Page 33 of Rookie Mistake

Well, she’s not mine, but I don’t know… maybe if she was, that wouldn’t be a bad thing.

The thought surprises me, but I’m so lost in her that I don’t even have time to really analyze what it means.

“I brought you a surprise,” I murmur, rising to my knees between her thighs and wiping the excess of her cum off my lips with the back of my hand. “You told me last night you wanted to try something…”

Trailing off, I reach into the pocket of my jeans and pull out the small butt plug I got for her, lifting it for her to see. Last night, when we were on FaceTime, she mentioned how much she loves when I stick my finger in her ass, and when I asked if she wanted to go any further with it, she rolled her lip between her teeth and gave me the sexiest fucking nod I’ve ever seen.

I swear I almost came in my pants imagining her bent over, taking my cock in her perfect, heart-shaped ass.

Fuckkkk. Me.

Which is why I immediately went to the nearest Hustler and spent thirty minutes picking out the perfect plug for her, to loosen her up so she can eventually take my cock. The plug is small and black, with a gem at the base that’s almost exactly the same shade of red as her lipstick that I love so goddamn much. When I saw it, I knew it was perfect for her. And I couldn’t wait to see it inside her.

Her eyes widen slightly when she sees me twirl it between my fingers, and my lip curves.

She looks surprised, but I can see the flicker of excitement burning in her eyes.

“What do you say we play, Trouble?”

I watch as her throat bobs, a rough swallow as her wild, heated gaze drops from me to the plug, and then she nods. With my free hand, I gently pull the panties from her mouth. “Consent is everything, baby. Need to hear you say it.”

“Yes,” she mumbles breathlessly with a nod.

“Tell me you want this plug in your ass,” I whisper, bringing it to her lips and dragging along her bottom lip.

Her fingers curl around my wrist. “I want you to use it.” Then she wraps her lips around the small plug, sucking it into her mouth and twirling her tongue around it while she holds my gaze.

Motherfucker, I think I like this girl.

My throat bobs as a wave of lust washes over me. She knows exactly what she’s doing to me.

She pulls her lips off the plug with a pop and reaches for my jeans, hooking her fingers in the waistband and hauling me closer until her hot little pussy is pressed against me, leaving behind a wet spot.

“Well, are you going to stand there, or are you going to fuck my ass, Davis?”

She flicks the button of my jeans open, dragging the zipper down until the fabric hangs open. My cock is straining against my boxers, the angry, red head peeking from the waistband, and when she sees the precum coating my slit, her eyes flood with heat.

I slide my hand around the back of her neck and crash my lips to hers, slipping my tongue into her mouth and kissing all the sass right off her lips, letting her taste herself on my tongue.

She’s a brat, but fuck, she’smybrat.

“Gonna fuck you right where you make your music, Zara. Every time you’re in here after this, I want you to think about how you came on my cock. How I filled both your tight little ass and your pussy at the same time.”

I spread her thighs wider, exposing her glistening cunt. Pretty and pink, so swollen from my lips that it makes my cock weep. I slide two fingers into her, gathering her wetness on the tips and bringing it to her asshole, coating the tight ring in preparation for the plug. My thumb circles her clit as I push my finger into her ass. Only the tip.

Her breath hitches, and then she whimpers loudly. The sound echoes off the walls, and I grab the panties, shoving them back into her mouth.

“Quiet, Trouble, or I’ll leave you empty and desperate to come. Be my good girl.”

A hungry, dark look passes over her face, and I smirk, pushing my finger in further, burying it to the knuckle as I massage her clit.

When she starts to relax, I add another finger, fucking her with both at once. Her hips roll as she arches her back, pressing her clit against my thumb and my fingers deeper into her ass. I rub the swollen bud in soft circles, slowly until I feel her muscles going lax.

I spit on her pussy, watching it trail down, covering her clit and dripping all the way to where my fingers are buried inside of her ass. Withdrawing them, I spread the wetness around her hole, then push my fingers deep, all the way to the hilt, before pulling them out and this time replacing them with the plug.

While steadily stroking her clit, I slowly push the plug through the tight ring of resistance until the tip slips inside.

It’s a little bigger than my fingers, but fuck, she takes it so good.

---