Page 39 of Resisting Temptation

She grabs for one and rips open the packet with her teeth. “I need you inside me now.” She rolls it on as I push her legs apart wider, bringing my mouth back to her lips as I push inside her.

“Oh, fuck, Noah.”

“Yeah, baby, let me fill you right up. I want you screaming my name tonight, Paisley.”

She whimpers as I thrust inside her, deeper with each movement. Collecting her legs, I hold them by the ankle in one hand, fucking her harder. Her cries of more and harder egg me on, taking me to a place where there is only us. A place where we don’t have huge obstacles standing in our way. Where she’s mine and I’m hers. Our bodies slap together, echoing through the room. “Tell me when you’re ready and Roger can join us,” I tell her, needing to know this is what she wants. I enjoy pushing her buttons, but I would never force her into something she didn’t want to do.

“Fill me up, Noah. I need it,” she begs me, so needy and desperate.

With her giving me the go-ahead, I pull out of her. I grab her little rabbit friend and a bottle of lube, then I’m back between her open legs, a wicked smile on my face. Fuck, this girl is like heaven. I spread the lubricant over her toy then hand it back to her. “You know what to do.”

She takes the toy from me, adjusting the setting, and pushes it inside herself as I get my cock all slippery. Fuck, it’s hot watching her play with herself. In and out she slides the toy, her eyes rolling back in her head. I could watch her all day, just stroking myself. But I’m not going to last much longer with how turned on she’s making me. I settle back between her legs, pushing a lubed-up finger into her tight puckered hole, followed by a second. She moans out loud as I stretch her, the vibrations from the toy making it all the way to my fingers. “Fuck me, what are you waiting for?” she begs, so desperate and needy for me, so perfect. “I want your cock in my ass, please, Noah.”

“That’s it, baby, beg me, tell me how much you need me to pleasure you.” My fingers keep working her.

Her face turns serious. “Noah,” she chastises. “Now.”

I smirk at her desperation, pulling my fingers free. Lining my cock up with her asshole, I ease the tip in. She arches her back off the bed. “Let me in, baby.” She’s so dang tight.

I take the toy from her and change the setting so it’s more of a dull pumping that throbs through her body, and I make sure her clit is fully stimulated. “Oh God,” she says, relaxing for me.

“That’s it, baby,” I say as I’m able to slide in a little further. “You feel so good. So tight.” When I’m all the way inside of her, I wait for her to catch up withme. Playing with the toy, I push it in then out, slowly applying pressure on her clit. I want her whole body alight with pleasure, for her to cum so hard she gets tingles through her entire body every time she sees me from now on. She can’t ignore me anymore. This thing between us is real, and it’s happening.

Focusing on her pretty eyes, the intensity between us kicks up a beat. She tries to look away. “Look at me,” I demand, and her attention comes right back. Her cheeks are pink, her lips are full and bee-stung from all the kissing. But her eyes tell me all I need to know. She still loves me. My heart races like mad because I know all my sacrifices have been worth it. She’s worth it all.

“Noah, I… Oh God,” she cries as her body convulses around my cock and wetness coats her toy, sliding all the way to her ass.

I slip the toy free and start to really move, my eyes not leaving her for a second. I want her to know how I feel about her. That she is the only girl for me and everything I’m doing is for her. I’ve been in love with this girl for years. She gazes back at me, sending tingles over my body, driving me crazy, and before I know it, I’m cumming in her ass.

I lower my head back to her, kissing her sweet lips as I rock, slowly filling her with my release. This, the closeness we share, is everything. I lace my hands with hers, and we stay like this for some time, foreheads resting against each other as our breathing settles. Eventually I pull out of her.

Our bodies go still and we fall silent. She snuggles tenderly into my side, satisfied and happy for the first time in so long. I hug her close into my body, not readyto let her go. I meant what I said earlier; a deal is a deal and she’s staying the night. I need her here with me.

“Noah.” Her body stiffens.

“What, baby?” I ask, concerned I’ve hurt her.

“There’s someone in my room,” she says, a fresh wave of panic in her voice.

I glance over toward her place, focusing on her bedroom as my euphoric haze vanishes in an instant. My blood goes cold. Sure enough, she’s right, there’s the light from a flashlight or phone shining as someone all in black walks through her room. “Stay here,” I demand, throwing on a pair of sweatpants and running down the stairs as quickly as I can.

“Noah, don’t, it’s not safe,” she calls after me. But I’m not worried about coming head-to-head with the intruder. They should be more worried about what I’m going to do to them.

I make it to her front door and find it ajar. What the fuck is going on? I take the stairs two at a time. No one in sight. By the time I shove open her bedroom door and flick on the light, it’s empty. Her normally perfect room is trashed. Whoever was here was looking for something and made a real mess trying to locate it. The window is wide open like they have jumped right out of it. I shove it closed. I glance back toward my place to see if I can find Paisley still in my bed, but she’s not. Panic floods through me. What if it was her they were looking for? I can’t stand the thought. I take off running back through her house.

As I get to my front door, I find her waiting for me with the door propped open. “Jesus, Paisley, you scared the shit out of me, I couldn’t see you. Why didn’t you stay in bed like I told you to?”

Her wide eyes meet mine. “Sorry, I wanted to make sure you were okay. Do I need to call the cops?” she whispers in a panic.

“Whoever broke into your place is gone now.” I sigh heavily, running a hand through my hair.

“I know, I saw him jump out my window when he heard you. Black hoody and dark jeans, but I couldn’t make out who it was.” She stares up at me, fear in her eyes. “Noah, why would someone break into my place?”

I take her arms and pull her into me, hugging her close, thanking God she was with me tonight, not home alone. “I’m not sure, but your room is trashed. They must have been after something of yours, nothing else in the house looks like it’s been touched.”

“I need to go see.” She pulls out of my hold on her and pushes past me.

I’m right behind her; there is no way I’m letting her go in there alone. “I’ll come with you.”

---