The Art House Cinema looked different at night, its neon sign casting a soft blue glow over empty sidewalks.A lone employee—barely old enough to drive, by the look of him—was happy to let them in after hours when Sheila showed her badge.
Now the ancient projector hummed overhead as "Ghost Light" played to an audience of two.
Sheila and Finn sat in the middle row, sharing the armrest between them.The theater smelled of popcorn and history—it had been showing independent films since before Sheila was born.She remembered coming here as a teenager, watching foreign movies she barely understood but pretended to appreciate.
"Feels strange, doesn't it?"she whispered."Like we're kids sneaking in after hours."
Finn's hand found hers in the darkness."Except we're watching a psychological thriller about a murderer instead of making out in the back row."
"Who says we can't do both?"The joke felt good—a moment of lightness in the heavy air of investigation.But then the scene they'd been waiting for began to play out on screen.
The flickering light from the screen cast shadows across the nearly empty theater.The film's stark prison setting created a haunting backdrop as Micah Weller, the actor who'd gotten the role Thomas Rivera had auditioned for, sat against a prison wall, head tilted in that familiar pose.His prison uniform was deliberately shabby, his hands resting loose in his lap—exactly the position they'd found Thomas in.Even the lighting was similar, harsh overhead fluorescents casting dramatic shadows across his face.
The similarity to how they'd found Thomas made Sheila's chest tighten.She felt Finn's hand squeeze hers gently.
"You okay?"he asked.
"Just processing."She watched the scene unfold—the condemned man waiting to hear his fate, his stillness almost unnatural.The camera slowly pushed in on his face, catching every micro-expression.A guard's footsteps echoed down the corridor, growing closer.The prisoner didn't move, didn't even seem to breathe.Just that terrible, patient waiting.
"The staging is identical," Finn whispered."Even the angle of his head."
"Not identical," Sheila corrected quietly."Perfect.Like someone studied this scene frame by frame, memorized every detail."
She watched as tension built in the scene, the guard's footsteps stopping just out of frame.The prisoner remained motionless, but his throat worked as he swallowed.The camera held steady on his face, refusing to cut away.
"About Thomas.About Jessica.About how someone looked at them and saw...this.Saw them as characters to be posed in their own private performance."
The film's score swelled dramatically—strings and percussion building to a crescendo as the prisoner received news of his parole.The guard's voice was deliberately muffled, making the prisoner's reaction the sole focus.A single tear tracked down his cheek as the news sank in.The camera stayed brutally close, documenting every moment of his transformation from condemned man to free one.
On screen, the actor's performance was masterful—subtle shifts in his expression conveying disbelief, hope, fear that this might be a cruel joke.His hands trembled slightly as he raised them to cover his face.
But Sheila could only see Thomas Rivera's body, those same hands carefully arranged in his lap, that same head tilt captured with surgical precision.The killer hadn't just recreated this scene—he'd elevated it, turned murder into his own twisted form of method acting.
"Our killer didn't just watch this film," she said as the scene continued to play out."He studied it.Memorized it.Understood exactly what made this moment powerful."She gestured at the screen where the actor was finally standing, unsteady on his feet as he absorbed his freedom."And then he recreated it, detail by detail, using Thomas as his actor."
"But Thomas never got to finish his performance," Finn added grimly."Never got to experience that moment of release."
The scene faded to black, the score gradually dying away until only the sound of the prisoner's ragged breathing remained.In the darkness, Sheila could almost see Thomas Rivera's face, forever frozen in that moment of anticipation, waiting for a resolution that would never come.
As the movie continued, Sheila found herself growing reflective.
"Sometimes I wonder," she said quietly, "if this job is changing me.Making me see the darkness in everything."She turned to Finn, whose face was illuminated by the flickering light from the screen."Even this—sitting in a movie theater with you—feels different now.Tainted, almost."
Finn shifted in his seat to face her."Tainted?"
She shook her head."That's not the right word.I'm not trying to say this isn't special, it's just…" She sighed."I don't know how to explain it."
He was silent for a few moments.
"You're not alone in this, you know," he finally said.
"I know."She managed a small smile."That's probably the only thing keeping me sane right now.That, and Star's art show next week.Normal things to look forward to."
The scene changed.Sheila leaned her head against Finn's shoulder, breathing in the familiar scent of his cologne mixed with coffee and autumn air.
"Remember our second date?"she asked."Right here, watching that terrible French comedy neither of us understood."
"I was so nervous," Finn admitted."Kept trying to think of clever things to say about the cinematography."