Page 7 of Theirs to Keep

“She’s playing with us, man,” Jamison growled.

“She can do whatever she fucking wants as long as she doesn’t stop touching me like that. It feels so damn good, baby. Don’t stop.” She leaned forward, darting her tongue out to tease the tip of Ash’s cock and he growled his approval. Jamison watched as she sucked Ash into her mouth and softly cursed when she let him push deeper into her throat.

“You’re going to kill me, honey,” Jamison barked as she stroked his shaft. She released Ash’s cock from her mouth, letting her lips make a popping sound as they made their way over the head of his shaft. Ash groaned his displeasure at the loss of her mouth.

“Ash, you are going to have to share and play nice.” She smiled at him and stroked him, loving the way that he thrust into her hand, seeming to need more from her. She wanted to give him everything, but she was so new at all of this and well, there were two of them. She just hoped that she was doing everything right but judging from the looks of both men standing in front of her, she was doing just fine.

“Your turn, Jamison.” He thrust his needy cock into her hand as if pleading with her for more. She didn’t tease him like she had Ash. Jamison didn’t seem like the kind of man who liked to be teased. He seemed to want everything hard and fast and that was just fine with her. She sucked his cock into her mouth and moaned around him. He was a little bigger than Ash and she wasn’t sure that she could take him as deep, but she wanted to try.

“That’s right, honey,” Jamison rasped. “Take me deeper, breathe through your nose, and open your throat.” She listened to his instructions and tried to do as he asked, letting him take over was just what she needed to overcome her nerves. Hepraised her, pushing her further and asking her for more. She gave Jamison her full attention, wrapping both hands around his body to grasp his ample ass in her hands, allowing him to fuck her mouth. She knew that he was close when he wrapped his hands into her hair and angled her mouth around his cock, giving himself better access to her mouth. He came in hot spurts down her throat, and she swallowed everything that he gave her. After he was spent, he pulled from her swollen lips and dropped to his knees, pulling her in for a kiss. Jamison was so gentle and sweet that it almost reminded her of the way Ash kissed her.

“Thank you, honey—that was beautiful. You are so fucking gorgeous.” Jamison kissed her one more time and released her to Ash who pulled her up against his body.

“My turn, baby.” He kissed her with all the pent-up need and desire that she was feeling. Her body felt like it was on fire after Jamison got done with her. Ash nudged her back to the bed, and she sat on the edge. “Jamison is going to show you just how much he appreciated your blow job, honey. We are going to make you feel so good.” She wanted to protest, to tell Ash that she needed to take care of him too, but Jamison had his big hands on her knees, spreading her thighs apart, running his fingers through her needy pussy, and she lost the ability to focus.

“Yes,” she hissed. “I need more, please Jamison.” He chuckled at her pleading and dipped his head between her legs, licking and sucking her throbbing clit into his hot mouth.

“Fuck, she tastes as good as she looks,” Jamison growled, licking her back into his hot mouth.

“Has anyone ever eaten your pussy, baby?” Ash was breathing heavily beside her, kissing her neck and jaw, taking her lips in hot, wet kisses.

“No,” she stuttered as Ash made his way down her body, stopping to lick and bite her nipples. She couldn’t help the way her body thrashed, and bucked from the pleasure that they wereboth giving her. Ash settled on his knees next to Jamison and she propped herself up on her elbows to watch. Seeing the two of them lick and suck at her wet core together sent her over the edge. She screamed out her orgasm as it seemed to go on forever. Both men kissed their way back up her body and from the mischievous looks on both of their faces, they were just getting started with her.

Ashton

Ash wanted to claim her; he wanted to be her first but he was afraid to ask her for such a gift. He looked over to Jamison, silently pleading for permission to do what he wanted with Regan and his friend nodded and smiled.

“Regan, I want to be your first.” She opened her eyes, still coming down from her orgasm, and looked at him confused.

“I don’t understand, I thought both of you were going to be my first.” She looked between them and Ash wanted to laugh but he wasn’t sure that it would go over too well with her right now. He knew that she had to be feeling vulnerable and laughing at her might send her running back into her bathroom.

“We both can’t take your virginity, baby. Only one of us can do that.” Regan’s eyes widened, and she nodded as if she understood.

“Yes, Ash, I want you to be my first.” He took her agreement as a green light, but he needed to tell his anxious dick to slow the fuck down. The last thing he wanted to do was hurt her. Watching her suck Jamison’s dick just about made him blow his wad. Jamison was right, she was a natural submissive, so eager to please them both. His friend hadn’t gone easy on her evenknowing that it was her first time, he took what he wanted from her and Regan handled it beautifully. God, when she swallowed down everything that Jamison pumped into her sultry little mouth and then licked him clean, Ash wanted to pull her in front of him to take his turn, but he wasn’t a greedy bastard.

