Page 51 of Hat Trick Daddies

“Oh no, you don’t come until we tell you to,” he tells her.

“Please, I need to,” she gasps, looking up at him.

“Not yet!” I groan at her from behind, my breath leaking out between gritted teeth. “Bend over, suck Tyler’s dick, baby.”

Ally obeys, bending over at the waist and eating my brother’s cock as I drive my own straight into her. We sigh and moan, feeling ourselves take full pleasure in Ally’s body. Her pussy and mouth both feel so good that it’s hard to decide where I want to come.

Normally, a threesome with a girl isn’t as organic as this one was; there’s usually a lot of planning, negotiating, talking.

This, what we have with Ally, it’s intuitive. There’s hardly any need to speak, we just move around naturally with one another,and with Ally being such a good listener, everything is flowing in the sexiest way imaginable.

Already I can feel the nervous excitement flooding my belly and telling me I’m about to cum. A few more pumps and I’m squeezing her hips, my legs shaking as my orgasm starts to wash over me.

“Come for me, Ally. Right now!”

She screams, muffled by the sound of my brother’s throbbing dick in her mouth. I hear him orgasm along with us, his light sighs and moans filling up the room with our own.

Ally gushes over me as she comes, and I growl with pleasure at being able to cause her to have that strong of an orgasm.

“Oh my God,” she gasps, pulling away from my brother’s cock, trembling with the force of the pleasure we just shared. I feel her pussy clenching around me still as the last bit of pleasure shudders through her.

“That was amazing, Doc,” I say to her, slipping out of her and helping her to stand upright again.

She looks so incredible, so freshly fucked, that I feel my cock already wanting a second round.

“That was…I don’t even know what it was except incredible,” Ally sighs, burying her face into my chest while my brother feels up her perfect ass from behind. “Seriously, if I had known that’s what it was going to be like…I would’ve jumped you guys the moment I walked in here.”

“Believe us,” Tyler says, “the feeling is mutual.”

“Really?” she asks, her cheeks red with excitement.

“Oh yes,” I chime in. “You’re the best we’ve ever had. Hands down. I honestly can’t believe that was your first threesome.”

“Threesome,” she echoes with a giggle, her hand pressed to her mouth. “I can’t believe that I did that with you guys. I’m not that kind of girl.”

“That kind of girl?” I repeat back, my brow lifted a little. “Sexy as hell? Adventurous? Generous? I think you are. I never doubted being with you would be fucking memorable as hell.”

She flushes at my praise and waves a hand as she starts to collect her clothing off the floor. “Gosh, you guys have no idea. I’ve always been the boring medical student. No one was ever interested in me.”

My brother and I exchange a look. “Somehow I doubt that very much,” he says, echoing my own thoughts perfectly.

She shakes her head again, pulling her hair back into a ponytail. “It’s true. I’ve always been…weird and nerdy.”

“Well, we don’t agree,” I say back as I start to get dressed myself.

“Would you consider…doing that again sometime?” Tyler asks her a bit tentatively. I glance at him. It’s rare to see my brother being anything less than totally sure of himself. Ally seems to bring something out in him that’s less secure, more vulnerable.

She looks at both of us for a moment, her expression serious. I think for a second that she might say no. Maybe she just wanted to give this a try, and now she’s not interested anymore. I hate how much that thought depresses me.

Suddenly, a grin spreads across her face. “Yeah,” she says, her voice clear in the small space. “Yeah, I think I would definitely like to do this again.”

CHAPTER FIFTEEN

Ally

The three ofus step out of my office, fully dressed, though my cheeks still burn with the heat of what just happened.

The rink is eerily quiet now as we make our way down the hallway. It’s long past closing time, and the lack of sound due to the power outage makes the building feel unnatural in its stillness.

---