Page 39 of My Song for You
“But is it mandatory to include it?”
“My guess is no. I’m sure that when some babies are born the mother has no idea of the father’s identity.”
A smile twitched at the corner of my mouth at what she was implying.
Her head tilted slightly to the side, not enough to be noticed by most, but enough for me to recognize I didn’t have long to come up with a plausible lie. “Is there any particular reason why you’re asking?” she said.
“Not really. The drummer from one of the bands I used to hang out with just found out he has a kid.” I inwardly cringed. The lie wasn’t even in the neighborhood of answering her question.
“A drummer? Or is there something I should know that you aren’t telling me?” Those astute eyes homed in on me again, and I squirmed, just like I had when I was a kid and was trying to get away with something.
I formed a smirk on my face that I prayed was convincing enough. “No one has claimed I’m a dad, if that’s what you’re asking.” I pushed away from the kitchen table. “I should be going. I have an early morning meeting tomorrow.”
—
The next day, after I dropped Logan off at preschool, I returned to Callie’s apartment. The memory of four-year-old me in the photo wouldn’t let go. I wandered around the place, unsure what I was looking for. Maybe a photo of Logan’s biological father. Some proof the guy existed. And yes, I was a tad bit curious about how much he resembled me.
The search started out casual. I just scanned the photos displayed around the apartment, where anyone could stumble across them. The pictures of Callie’s parents filled me with sadness. Her mother and father had been like second parents to me. There were a few things they knew about me that my own parents didn’t, like who really had broken the bathroom window at my house when I was thirteen. None of Alexis’s pictures looked recent, but thinking back to a conversation she and I had once had back in my senior year of high school, this didn’t surprise me. At the time she’d been finishing her nursing degree and had planned to spend a few years volunteering with Doctors Without Borders or the Red Cross. Maybe she was still working overseas doing that.
When that search revealed nothing beyond pictures of Logan and Callie, and of Callie with her family, I entered her room. This was the first time I’d been in here. Like the rest of the apartment, it was furnished with what I’d guessed was her parents’ old furniture—all of it dark, reddish brown wood.
A Mac computer sat on the antique-looking desk that used to be in her father’s home office. It was an odd contrast of old and new. This computer was a top-of-the-line model, like the one my brother-in-law used when he worked at home. Callie was studying graphic design. It would make sense that she needed a computer like this.
Two framed pieces of artwork, which I was positive Callie had created, hung on the wall behind her bed. One was a rough cartoon sketch of two white ducks and a duckling. The parents—a heart pendant around the mother’s long neck—were gazing down at their duckling, proud smiles on their faces. The duckling was inspecting a worm on the ground.
The next picture was similar, except this time it had been created on the computer with lots of bright colors. Callie really was talented, not that I’d ever doubted that. It was a shame her talent had gone to waste now that she was no longer pursuing her dream of working for Pixar.
I turned away from her artwork and checked out the framed photos lined up on her oak dresser. If pictures of Logan’s father existed, they weren’t here. Like before, these pictures were of her family. Some were of her old friends from high school and from when she lived in San Francisco. There wasn’t a single photo of someone who could’ve been her old boyfriend.
The other photos were of me and Callie, taken before I began “dating” Alexis. In one, Callie was smiling, my arm around her shoulder. I was sixteen years old, Callie was twelve, and we had gone camping with our families. Alexis had opted out of the trip. Even back then Callie had been pretty. If things had been different and there hadn’t been that four-year age difference, I could’ve easily seen myself dating her when she was older. She was sweet, funny, and generous, and she had a way of making you feel good about yourself, even when you were having the worst day ever. And with Callie, it wouldn’t have been about the hot sex. It would’ve been something more real. Of course, if she had wanted to have hot sex at the time, I wouldn’t have complained.
The final picture caused my heart to trip over itself. In it, Alexis was holding a baby, and the love in her eyes was unmistakable. She must have been twenty-three years old in it. Her blond hair had been cut to shoulder length, and the baby couldn’t have been more than a few months old. The baby—a boy, if the blue blanket wrapped around him was anything to go by—had spiky brown hair. This must’ve been Logan.
My heart pinched that she could show so much love toward her nephew but hadn’t wanted to give our own baby a chance. Unlike Logan’s father, I would’ve been there for both her and our child.
I returned the photo and turned toward the door…except something held me back.
I wasn’t even sure what compelled me to do it, but I opened the top drawer of the dresser, wondering if Callie kept anything important there, the way I did. Fortunately, it didn’t contain Callie’s underwear. Despite what I was doing, even I had my limits. Going through a woman’s underwear drawer without her permission went well beyond creepy.
The drawer contained her jeans, neatly folded. I carefully pulled them out and found an envelope at the bottom labeledBIRTH CERTIFICATES. Underneath that was a large brown envelope that I ignored for the moment, homing in on what was on top.
I hesitated for several seconds, my hand hovering over the top envelope. I released a hard breath, picked the envelope up, and removed the birth certificates. The first document was Callie’s. Both her mother’s and father’s names had been included. The second certificate had Logan’s name on it, with Callie’s last name listed also as his. But Callie wasn’t listed as his mother—Alexis was.
My heart stopped beating as I did the mental math. There had to be a mistake. Logan couldn’t be my son.
I looked at where the father’s name should’ve been listed. Alexis hadn’t declared his name. What were the odds the baby hadn’t been mine after all?
Without thinking, I opened the other envelope. Inside it were legal documents. I skimmed them very quickly, realizing that they named Callie as Logan’s legal guardian.
The question about the odds that Logan wasn’t mine was not the only one firing around in my head. Why was Callie claiming Logan was her son? She had given up on her dream of working as an animator for Pixar, but why? And where was Alexis? Had she gotten up one morning and decided that being a mother wasn’t in her plans after all? That Doctors Without Borders was more important to her?
The questions kept circulating, but one specifically kept coming back—did Callie know who the father was, or had Alexis lied to her? Or maybe Alexis didn’t know who the father was. She liked sex. There could’ve easily been other guys. Any one of them could’ve been responsible for creating Logan.
I could’ve asked Callie, but what would I say? I was snooping in her drawers. She wouldn’t appreciate that. And Callie had been lying to me about her relationship to Logan. Who was to say she wouldn’t continue to lie about the real father, assuming she knew who he was?
I returned the birth certificates to the drawer and yanked my phone from my back pocket. I needed answers, and there was only one person I could think of who could give them to me. But I no longer had Alexis’s number, nor did I have any idea where she lived—or if she was even in the United States. Maybe she was working overseas as a nurse after all, and Callie was looking after Logan while she was gone. But then why was Callie lying about being his mother? And what kind of mother left her young child so that she could volunteer overseas for a few years?
I ignored the loud voice in my head pointing out that maybe Callie’s parents weren’t the only ones who had died in the car accident.
