Page 40 of Double Play

So that’s exactly what I do.

Lifting my lower half from the bed, I accept him as he pushes forward, his cock breaching my entrance as we both sigh in relief. I’m so ready, there’s barely even a stretch when he bottoms out, dragging his heavy length back out before driving inside again.

“Yes,” I moan. “Fuck me.” But he keeps a slow and steady pace, refusing to give me what I’m begging for. I try to buck up into him, but he wraps a hand around my hip, pressing me into the mattress so I can’t create the friction I need. A flustered, pitiful whine falls from my lips just as Hawk crawls up beside us.

“Is he being mean to you, baby?” he mocks. “Do you need more?”

I nod my head frantically, desperate for him to do something—anything—to cure the throbbing ache between my legs. “Mhmm.”

He reaches out, nudging Jackson’s shoulder as he lazily and deliberately thrusts into me. “Roll over. We need her on top of you.” Before I can even register his request, a thick arm bands around my waist and we’re switching positions so I’m straddling him. I seize the opportunity, immediately bouncing on his cock as my release blooms to life deep within me.

“That’s it, Princess,” he praises, bringing his hands to my tits and squeezing as I throw my head back in pleasure. “You look so beautiful right now. I love you.”

“I love you too,” I reply, barely able to form coherent words through the thick haze in my brain. Between everything that happened downstairs, the feel of him inside me, and the thought of what’s to come, I’m ready to explode again at any second.

I whimper loudly, my clit beginning to pulse against his pelvis as I feel the mattress dip behind me. Hawk’s minty breath ghosts along my cheek, and I savor the warmth of his body as he speaks much softer than I’m used to in these situations. “I’m going to get you ready. Keep riding and come whenever you want to. Use your safe word if you don’t like something, okay?”

Turning my head, I meet his gaze with mine, conveying all the trust I have in him with a single look. “Yes,” I reply, leaning back to kiss him one last time before lowering down so my chest is pressed tightly to Jackson’s. I resume my movements, grinding my clit against him as his hands slide around and spread my ass cheeks apart. Sparks of electricity prick on my skin, and I feel something cool and wet drip onto my tight hole, followed by the pad of Hawk’s finger gliding over it. I’m so close to coming that I barely even flinch as he presses forward, sinking all the way in and sending a bolt of pleasure right up my spine.

“Holy shit,” Jacks grits out. “You’re choking my cock. Let go for me, Arden. Fucking come.” My body listens to his command, detonating around him as I fall over the edge. I cry out, chanting their names over and over while I shatter, consumed by the feeling of them working together to give me everything I need.

It goes on forever, until I finally begin to return to awareness, registering the slow slide of them moving in and out as I recover. Soft praises come from each side of my head, and I sigh contentedly as I resume moving my hips back and forth languidly.

“There you go, Hellcat,” Hawk says, dripping more lube onto where we’re joined before pushing another finger inside. It feels incredible, the stretch a welcome sensation as my pussy continues to pulse against Jackson’s hard cock with aftershocks. “You’re doing so good opening up. Bear down for me.” I obey, and he gently works in a third finger, causing a deep, satisfied moan to rise up my chest before filling the air around us. I give him time to prep me completely as I become wetter and more desperate with every deliciously agonizing thrust. Just as I’m ready to beg for more, he pulls out, making me whimper in frustration.

“He’s just lubing up,” Jackson coos, his hands rubbing reassuring circles along my lower back as I continue riding him. His muscles are wound tight underneath me, and I’m sure he’s hanging by a thread, considering he’s the only one of us who hasn’t had a release yet. I press my lips to his, both of us opening up to deepen the kiss just as the head of Hawk’s cock presses to my asshole. I clench, but he curls himself over me, so close that all three of our faces are practically touching.

“We’re here, sweetheart,” he says into my ear. “Let us in.” I keep still, exhaling a shaky breath as I relax my body, focusing on the way their skin feels against mine in this monumental moment. Opening my eyes, I lock onto the bright green ones in front of me, the softness in them giving me everything I need to feel safe and adored. Hawk pushes forward slowly, his head stretching me much wider than his fingers did before I feel the small metal barbell notch through the tight ring of muscle. He stops, but that’s the last thing I want right now, because while there’s a slight burn, the indescribable pleasure far outweighs the pain.

