Page 48 of Marquess of Stone

Marian blinked, caught off-guard by this businesslike assessment of her social prospects. “I... see,” she managed, though in truth, confusion rather than comprehension was her primary reaction.

“However,” Nicholas continued, seemingly oblivious to her bewilderment, “such rehabilitation would require certain... structural advantages. A connection to an established family of unimpeachable standing. Resources sufficient to overcome lingering prejudice. A position that would render you beyond the reach of common gossip.”

Understanding began to dawn, a slow realization that sent conflicting waves of hope and disappointment crashing through her. “Nicholas,” she said, deliberately using his given name, a final test of the intimacy they had once shared, “what exactly are you proposing?”

The sound of his name on her lips seemed to reach Nicholas in a way his careful reasoning had not. He paused, something vulnerable flickering across his features before the composed mask returned. When he spoke again, his voice carried a different quality – not the calculated precision of business, but something more genuine, if still carefully controlled.

“I am proposing marriage, Marian,” he said simply.

The words hung in the air between them, weighty despite their quiet delivery. A nearby robin landed on the path, tilting its head inquisitively before continuing its search for sustenance, utterly indifferent to the human drama unfolding mere feet away.

“Marriage,” Marian repeated, the word emerging as barely more than a whisper.

“Yes.” Nicholas turned more fully toward her now, his posture straight-backed and formal despite the intimate nature of their conversation. “I believe such an arrangement would be advantageous for us both.”

Advantageous. The word settled like a stone in Marian’s stomach, cold and hard where moments before hope had begun to flutter. “I see,” she said, working to keep her voice steady. “And what advantages do you perceive in such an arrangement?”

If Nicholas noticed the sudden coolness in her tone, he gave no indication. Instead, he launched into what was clearly a well-considered presentation, each point articulated with the same precision he might use when outlining a business proposition to potential investors.

“For yourself, there would be immediate social rehabilitation. As the Marchioness of Stone, you would be elevated beyond the reach of common scandal. My family name carries sufficient weight to silence most critics, and those who persisted would find themselves unwelcome in circles where my influence extends.” He spoke with the casual confidence of a man accustomed to wielding significant social power, stating facts rather than boasting.

“Additionally,” he continued, “you would have access to resources that would allow you to pursue your intellectual interests without constraint. My library at Stone House is extensive and could be expanded in whatever direction you wished. You could correspond with scholars, patronize female authors, establish educational initiatives for young women – pursuits I understand you value.”

Marian listened in growing dismay, each perfectly logical point driving a deeper wedge between the reality of this conversation and the hope she had secretly harbored. This was not a declaration born of passion or even genuine affection; it was a contract being offered, a business arrangement dressed in matrimonial language.

“And what advantage would you derive from this... arrangement?” she asked, proud of how steady her voice remained despite the ache blooming beneath her ribs.

Nicholas’s expression remained impassive though something flickered briefly in his eyes – perhaps surprise at her question, or grudging approval of her practical consideration. “Several, in fact,” he replied with characteristic directness. “A wife of your intelligence and educational background would be an asset in both social and practical matters. Your perspective on various issues often differs from conventional wisdom in ways I find... stimulating.”

He paused, as if considering how much to reveal, before continuing in a slightly more measured tone. “I have reached a point in my life where establishing a household makes practical sense. My business affairs are well-ordered, my estates prosperous. The next logical step is to secure the succession, which naturally requires a suitable marriage.”

Suitable. Another cold, practical word that made clear the nature of his proposal – not love, not even particular desire, but suitability. Compatibility. Advantage.

“I see,” Marian said again, the simple phrase now carrying the weight of profound disappointment. “You present a most logical case.”

“I believe it is a situation where our mutual interests align perfectly,” Nicholas agreed, apparently mistaking her response for approval. “We share intellectual compatibility, similar views on many social issues, and have demonstrated an ability to enjoy each other’s company. These are more solid foundations for marriage than most of the ton can claim.”

A small, bitter laugh escaped Marian before she could prevent it. “Indeed. How very enlightened we would be, entering matrimony with our eyes wide open to its practical benefits, unburdened by such inconvenient complications as emotion.”

Nicholas frowned slightly, the first crack in his composed delivery. “I did not say emotion was absent from my consideration,” he corrected, a hint of defensiveness entering his tone. “I hold you in highest esteem and regard. Our interactions have been among the most satisfying of my recent experience.”

“High esteem. Regard. Satisfying interactions.” Marian repeated the words, each one falling from her lips like a small, polished stone. “Such passionate declarations would make any woman swoon with delight.”

“Marian-“ he began, but she cut him off with a sharp gesture, rising from the bench in a swift movement that sent startled birds fluttering from nearby bushes.

“No,” she said, emotion finally breaking through her careful control. “I will not sit here and listen to you dissect our potential union as if it were a business merger or a property acquisition. Marriage may be a practical arrangement for many, but I-“ She stopped, drawing a steadying breath before continuing more quietly. “I want more.”

Nicholas rose as well, his height allowing him to look down at her despite her standing position. “What more do you want?” he asked, genuine confusion evident in his expression. “I have offered you freedom from scandal, financial security, intellectual liberty – everything you have expressed value for.”

“Everything except love,” Marian replied simply, the word hanging between them like a challenge. “I will not bind myself to a man who sees me as a convenient solution to his need for an heir and an occasional intellectual sparring partner. I would rather face spinsterhood and all its limitations than wake each day beside someone who holds me inhigh esteembut does not love me.”

Something flashed in Nicholas’s eyes – surprise, perhaps, or a deeper emotion she could not identify. “Love is a poetic notion often used to disguise baser instincts,” he said carefully. “I offer something more substantial – respect, compatibility, shared interests.”

“And I decline,” Marian replied, her voice softening despite the firmness of her rejection. “I cannot fault your logic, Nicholas. Everything you say makes perfect sense. But I have learned through our adventures together that some experiences cannot be approached through logic alone.” She took a small step back, creating additional distance between them. “I thank you for your offer, but my answer is no.”

For a moment, Nicholas stood perfectly still, his expression betraying nothing of whatever thoughts might be racing behind that composed exterior. When he finally spoke, his voice had returned to the cool, controlled tone she had come to associate with his public persona rather than the man who had helped her cross items off her list.

“I understand,” he said, executing a bow of perfect correctness that nonetheless felt like a door closing between them. “I apologize for having taken up your time with an unwelcome proposition.”

---