Ash pulled Regan onto his lap holding her luscious, curvy ass in his hands, and kissed her senseless. Her wet, hot folds slid over his cock as she rubbed her pussy on his lap. He knew that he wasn’t going to be able to last long, especially after tasting her. He nudged the head of his cock into her opening, and she gasped as he started to fill her, inch by excruciating inch. Jamison filed in behind her, supporting her with his big body, holding her between the two of them. It wouldn’t be long before they gave her what she wanted, both of them in her at once. But her first time needed to be special, not two cavemen taking what they wanted from her.

“That’s it, honey. Just relax and let Ash in.” Jamison’s big hands covered Regan’s breasts as he plucked her puckered nipples. She moaned at the sensation, wiggling and writhing against Ash’s cock. Finally, he couldn’t take it anymore and he thrust balls deep into Regan’s tight pussy. She cried out and froze against him, making him feel like a complete ass. This was the first time that he had taken anyone’s virginity, and he was beginning to think that maybe he should have given Jamison the honors. Knowing his friend, he wouldn’t have been any gentler at deflowering their girl.

“Regan, tell us that you are okay.” Jamison wrapped his arms around her and Ash was doing everything in his power not to move until she was ready. Minutes ticked by, feeling as if an eternity had passed, and finally, she smiled down at Ash letting him know that she was all right.

“It’s fine, Ash,” Regan whispered. “Don’t look so serious, it’s just sex.” Jamison bit down on her shoulder, releasing her from his arms.

“It is not just sex, baby. This is—well, it just feels like more,” Ash rasped. She nodded her head and moved her hips, letting him know that she was ready for more. Ash sat up and pulled her into his arms, kissing her hard, thrusting his tongue into her mouth. He moved slowly at first but then set a punishing pace, thrusting balls deep and pulling almost completely out of her slick pussy. He looked past Regan to where Jamison watched the two of them. His best friend was stroking his cock and Ash could tell by the hungry look in his eyes that he wanted more.

“Help her Jamison, I want her with me. I won’t last too much longer.” Jamison settled behind Regan again and snaked his hand down her body to rub her clit. Regan turned just enough to be able to kiss Jamison as he plucked her nipples and circled her clit. Ash had always loved to watch the other women that they shared with Jamison but with Regan, it felt like so much more. They were claiming her, making her theirs. She shouted out both of their names as she found her release and Ash quickly followed her over, thrusting deep into her spasming core, spilling himself inside of her.

Regan

Regan woke up just before dawn, wrapped up in arms and legs between her two men. They made love to her all night long, both taking turns and sharing her body and she couldn’t seem to get enough of the way that they needed her. She felt the same way about them both and that scared the living shit out of her. The one thing that she learned from her mother’s tumultuous relationships with men was not to lose your heart. Regan knew that it had only been a day since she rode into town to find them both, but she was afraid that she was quickly developing feelings for each of them.

She decided to get up and shower, wanting to make them breakfast before they had to head out to work for the day. She could only imagine how hard farming was, they would both need a big breakfast after the night that they all had together.

Regan made her way down to the kitchen and started looking through cabinets trying to acquaint herself with their set up. The guys didn’t have any method to their madness, just piling dishes and kitchen gadgets with no thought as to usefulness. She might have grown up with nothing but working in Pete’s diner taught her that everything had a place in a well-run kitchen.She decided that after she made them breakfast, she would re-arrange the kitchen and then find her way to a grocery store and stock up for the week. She needed to go through the pantry and make a list before heading out. Sighing, she pulled out a griddle and found a mixing bowl to make the pancakes in. Regan was pleased to find all the fixings that she needed for pancakes and bacon, which Jamison ordered for breakfast.

She whisked the pancake mix, smiling to herself at just how much Jamison liked to order her around. He was bossy both in and out of the bedroom and she loved the way he took charge. Ash even seemed to like the way Jamison took the lead although, he was almost as bossy as his best friend.

Regan put the bacon on a baking tray and put it in the oven, a little trick that Pete taught her. He was the only person that she missed from back home. Last night, after she unpacked she sent him a quick text to let Pete know that she was safe and found a good job. She told him that she was going to be cooking at a farm in the South but decided to leave out the sordid details about her sexy new bosses. She wasn’t sure how to explain them anyway, especially now that she slept with them both after only knowing them for a few hours.

---