Page 28 of All I Ask
I’m frustrated because I should’ve let him go. It’s clear he didn’t want to talk and I don’t have anything to say—well, that’s a lie. I have a million questions I want answers to, but this place, this beach, is where we came when we needed to think.
Which we both clearly are grappling with.
Derek starts to walk toward me so I get to my feet, heading to meet him.
“Hi,” he says as we stand a yard apart.
“Hi. If you want the beach, I can leave,” I offer.
If he needed solitude, I’ll grant him that. I’ve been here for an hour already and feel no better than when I arrived.
“No, no. It’s fine, really. Not like the beach isn’t big enough for the both of us.”
“Then why did you leave?”
He straightens his back and looks off to the left. “I don’t know.”
“You saw me, right?”
“Yes.”
“Oh.” The air escapes my chest in a huff. “I get it.”
He steps forward. “No, you can’t possibly because I don’t get it.”
I don’t know what he means, but my pride can only take so much. He was my best friend. He knew me. He was the only person on my side and he walked away.
He let me down.
“I’m truly too spent for riddles or anything. I’ll head out, take the solitude.”
When I start to walk away, he grips my arm. “Stay.” Derek looks as shocked as I feel. “We don’t have to talk, but I’d like you to stay.”
My heart is racing, and as much as I want to be the one to walk away this time, I can’t. I’d never been able to before, and it seems I’m still not. It’s clear that things are weighing on him.
“Okay.”
We walk down to the shoreline, allowing the water to lap over our feet.
This isn’t the time to ask the one question that weighs on me so heavily…how?
Not why, because I know why. It’s obvious that Meghan forbade him from talking to me. Something happened, I still don’t know what, but we went from some kind of mutual understanding to radio silence.
At first, I thought maybe she knew that I loved him. Although, not a soul was aware of that, so it always seemed impossible.
Then I thought she suspected something was going on between us, but again, it made no sense. Yeah, he was coming to see me once a month, like he did the entire time we were in college, but that was part of our thing.
So it isn’t the why that has kept me up at night, it’s how.
How could he do it?
How could he turn and walk away when he was my best friend?
I look at his face as we walk, but he keeps his eyes down.
“I can practically hear you screaming at me in your head,” Derek says with a sigh. “I said we didn’t have to talk, not that we couldn’t.”
I cross my arms over my chest to hold myself together. Instead of asking about what happened all those years ago, I decide to start small. “What brought you out here tonight?”
