Page 54 of Until I Break

“You are not fat, Cassidy,” Oscar says.

“Considering there is enough for him to grab hold of and bruise me, I’m inclined to say you’re full of shit,” I say, covering my body with the blanket entirely. Feeling their eyes on my body is overwhelming when I am waiting for their judgment. I gasp when Collin yanks the blanket off me suddenly.

“Don’t scare her,” Oscar warns. He says nothing, but he grabs my hips and pulls me down on the bed until he can lean over my body and get in my face.

“I don’t ever want to hear that come out of your fucking mouth again. If I ever hear you degrade yourself again, I swear to God, I will sit your cute little ass on my face and make you come until you are begging for mercy. I’m a patient man, and I’ve been waiting a long time for you to leave that dumbass. If you want me to ease you into the idea of us, stop fucking pushing me because when I snap, I’ll fucking ruin you for every other man. No one will ever compare. Understand?” Collin growls.

A grin spreads across my face, not just because of his admittance of wanting me, but because I found his breaking point. Oscar laughs, and it only makes Collin growl at me again.

“Sorry, understand what? I’m having a hard time hearing you. All the fat got in the way,” I say innocently.

“You little shit,” he laughs as he tickles my sides. I squeal and squirm to get away from him, but he eventually stops. “You might be thicker than a Snicker, but your size means nothing when it comes to your worth. You are beautiful, sexy, smart, kind, and absolutely amazing in every way. If he can’t see what he had, then it’s his loss and our gain.”

“Our? What you…” I start to ask.

The world stops, and I melt into a puddle of my former self when he kisses me. His kiss tastes like sin and happiness. When he pulls away, I keep my eyes closed. “Any more questions, Pebbles?” Collin asks softly.

“No,” I whisper. When I open my eyes, he smiles.

“I meant it when I said I was a patient man. We’ve waited this long, so I can wait longer,” he says.

“Aww. You broke her,” Oscar laughs before leaning down to kiss my forehead. “You’ve been avoiding us for a while, so a lot has happened. Many contradictory things.”

“Oh,” I say.

“Alright. Her face is going to burst into flames if she blushes any harder,” Gunner laughs and pulls me up to sit before carefullyhelping me back into a shirt. He moves to put boxers on me, and I laugh.

“What?” Gunner asks with a smirk. “They’re clean. I promise.”

“Yep, the ones with shit stains are in the wash,” Collin muses.

“And here I was going to invite you to stay with us,” Gunner says.

“Us?” I squeak out.

“Oh yeah. You’re sleeping in here with me. The alternative is Oscar or the couch. You aren’t sleeping on the couch, and it would be torture to put you in bed with Oscar.”

“So brave for you to take on the torture,” I say simply. “How taxing it must be to be so close to…”

“Go ahead. Say it,” Collin says as he glares at me. “I’ll get the first orgasm in under a minute and have you screaming my name in two.”

“I can’t tell if he is joking,” I say.

“He is not,” Oscar says. “You should get some rest. Guys… let her sleep. It’s her first night here, so keep your dicks in your pants.”

“Or not,” I mutter. What the fuck is wrong with me?

“You worry about yourself, sir,” Gunner laughs. “She’s okay. Go get some sleep, Oscar.”

“Goodnight, Cass. I’m across the hall if you need me. Okay?” Oscar says to me.

“Thank you, Oscar,” I say. “Night.”

I am moved up to lay in the middle of the bed before both Collin and Gunner strip down to their boxers. When they get in bed with me, Gunner pulls me to his chest, and Collin moves in close to press himself against me. I try to be still, but I can’t. I’m fidgety and nervous. My traitorous pussy is aching to be filled. I am damn near ready to beg them to fuck me, and I don’t get it.

“Pebbles, you’ve got to stop wiggling around and go to sleep,” Collin mutters.

“Sorry,” I say, trying not to move. I do well until he fucks up and kisses my shoulder. I involuntarily push my hips back against him. I automatically try to pull away, but he grabs my hip and pushes against me, making me feel how hard he is. I gasp when Gunner presses himself against me, and I am suddenly pinned between two giant cocks and their owners.

---