Page 6 of Theirs to Keep

“We both want you, baby.” Ash purred, running his hands up her body to cup her full breasts. She moaned and leaned back against Ash’s body. Jamison didn’t want to wait a moment longer to taste her. He dropped to his knees and spread her legs apart and Ash wrapped his arms around her body, for support.She whimpered, looking down at him and he just about lost all his tightly held control.

“Fuck, she’s already so wet for us, Ash.” He let two fingers slide through her wet folds causing her whole body to buck. “You like that don’t you, honey?” Jamison kissed his way up Regan’s thighs and stopped just short of licking her throbbing clit into his mouth. Every instinct in his body was telling him to take her and make her theirs but her being a virgin changed the game. They both needed to remember that this was her first time.

Regan groaned in frustration as he removed his fingers from her hot core and stood to face her. “We’re going to take this nice and slow, honey. Ash and I want your first time to be everything that you ever dreamed it could be.” Jamison took her mouth in a hard, punishing kiss, leaving her breathless. He could see her desire and raw need as she panted for air. He was pretty sure that if Ash released their pretty, little girl that she would claw her way onto him and take what she wanted.

“Easy, honey. We’ll get there,” Jamison promised. He stroked her face and pulled her into his arms, turning her to face Ash. He watched as Regan wrapped her arms around Ash’s neck and pulled him down for a kiss. She wasn’t shy about taking what she wanted but they needed more. They needed her to tell them what she wanted, otherwise, this wouldn’t work.

“Tell us what you want us to do with you, honey,” Jamison ordered, and Regan stilled in Ash’s arms. He knew that she was too caught up in the moment and he needed to make sure that she wanted everything that they were going to do to her.

“Um—” she squeaked. One-syllable answers weren’t going to work for him, he needed to know that she was with them every step of the way. He swatted her curvy ass, running his fingers down the seam to her hot core. She moaned and pushed back against his hand, letting him in deeper.

Ash smiled down at her seeming to know what Jamison was after. “He needs to know that you want what we are going to give you. What do you want us to do with you, baby?” Ash pinched her pebbled nipple, and Jamison felt a rush of wetness coat his already slick fingers. Regan was so responsive to them; she was going to be incredible, and they were just getting started.

Regan

She was trapped between the two of them, her breath hitched in anticipation making her whole body shiver. “I think our little girl wants to play.” Jamison’s raspy voice felt like it touched every erotic zone of her overly sensitive body. Her nipples pebbled and she felt a new wave of wetness between her legs.

“Is he right, Regan?” Ash asked. She nodded, not trusting that she could make the words form in her mouth. “No baby, we need to hear you say it. Do you want both of us touching you, licking you, fucking you?” She moaned at Ash’s words, closing her eyes, and throwing her head back waiting for them to do all those things to her. Instead, they both backed away from her body leaving her longing and confused.

Her eyes fluttered open and she found them both standing in front of her smirking. Her anger flared, “What the hell, guys? You got me worked up for what—to make fun of me?” Tears stung her eyes, and she tried to hold them back, to no avail.

“Fuck,” Ash said, pulling her into his arms. “We didn’t mean to make you cry, baby. Please don’t, I can’t stand to see you upset like this.” She rubbed her face into his hard chest, needing contact, and sniffled. This was so unlike her, crying at the dropof a hat. She was never a crybaby but these two men both seemed to wring out every emotion that she had in her.

Jamison crowded up against her back, wrapping his arms around her and pulling her into his big body. “Don’t cry, Regan. We weren’t teasing you, honey. We just wanted to make sure that you were with us. We need to hear you say the words, tell us what you want.”

She let her head fall back against Jamison’s shoulder, “I want you both.” She slid her hands up to her face trying to hide from them. It felt like agony sorting out her feelings for them. She wanted them both and that made her feel as though something was wrong with her. What kind of woman wanted two men at once? Regan felt like she was asking too much from life, being too greedy wanting them both. There was no way she’d be able to choose between the two of them, not now. Not when they were offering her everything that she ever dreamed of. Honesty was her only path now.

