Page 56 of Destroying Everleigh

We played a few more rounds of Never Have I Ever, before Amber got up to go find her friend to see if she wanted to play the next game. The couch was soft beneath my head and the alcohol was strong in my veins. I’d been here for a few hours now and got to make out with that Jocelyn chick, but apparently, she had a boyfriend and wouldn’t let me past second base.

When Amber returned with Everleigh, she was taking her spot back on Lucas’s lap. He leaned forward, brushing her dark hair behind her ear. “We need to talk later,” he said sternly.

“Oh, joy,” she retorted dryly with an eyeroll.

“You can’t sit on anyone’s lap for this game,” Amber said, crossing her arms over her chest. “It’s spin the bottle but with an adult twist to it.”

Everleigh, Crystal, and Allison all rose. Crystal sat between Kash and Ash, while Amber was tugging Evie by the wrist, forcing her between me and her. The heat from her body soaked into my skin from the tight fit, her leg brushing mine.

Colt leaned forward, placing an empty glass beer bottle on the coffee table.

“Rules?” Kash questioned.

“The rules are simple,” Colt replied. “If the bottle lands on you, you get to do whatever you want to that person for ten minutes straight.”

My eyebrows rose. We played something similar back at my old college, but it was more like a spin on seven minutes of heaven, and we got to sneak off to do it, not be watched the entire time.

“I’ll go first,” Colt offered. He leaned forward and spun the bottle. After a few spins, it landed on Crystal.

“What happens if it lands on the same gender?” Ashton inquired.

“You’re allowed to pass and re-spin if that happens,” Lucas said. “But you don’t have to.”

Allison frowned, watching her boyfriend get up, his gaze pinned on the blonde. She slowly rose, a tint of pink flushing her features. They sat down near the coffee table while Lucas started a timer on his phone. Colt wasted no time, grabbing her and kissing her harshly, like he’d been starving for it. Her hands fisted the front of his shirt, tugging him closer. Colt’s hand slipped beneath her dress, and she gasped out as he started fingering her right there.

“Holy shit,” Kash muttered with wide eyes as he glanced over at me. “People at this school don’t play around.”

Allison was seething, glaring daggers at her best friend and boyfriend going at it on the floor. Crystal’s moans echoed around the quiet area as he plunged his fingers in and out of her forcefully. After a few moments, he pushed her on her back and hitched her dress around her hips before burying his face in her pussy.

“You’ve gotta be fucking kidding me,” Allison growled.

“How many minutes are left?” My gaze darted to Lucas where he was busy watching the scene play out in front of him.

He glanced at his phone. “Seven minutes and eighteen seconds.”

Colt came up for air, her juices dripping down his chin. If it wasn’t Crystal, it might have been hot. But I hated that bitch. “I think I can get off in that amount of time.” He quickly undid his jeans before sliding on top of her and then plunged inside. Her back arched off the ground, her hands tearing through his hair. He fucked her ruthlessly, and right as the timer sounded, he stilled inside of her, his body shuddering with his release.

“Damn,” Lucas remarked. “That should be like some kind of record.”

Colt grinned before pulling out of her and then tucked himself back into his jeans, clearly proud of himself. He sat down in the chair, stretching his legs out in front of him likenothing had ever happened. The dude was ballsy for sure. Right in front of his girlfriend and everything.

The bottle was soon back in motion, twirling around on the coffee table. Next up was Allison and Lucas. This had to be good. A smirk tugged at my mouth and my gaze locked with Ashton’s who mirrored my expression.

Lucas stayed in his seat, letting her come to him. Colt pressed play on the timer right as Allison was climbing onto his lap. She leaned in, their lips locking immediately. His hands were on her hips as she moved back and forth across his dick, seeking out some kind of friction. I glanced over at Everleigh, who was watching with a bored expression, not seeming to give a shit in the slightest. Interesting.

Lucas started kissing down her neck, causing her dark hair to fall down her back as she moaned. He lifted her shirt, kissing up her stomach until he found her breast. He pushed her bra up and started tugging at her nipple with his teeth. She shuttered against him digging her sharp pointed nails into his shoulders.

It was weird seeing how open everyone was with their sexual desires. There was a couple having sex across the room for Christ’s sake. No one even batted an eye, like it was a completely normal occurrence.

Lucas and Allison continued to make out and feel up on one another, but it didn’t go any further than that. Probably because he was friends with Colt, but who the hell knows. Allison was hot with long light brown hair that tumbled down her back in waves, but he didn’t seem that interested in her. Maybe he only had eyes for Everleigh. I probably would, too, if she was my girl.

When the timer went off, Allison readjusted herself and found her seat again. The bottle was spinning soon after, stopping on me. My heart started racing and I leaned forward to spin the bottle again to see who I’d be paired with. After a few spins, it landed on Ashton.

We glanced at each other and burst into laughter, because hell no. We might have been best friends, but I was strictly a pussy kind of guy. And ass when it belonged to a female. No way was I kissing that asshole.

Spinning the bottle again, I watched as it moved around and around in circles before finally coming to a stop. My chest constricted painfully as I locked eyes with Everleigh, her face paling instantly.

“Pass,” we both said in unison.

---