“More,” I choke out. “I need more.”

THIRTY-THREE

JACKSON

“Fuck, you’re perfect,”I sigh, gritting my teeth as Hawk drives further into Arden’s ass, her satisfied moans ricocheting off my lips. He pauses when he’s buried to the hilt, and I have to take several deep breaths, so I don’t come early. Her pussy is tight as it is, but with him inside her too? I can’t even think straight. “Are you okay?”

“Mhmm,” she hums, her eyes rolling to the back of her head like she’s completely lost to the sensation of being filled by us both at the same time.

“You’re doing so good, baby,” he says from behind her, lowering his heated gaze to where they’re joined. “I’m going to move. Tell me if you need a break.” He slowly retreats, thrusting forward again as a satisfied moan works its way up her chest. He repeats the motion, making me grunt loudly as I continue to fight the orgasm that’s already starting to coil tightly inside me.

“Jesus Christ,” I hiss, unable to stop the words from coming out. “I can feel your fucking piercing. It’s insane.”

He grins over her shoulder, both of us moving opposite one another, sawing in and out as she mindlessly lets us use her. “Good. Maybe now you’ll stop talking shit.” I roll my eyes in response, but there’s no fucking way I’ll ever say another bad word about it, because it feels phenomenal through the thin wall that separates us.

“I love feeling you both inside me at once,” she whimpers. “Please don’t stop. I need to come so bad.” The desperation in her pleading tone has me ready to blow at any moment, and by the look on Hawk’s face as he picks up speed, he’s right there, too. Normally, I think we’d both be able to last longer, but the entire experience, paired with how tight she is when she’s stuffed with both of our cocks is making me feel like it’s my first time all over again.

“Please, please,please.” The chant sounds like a prayer as she begs us to push her over the edge, and the knowing glance my best friend tosses my way tells me exactly how this thing is about to end. The corner of my mouth tugs up in a coy grin before I get into character, ready to send her careening over the edge.

“That’s my sweet girl,” I say softly, lifting my hips from the mattress and thrusting into her warmth. “You’re taking us so well. So beautiful. I can’t wait to feel your cunt grip me when you fall apart. Do you want us to come inside you?” She nods her head rapidly, and I feel her inner walls flutter around me as they swell with her impending orgasm.

“Such a greedy cumslut,” Hawk says darkly, his mouth hovering right next to her ear. “Ready to explode at the thought of us filling her up. You going to purr for us when we breed both of your pathetic little holes at once, Hellcat?”

“Oh my God, yes!” she cries out, convulsing wildly as his words finally hit their mark, making her shatter into a million perfect pieces between us. She pushes down, frantically grinding her clit over the muscles covering my pelvis before arching into Hawk’s chest. A scream falls from her parted lips and her pussy closes in around me so tightly, there’s nothing I can do to stop myself from being pulled under right behind her. Electricity moves through me and an unintelligible string of curses falls from my lips as I come, white light flashing behind my eyes as my balls contract and release repeatedly, pumping everything I have into her. It’s intense—so much so, that I barely even register Hawk pushing in with one final thrust, his loud roar practically shaking the walls while his orgasm tears through him.

We ride it out together, moving as though we share a body until each of us is completely exhausted and unable to go on for another second. Arden collapses on top of me, her chest heaving against mine as she struggles to catch her breath. Her thighs shake, and my cock twitches with aftershocks, more thick ropes flowing into her as she greedily accepts every last drop. We lie there as we recover, both of us whispering gentle praises until she finally gives in to her exhaustion and falls asleep.

“I’m so fucking proud of you, baby,” Hawk whispers, coasting tender kisses along her neck and shoulders. “We love you so much, I hope you know that.” She hums in response, and my heart squeezes in my chest at the exchange, because it all feels so natural. I can barely even remember a time when it wasn’t true. I’ve loved this girl for most of my life, even before I knew what the word truly meant—but him not being a part of what we have now seems unfathomable. Like, without him, we’d always have a missing piece.

---