“I’m so sorry,” she sobbed from behind her hands. “I know that I’m asking too much but I don’t think that I can choose between the two of you.” Ash’s chuckle had her peeking out through her fingers.

“If you can’t tell by now, baby, we are more than fine with sharing you. We’ve come to an understanding. Jamison and I are willing to share because neither one of us is willing to walk away from you.” Ash gently kissed her lips, and she melted against him, pressing her hands into his pecks.

Jamison moaned from behind her, turning her to face him as soon as Ash was finished kissing her. “He’s right, honey, we want to share you—we prefer it that way. I’m not saying it’s going to be a cakewalk, but we’ll work things out as we go.” He pulled her into his body, his fingers digging into her hips, leaving their mark. He took her mouth in a hot, passionate kiss that would leave her lips swollen. She loved the contrast between the twomen. Ash seemed so gentle and loving while Jamison took what he wanted from her, leaving her hot and needy.

“Tell us what you want us to do to you, baby.” Ash pulled her back against his body and cupped her breast, tugging her sensitive nipples. Jamison was kissing her senseless, rubbing his hard cock against her belly. How they expected her to be able to put two syllables together was beyond her.

Jamison broke their kiss, leaving them both breathless. “We need the words, honey. What will it be?” He bobbed his eyebrows making her giggle. “What should we do with you and this sexy little body of yours?”

Regan took a deep breath and exhaled, trying to collect her thoughts. The two of them together threw her off her game. “I’d like to know what it feels like to have you both in me, you know, at the same time.” Ash moaned from behind her and rubbed his erection against her ass.

Well, at least he seemed to like her idea. Jamison just stood in front of her, staring down as if he had lost the ability to speak. He cleared his throat, “You mean, you want one of us in that hot, sassy mouth of yours and the other in your pussy?” His brown eyes grew darker, and she knew that he was turned on. She pulled him down to kiss his mouth with just as much passion as he had given her moments earlier.

“Yes,” she sighed against his lips. “I want that and more.” Jamison closed his eyes as if trying to find his control. Ash turned her to face him softly kissing her lips and down her throat.

“Do you want us in your ass, baby,” Ash asked, licking a path to her breasts. She moaned when he sucked one of her nipples into his hot mouth and then bit down lightly.

“Yes,” she hissed. “I want you in my ass, I want you to fill all of my holes,” Regan moaned. Jamison guided them over to the bed and pulled her and Ash down with him.

“We want you so much, baby. Do you feel how hard you make us?” Both men were rubbing against her, but she wanted more. She wanted them naked and inside of her.

“I need you both. I need more,” she panted. Their hands were roaming all over her body, tugging and pulling, giving her so much pleasure.

“We are going to take good care of you, honey,” Jamison growled. “Since this is your first time we are going to take this nice and slow. We’ll get to filling up all your lovely holes before you know it. Tonight, it’s all about you, Regan.” She couldn’t control her shiver at his promise.

She watched as both men stood before her, leaving her panting on the edge of her bed. They slowly removed their t-shirts and all she wanted to do was run her hands over their hard, muscular bodies. Ash pulled down his shorts, letting his erection spring free and she licked her lips at the memory of having him in her mouth, just moments ago. She wanted to taste him again, taste them both. Jamison undid the button on his jeans and slowly pulled down the zipper, garnering her full attention. It was like unwrapping a present, the anticipation was killing her. He stood next to Ash after shucking out of his jeans. They both stroked their cocks, watching for her to make the next move. She knew that they wanted her to ask for what she wanted but she needed to show them rather than tell them what she wanted from them.

She dropped to her knees in front of them both and ran her hands over their jutting erections. She marveled at how hard and smooth they felt, trailing her fingers over the tips of their cocks and back down to cup their balls. Both men groaned and she giggled, heady with power.

“Now boys, I’m going to need you to tell me what you want.” She smiled up at them and sat back on her knees, waiting forthem to be able to verbalize all the need that she saw on their faces.

---