Page 13 of Theirs to Keep

“Please make love to me, Jamison. I want you and I don’t care about some stupid age difference.” She looked up at him, silently begging him to give her everything that she was asking for.

“Honey, I need you to be sure. I won’t keep doing this to myself or you if you are just going to change your mind. Be sure, Regan.” She knew what he was asking; he wanted a guarantee that she wasn’t going to disappear and leave them both. Her heart melted a little knowing that he wasn’t just asking for himself but for Ash, tore down her defenses and made her want to agree to everything that he was asking.

“I’m not going anywhere, Jamison. I won’t do that to either of you. I’m here to stay if you’ll have me.” Jamison lifted her against his body, cupping her face with his big hands, he took her mouth in a passionate kiss. She had never been kissed the way that Jamison kissed her, almost like he wanted to eat her alive.

He broke their kiss, leaving them both breathless. “Ash can’t take you leaving, honey and I’m not sure that I can either. It would destroy him.” Regan nodded. She knew just how much her leaving would hurt Ash, especially now that she knew how his mother left him when he was little.

“He told me about his mother, Jamison. I would never do that to Ash or you. Just let me in, let me show you that the three of us can be good together.” Jamison growled lifting her into his arms and settling with her on the bed. She loved the feel of the weight of his body on top of hers. He kissed his way from her lips down her neck and she shivered from the cold where his lips left her bare skin.

Jamison stopped halfway down her neck. “What about Ash—does he know you are here with me?”

Regan nodded, “Yes, he gave me pointers,” she giggled. “He told me that failing wasn’t an option, and I have to say that I agree with him. I know that we all just met, and we’ve only spent a couple of days in each other’s lives, but I feel this crazy connection with both of you. I can’t explain it.”

Jamison rolled over, pulling Regan on top of him. “I know what you mean, honey. I feel the same way and I don’t want to speak for Ash but I’m pretty sure he does too.”

“I do,” Ash said, standing in the doorway. Regan and Jamison both turned to see that he had showered and wrapped a towel around his waist. “I didn’t want to say anything earlier not knowing how Jamison felt about you.” Regan twisted in Jamison’s arms reaching out her hand for Ash to join them in bed. He leaned in to kiss her and released her back to Jamison. Ash sat in the corner chair smiling at both of them. “I’d like for the three of us to try to make this work, you know—see where it goes.” Ash leaned back making himself comfortable in Jamison’s chair.

Jamison sat up in bed letting Regan straddle his lap. “What do you think, honey? You want to give this a shot and see where we end up?” She smiled at both men and nodded her head.

“More than anything,” she said. Regan giggled when Jamison palmed her ass, giving it one hard smack.

“Well, Jamison, I think that you should fuck our girl while I watch from over here.” Ash reached down to release his towel, stroking his long shaft. Regan looked at Jamison, not quite sure what to do. She knew that she wanted both of them, but she didn’t know if she was ready to take both men at the same time.

Jamison thrust into her hard and deep, not giving her much time to adjust to his size. She loved the way that he took her body as if he couldn’t wait another minute to be inside her. “Fuck, she’s tight and so wet,” Jamison growled looking in Ash’s direction.

Ash stood as if he couldn’t just watch the two of them any longer. “I changed my mind, honey.” Regan’s heart dropped at Ash’s words. He moved to stand behind her and ran his hands over her puckered nipples, tugging and pulling at them while she rode Jamison’s cock.

“Fuck that’s hot,” Ash hissed.

Jamison nodded, “Yeah, but I think our girl thought that you were telling her you changed your mind about her. Maybe some punishment is in order for doubting what we said earlier.” Jamison pumped into her thrusting harder and harder each time. She wanted to come but every time she got close they both backed off.

“Guys, I need to come,” Regan begged. Both men chuckled as if they weren’t letting her in on the joke.

“We know what you need, baby. You just need to trust us to give it to you. Do you trust us, Regan?” Ash asked. She nodded her head, letting it fall back against Ash as he continued to play with her sensitive nipples.

“Say the words, honey,” Jamison growled.

“I trust both of you. You will give me what I need, please Jamison.” He pumped into her harder and faster while Ash rubbed his erection against her back, playing with her breasts.

“Come now, honey. We want to watch you come undone for us,” Jamison commanded. Regan rode out her orgasm and before she was finished Jamison was spilling his seed into her core and Ash’s hot release coated her back. Both men pulled her in for kisses, praising her for trusting them and being just who they had been waiting for. She had never felt so wanted and safe in her whole life. Jamison and Ash had given her more than she ever dreamt possible and so much more than she ever dared to hope for.

Ashton

Ash got a warm washcloth from Jamison’s bathroom and cleaned his release from Regan’s back. He couldn’t wait for the day that they would both be able to take Regan together. He didn’t want to push her, but he knew that Jamison would feel the same way. She mentioned that she wanted them both in her at the same time, last night. Still, he felt like a first-class asshole for asking.

“Baby, we want to start training that sexy little ass of yours, do you still want that?” Regan looked at Ash as if she didn’t understand a word of what he just said. Of course, she didn’t. Up until last night, she was a virgin. Now, he wanted to train her virgin ass and convince her it was a normal thing to do.

Jamison laughed pulling Regan back against his body to kiss her shoulder. “Honey, you said that you want us in all of your holes.” Regan shyly nodded against him, her cheeks turning an adorable shade of pink. “Well, we have to prepare your sexy little ass, so we won’t hurt you.” Again, she just nodded and smiled up at Ash, taking his breath away.

“You are so fucking beautiful, baby. I can’t wait for both of us to be able to take you together. I want to make you ours, Regan,” Ash growled.

“I want that too, both of you. I’m already yours, Ash. I’m not going anywhere.” Regan snuggled into Jamison’s arms holding her own open for Ash to join them. He didn’t need to be asked twice, he jumped into bed and pulled Regan into his arms, kissing her until she sighed into his mouth. He loved that she seemed to be content with them and their arrangement. He didn’t want to get his hopes up at her promise that she was already theirs, but he couldn’t help himself. He was falling for Regan and he sure as fuck hoped that she felt the same.

“Since I fucked up our plans for tonight, how about we go out for dinner tomorrow night?” Jamison asked, surprising them both. Ash knew that going into town and listening to all the gossip circulating around them was the last thing that Jamison would want. Especially after Regan’s run-in with Katie earlier. But he was thankful that his friend was willing to work at wooing their girl. Regan had shared a little about herself and her upbringing. Ash knew that she didn’t have it easy, especially after her mom died leaving her with that asshole stepfather of hers. Every time he thought of that asshole even laying a finger on Regan he wanted to punch something or better yet, someone. Regan needed to be shown that good guys did exist and that they knew how to treat a woman. Taking her out on a real date was just what she needed and screw anyone in town that might give them a hard time about their sleeping arrangements.

Regan hesitated and Ash knew that she was thinking about other people in town giving her as hard a time as Katie had.

“I’m not sure that is such a great idea, Jamison,” she whispered. “What if we run into Katie or someone else in town and they figure out that the three of us are together?”

---