brother feels inside that little cunt and how he’s going to fill it with his cum and mark you again as ours.” His words are like a balm, and suddenly the pain becomes a distant thrum as I focus on how good he feels inside me… how perfectly he fits like he belongs there.
I would be a liar if I said I didn’t enjoy running my tongue along the guy’s cock I was just sucking, because those piercings are fucking hot. I want to see them and stroke my finger along those bars and watch him tremble from my touch.
“Fuck, birdy, this ass is so tight, baby,” the guy behind me groans.
“The deeper you get the tighter her pussy clamps down on me,” the guy under me answers.
“Fuck, boys, revenge never looked so sweet,” the guy holding my face says. Before I can mull over his words too much, I cry out in pain as the guy pushes inside me further, stretching myhole to the point I fear he will tear me in half. I’ve stopped breathing, unable to focus on anything aside from the pain radiating through me.