He also grabbed a couple of vibrators to keep nearby, just in case.
Now the only problem was, they hadn’t yet decided who would plunder which hole. Theycouldplay rock-paper-scissors again like he and Dayne did the first time they fucked out in the woods.
“Do you have a preference?” he asked Dayne.
“I want her ass.”
No surprise.
Cara raised a single eyebrow. “Who is smaller?”
Heath chuckled. “Good point. I guess that means you get what you want, Dayne.”
Dayne huffed, “There isn’t much difference between us.”
“Of course you’d say that,” Heath teased before glancing over at Cara. “You make the decision, then. Who do you want where?”
Her head tipped to the side as she considered that question. Finally, she answered, “Dayne isn’t as girthy as you, so…”
Heath snorted, then gave Dayne a toothy smile. “See? Told you.”
Cara sighed. “Why is dick size always a competition? It shouldn’t be since it’s not the size that counts but how you use it.”
In Heath’s opinion, size was debatable. He’d been with very small men who were very skilled and extremely large men who were horrible. He preferred the perfect combination. Like Dayne.
“And we’re both pros, right?” Dayne winked at her.
“I don’t have any complaints.”
“Umm. You did after I fucked your ass last time,” Heath reminded her.
“I was sore afterwards, that’s why.”
“And you weren’t as sore after Dayne fucked you there, right? That’s proof?—”
“Of nothing,” Dayne finished for him. He sighed. “Fine. I’ll live with my tiny dick as long as I get to claim her ass.”
The resort owner certainly did not have a small dick. But it was all in good fun to put the cocky man in his place. While Dayne wasn’t as cocky now as he had been months ago when they all first met, the man still had his moments.
Heath gave Dayne the tube of lube and a condom, keeping the other for himself. The three of them needed to sitdown soon and have a discussion about ditching the condoms. Cara was already on birth control pills and they had all been tested and cleared for STDs. Plus, none of them have had sex outside of their threesome. They could always don condoms if they invited anyone else to play with them for a night.
He made a mental note to have a discussion about this before the end of the weekend and they all parted ways.
After rolling on the condom and spreading the lube generously over his latex-covered cock in preparation, Dayne ordered Cara, “Get on the bed and on your hands and knees.”
As soon as Cara climbed on the bed and moved into position, Dayne tugged the thong portion of her teddy to the side, exposing her tightly puckered hole. Heath slowly stroked himself as Dayne liberally spread the lube on the outside before working some inside. Afterward, he plunged his fingers in and out of her, working it even deeper and making her groan in pleasure.
“Do you like that?” Dayne’s question sounded a bit tense. Since it had taken so long to get her to this point, he was probably as impatient as Heath.
“It feels so good.”
Dayne drove his fingers harder and deeper, giving her a preview of what was to come. Heath’s eyelids slid shut as he imagined his cock replacing Dayne’s digits.
“Remember how full you feel when we fuck you there? It’s going to be much more intense when we fill both holes,” Dayne warned. “We might stretch you to the point where you worry, but give it a chance. Let your body adjust to us. Remember to push out when I push in and try not to tense. It’ll only make it more difficult for allof us.”
Cara glanced over her shoulder at him. “You’ve done this before?”
“I have,” Dayne answered.