Page 55 of Out of the Shadows
Hailey dug her nails into my shoulder, forcing my gaze, which had been transfixed on my cock pressed against her pussy, back to her face.
“I want you to fuck me, Colt. I need it. Claim what’s yours.”
Jesus Christ. She couldn’t have gotten me more fired up.
“Your wish is my command.”
I pushed myself up on one arm, my fist sinking into the soft mattress next to her delicate shoulder before I used my other hand to line up my twitching dick with her tight opening.Holy shit, this was really happening.I was about to lose my virginity to the girl of my dreams. Even crazier, she was about to lose her virginity to me.
“You good?” I asked, my eyes glued to her face, not wanting to miss even the smallest detail. Her shallow, warm breath brushed over my collarbone, triggering a brief, pleasant shiver, and when she nodded vigorously, I was done for. Nothing could make me back down now.
Breathing heavily, I hovered over her like a bull before mounting, suddenly struck again by how much smaller she was than me. How far she had to spread her dainty legs to accommodate my much thicker, less smooth ones. How wide the head of my cock looked pressed against her hole. It turned me into a feral beast, and although she hadn’t responded yet,I pushed forward slightly. She was soaking wet, yet it wasn’t as easy as I’d expected.
Hailey whimpered and squirmed, her impatience visible on her face. “Do I have to beg?”
My eyes narrowed, one eyebrow raised. “Patience isn’t your strong suit, it seems. Baby, I’m doing my best here not to hurt you, and it’s going to take every ounce of restraint I have. So how about you just let me handle this, huh? I’ll take care of you.”
Her eyes widened, pupils dilated, the honey color of her irises barely visible. Refocusing, I pushed my hips forward slightly, causing the tip to pop into her.Holy shit.If this was what it felt like, how was I ever going to last for the rest of it? I was fucked.
Hailey’s breath hitched, but then she slid her hands down my lower back, applying light pressure to spur me on.
“Fuck. Baby, I … You let me know if it hurts, okay?”
She nodded, and with a cursory glance down to where our bodies merged, I made a decision. A potentially insane decision, but we’d come this far already. If she didn’t like it, at least I would know and not try to live out any of my other fantasies on that front.
“Colt, come on, what—”
I cut her off by leaning back on my haunches and spitting straight on her pretty pussy, right where I was jammed inside her.
“A little bit of extra lube can’t hurt.”
Her lips parted slightly, her expression one of disbelief, and for a split second, I feared I’d screwed up.
“Fucking hell, you’re dirty. Iloveit.” As my spit trickled over her flesh, she reached down and spread it over the visiblepart of my shaft.
A small, slightly incredulous chuckle escaped me.I mean, could she get any more perfect?
Every nerve in my body was electrified, vibrating under the tension, and I couldn’t hold back any longer. I pushed myself farther into her, my freshly lubricated cock slowly plunging into her slippery cunt inch by motherfucking inch, as if in slow motion.
I met resistance and decided not to give her or myself much time to think about it. With a savage snap of my hips, I broke through the barrier, my pelvis suddenly flush against her, my heavy balls resting on her plump ass.
A sharp gasp tore out of her throat as I smashed through to claim her cherry, and she squeezed her eyes shut for a second.
“Uh-uh. Eyes on me. I’m sorry I hurt you, baby, I’ll make it better in a minute.”
She nodded, running a palm down my back as she said, “It’s okay, I knew this would happen. It’s not as bad as I thought.”
For a fleeting moment, concern for her overshadowed the sensations I felt at finally being inside her. My length was coated in heat, slick and red-hot, and somewhere in my lower back, a tingling sensation began to eat its way through my abdomen and into my groin.
Although the thrill of being inside her at last was mind-blowing, I wanted to move; my dick was throbbing in anticipation and eagerness. I was primed to fuck Hailey, and it took all my self-control to hold back.
“Fuck, you feel so good. I knew you’d be this perfect. Please tell me I can move, I need … Holy fucking shit, it’s so hard not to just pound into you.”
“You can move, just … just take it slow, okay?”
I grunted. “Of course, baby.”
I pulled out of her agonizingly slowly, my gaze drifting down, and watched in fascination as my wet length reappeared. I didn’t pull out too far, not wanting to get out of her so quickly and hoping that short thrusts would be less painful for her, for now.
